Benches Vintage and obsolete

5

VERY slow iBook

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

A couple of months ago, I had a computer tsunami: the HD in my iBook died, the external HD for this computer died (just put it in a new case - hope it works!), and the motherboard on my PowerBook would only read one stick of memory, regardless of which stick was in which slot. I bought a new iMac.

I still needed a 2nd computer, so since the PowerBook had a year old new HD in it, and since I was assured at the Apple store that it would also work in my iBook, this week I paid a Mac repair person (I've used him before) to move the good HD from the PowerBook to the iBook. He did this and I picked it up today.

First of all, there is something funky with my keyboard - shift key is irratic. Second, even though it now has a 1 gig stick in addition to the 256 that is on it (RAM from the PB and the iBook are interchangeable), it is slow as molasses.

What on earth could have happened? I hate to take this elsewhere and spend still more money on a 6 yr old computer, but I need this. I had upgraded the OS on the PB to Leopard, but intend to erase the HD and use the bootable external HD which has Tiger on it to install this on my iBook - I very badly need a couple of Classic programs/data bases that are on Tiger on this HD.

I think I just keep throwing good money after bad.

5 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thatch,
    Need to know exactly which iBook we're talking about (CPU speed and screen size) and probably the PowerBook as well.

    ..I paid a Mac repair person (I've used him before) to move the good HD from the PowerBook to the iBook.

    Did he think this would work?

    He did this and I picked it up today.

    First of all, there is something funky with my keyboard - shift key is irratic.
    Is the keyboard plugged in correctly? Does an external keyboard work better?
    Second, even though it now has a 1 gig stick in addition to the 256 that is on it (RAM from the PB and the iBook are interchangeable), it is slow as molasses.
    I don't think you can judge w/o installing the OS in situ in the iBook. Do that and report back.
    Richard

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Well, I've had one disaster after another. I had taken my dead external HD out of its enclosure and put it in a new one I purchased (yes, it was the proper enclosure). I plugged it into my iMac, and it mounted nicely. That's when I made my 1st HUGE mistake: I should have immediately dragged all my Classic stuff of it and burned it to a back-up DVD. It was working and I was dumb.

    I tried to boot up my iBook with its new HD using the external drive but it would not boot. So I took it to my local Apple store. They decided that we should erase the HD on the iBook and then migrate from the bootable external HD. So they took it in the back and erased it, brought it out, and hooked it up. I decided to stay there with it to be sure this worked. THREE HOURS later, we realized it had hung at the very end, but worse than that, the external HD was now VERY hot. We let it cool down, tried to boot up my iBook using one of the HD's, and ran Disk Utility. It would work for a while and then it wouldn't. Again, we tried to boot it up, but this time using my external HD - wouldn't work.

    They told me to leave it there - the buy said he'd mess with it and for me to come back today. I went back this afternoon, and he told me my external HD was now melted and dead but that he'd installed Tiger (this is what I wanted on the iBook) and it was working fine. The store was mobbed so I brought everything home.

    At home, I tried to start my iBook - would get to the Apple but no spinning wheel. I tried booting up using my Tiger disk - after several attempts, this worked. I ran "repair disk" and it said the disk was fine. I tried to "repair permissions" and it hung. I restarted it and this time it said my HD would not mount.

    I've lost some VERY valuable data on that external HD. No, it was my only back-up - I have nothing else. It has a recipe program where all my family heirloom recipes are entered and 40 years of recipes I've clipped. No - there is no hard copy - my plan had been when this was up and running, to print out all the recipes so I would have hard copy.

    I've now wasted nearly $200 and no longer have a PB that works (took the HD out of it and put it in the iBook), and no longer have a working external HD.

    Oh - did I mention that a local Mac computer store had told me that the reason my PB was only showing memory working in one slot was a fault in the motherboard - not the sticks of ram or the slots. That's why I took out the HD and put it in the iBook. Now the Apple store tells me that one of the PB's slots was faulty, not the motherboard.

    Agggghhhhh!!!!!

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thatch,

    I should have immediately dragged all my Classic stuff of it and burned it to a back-up DVD.

    Yup anytime you're in a situation like this and you get to see your stuff you should immediately back up. I've got about 20 backup drives in my shop here so I've got backups and backups.

    They told me to leave it there - the buy said he'd mess with it and for me to come back today.

    Hmm well I'd never leave my.."red stapler"...

    he told me my external HD was now melted and dead

    Now I don't really know about this guy. Is that external bad?

    I had taken my dead external HD out of its enclosure

    So it was dead? or the enclosure was dead?

    I have nothing else. It has a recipe program where all my family heirloom recipes are entered and 40 years of recipes I've clipped.

    Will that drive spin up? If it will look at Data Rescue 3.
    If not you could have a pro service do it. Used to be very expensive but now a lot cheaper.
    These are all Apple Stores you're dealing with?
    Richard

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The saga continues. During the night (not sleeping - worrying about that lost recipe program and files), I got to thinking about the original diagnosis. Two places told me that what was happening was indicative of a HD failure. I began to wonder if it was not the logic board instead, and that was why the new HD would not work properly.

    So, today I took it to yet another Mac repair place. I asked them to check the HD that was REMOVED from my iBook - the one that was thought to be dead. I also asked them if they actually got it to mount, to immediately burn the recipe program and files to a CD. Guess what - it worked just fine!

    So I spend $135 moving a HD from my PB to my iBook when it was not the HD that was the problem. Now, I will have the HD moved back to the PB and just live with the bad slot (too expensive to repair). I will use the HD out of the iBook to move all my files to the PB. When that is done, I will then print, print, print like mad until I have hard copy of all those recipes. I will also burn a CD of the other things on the HD and try to get them into software that is Snow Leopard compatible so that when there is no more Tiger I will not be left in the lurch.

    I'm very angry at myself as my first thought when the iBook started giving me trouble, was the logic board as I knew that era of iBooks had some serious logic board problems. I allowed the "experts" to overrule my instincts. One would think that by age 66, I would have learned to trust my instincts (which tend to be VERY good!), and stand my ground.

    Perhaps by 70....

  5. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thatchcote,

    I also asked them if they actually got it to mount, to immediately burn the recipe program and files to a CD. Guess what - it worked just fine!

    Yah! Glad it worked out.

    I allowed the "experts" to overrule my instincts

    Well work with different "experts". Y'know there are Mac places and then there are Mac places.
    You know when you said this:

    They told me to leave it there - the buy said he'd mess with it and for me to come back today.

    That didn't sound good.

    I went back this afternoon, and he told me my external HD was now melted and dead

    That confirmed that you should have just walked out in the first place.

    I've now wasted nearly $200

    So they did all this and then charged you! What __lls!
    Well anyway don't go back there or perhaps talk to the manager about getting your money back.
    BTW what do you plan to do w/ the iBook? I repair and donate them into the inner city here in Chicago.
    Anyway glad you got those recipes off safely.
    Richard