Benches / Vintage and obsolete
Pages 09 initial impressions
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I've used Pages 09 for a couple of weeks now, on simple WP documents and editing our newsletter template and it seemed more polished than 08. Today I created a template with lots of tables for a report, and I gotta say wow. Up until 09 I avoided using Pages for anything with tables as the feature seemed unpolished and unpredictable. Pages 09 changes all that. Manipulating tables and customizing and formating cells (even cell by cell) worked flawlessly. It reminded me of what to-date IMHO was the best implementations of tables in a mac word processor, the old World Perfect (although I still miss "view code"). Anyway, Pages has come a long way. v. 1 was utterly unusable even on the fastest systems, v. 2 looked a little tempting, v. 3 was polished enough that I moved some of our simpler page layout stuff from quark (although it was still wanting in terms of a serious word processor), v. 4 seems pretty much ready for prime-time.
As for Keynote, it's been there for years and numbers.... Haven't used v. 2 yet, but v. 1 was ... more proof of concept then anything else. What are others thoughts?
14 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Love the features, hate the performance (1.67GHz PowerBook, 2.0 GHz PowerMac G5).
One of my favorite features is when grammar checking is enabled, mouse over a green underlined word (or phrase) and a pop-up either tells you what's incorrect or recommends a better word choice. Very cool.
Both Pages and Numbers now handle pasting HTML tables. In '08, neither handled HTML tables at all, with Numbers being the worst (the entire table would be pasted into a single cell). Now, copy an HTML table from Safari and paste it into numbers, and voila! your table is now a spreadsheet. Very, very cool.
Full screen editing is nice, but not a must-have for me. Not having split screens in Pages or Numbers is a disappointment (maybe in iWork '10 or '11?). But by far the single issue keeping me from buying the product (I've been using the trial) is how Pages '09 stalls and stutters when scrolling a document with tables. The same document scrolls smooth as silk (as one person commented) in Pages '08 (and, for that matter, Word v.x), but in '09 it's literally painful trying to scroll.
As soon as Apple fixes the scrolling, I will order iWork '09.
-D
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Friends,
I bought iWorks™ 09 instead of upgrading to the new Office™ for Macs.
On my first document in Pages™, I found it lacked a basic text sort tool.
Based on responses to my questions in this forum, I am advised that I need to use a third party's tools to make Pages™ useful to me.
I will not depend on a third party for essential functions of anyone's software.
I removed iWorks™ 09 from my laptop this morning, took it back to my university computer store, and bought the new Office™.
MQP - 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
i'm new to mac but found numbers pretty intuitive- 09 is much better than 08 but still has some things that need worked on- like when you enter a date and auto fill down- it automatically advances a day a time down the page- you have to enter 2 dates and then autofill down in order to keep the same date the whole way down the page. also - there needs to be a better help section on formulas.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
This won't help you, but I don't see any performance issue on any of the intel Macs I'm running it on. (yes it's a family pack). The only powerpc I have reverted to 10.4 because leopard had too many performance issues on it (iBook - 1.42 icebook) so it won't run on it. I also have office and use it when I need it primarily for excel or integration with excel.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Regarding getting better help with formulas ... check out this pdf dedicated to formulas and functions:
http://manuals.info.apple.com/enUS/Formulas_and_Functions_UserGuide.pdf - 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm shocked that they took it back!
But you gotta love educational pricing - especially for Office. We get the whole package for $19. A special campus program we have with MS.
Having said that, I'm trying to move over to Pages. I haven't used 09 enough to tell whether past problems I had with it have improved. I do have the new Office, and brother, some of the changes to Word are so bad that I'm even more rushed to dump it in favor of Pages 09.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
MQP
You are being absolutely silly on this.
Services are exactly what they say they are, services to your computer, and are especially useful because they are universally available, even in Finder to change file/folder names.
You have no problem if the change case function was found in another menu in Pages, but refuse to touch it if it appears under the Application's menu!
You realise that by installing MsOffice on your computer you are altering it from its "as bought" state?
You have had to "depend on a third party for essential functions" on your Mac.
…and it will not let you change case on your Mac, outside of MsOffice!
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
mpq writes, "I removed iWorks™ 09 from my laptop this morning, took it back to my university computer store, and bought the new Office™."
Oops. One of those rash steps we usually regret later. MS Word is a great tool along side Pages, but I couldn't imagine not having Pages! Usually I sort text in Numbers (or Excel). Its sometimes an issue of which tool you are using and what you need it for. Perhaps that would not work in your application.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Friends, pvonk, PeterBreis, and wr,
Thank you all for your thoughtful responses.I agree that I am silly and acting rashly.
I also acknowledge that I may tolerate the new Word no better than the new Pages.My computer experience began with the Control Data 1604 in 1959.
Since then, I have used IBM and CDC mainframes, midi’s, and most of the flavors of modern personal computers.These experiences led to three rules of thumb.
1. Standardize workflow.
Once I use applications that allow me to efficiently and accurately handle data and write reports, I change only to improve workflow.2. Reject incomplete software.
If the software misses any one basic tool, I expect to find other deficiencies. Why look for trouble?3. Avoid third party solutions.
Back in the day, I needed outside programs to extend the functions of word processing programs. None of those vendors remains in the market.I look forward to Pages 10.
MQP
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi Brian.
Thanks for the reply. I've heard from other (non-Apple) contributors that iWork was probably optimized for Intel.
Furthermore, Office '08 is slower than '04 on PowerPC Macs, so I've decided against Office 2008.
For now, I am using Pages '08 and Work v.x (2001) and both work fine. If Apple fixes the performance issues on PowerPC Macs, then I'll pick up a copy (a family pack, even).
iWork should run on 10.4, but perhaps your iBook doesn't meet iWork's other system requirements?
-D
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Well, I don't quite go back to the '50s when I started my computing experience, but I did start before the microcomputer era.
I've worked in a number of operating systems (mini computers on down) and if you've ever worked a lot in UNIX, you know that the culture there is not to have one app that does it all. Instead you have a lot of small, efficient "tools" that can be linked together to perform an overall task. Let's see, OSX is... well, it is UNIX, so I suppose some of that culture exists in the Apple world. That fact that we have "services" that link external utilities to main applications is testament to that mindset and for many people, software providers included, leaving some tasks to these utilities is not that unusual.
The suggestions in this thread to use an external application should not be considered an unacceptable solution.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
2. Reject incomplete software.
If the software misses any one basic tool, I expect to find other deficiencies. Why look for trouble?As a programmer my philosophy is exactly the opposite. Instead of a swiss army knife, I own a serrated knife, a scalpel, a spoon, and a magnifying glass. My toolkit may be more bulky but each tool is fully usable since no compromises were made to make the tools fit into the small package.
Your Microsoft Office does it all, no doubt about it but you've substituted a well designed and balanced program for a bloated program that as much flash as it does substance. I say this not just as a programmer but a certified Microsoft Office trainer. Word isn't a bad program - it just isn't a very good program.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
It's really nice that the dev team is listening to user requests. The full screen mode is great however the spell checker needs more work. Depending on what word has been typed wrong you can sometimes get a really long list of suggestions in the context menu. This is definitely a problem because you end up having to scroll down in a context menu. It would be much better if they limit the number of suggestions to something reasonable and if you want more then click a button or something. Also the transition from full screen to regular mode and back is kind of slow.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Friends,
I agree completely with pvonk and dwb about the use and importance of outside tools. Completely!
I apologize for my lack of clarity.
I attempted to distinguish between two type of outside tools.
Outside tools required for Pages 09 to accomplish its primary function
Versus
Outside tools that extend the function of Pages 09.If Pages 09 requires outside vendors to supply a basic tool, I am at the mercy of the business fortune of the outside vendor.
My rules of thumb have to do with small business stability as well as computing issues. These rules apply to my experience and I do not suggest they generalize to others.
I run many applications outside of Word on my text files, and then return to Word to finish. If the support for the outside applications vanishes, as has happened before, I can still get the basic job done in Word.
In contrast, I cannot get my basic job done in Pages 09, so if the outside support vanishes, I cannot return to Pages 09 and continue working.
If I were satisfied with Word, I would have ignored Pages 09.
When Pages 09 supplies me with tools basic to my use, I will adopt it, but until then, I am stuck with Word.MQP