Benches Vintage and obsolete

6

Has my hard drive failed, and if so can I repla...

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Can someone help me, please? I believe my hard drive has failed (or is about to) and needs replacing. Problem is I took my laptop (Powerbook G4, 15" 1.5GHz 512MB 80G Sdrv APX, recently upgraded to OS10.5) to our local official Apple Store to be serviced when this problem first became apparent. They returned the laptop two weeks later saying it had now been fixed using Disk Warrior, and was working fine – no charge as I bought the laptop there originally.

Great! Took it home, booted up OK first time, worked as it should for a few hours, then shut down unexpectedly. I have tried to revive it several times now, and all I get when I power up is the chimes, then a grey screen for several minutes followed by the dreaded flashing folder with a question mark, which I understand to mean it can't find a bootable system folder.

The background: Problems began when computer shut itself down during sleep (energy saver set to sleep after a time as is normal). I have a LaCie Little Book 320G connected by firewire, using Time Machine to make regular backups. The problem seems to relate to the laptop going into sleep mode after the alloted time and in some way this seems to make the Little Book think it has been ejected incorrectly, and puts up a warning message. Sometimes it is unavoidable to have to leave the laptop, with the Little Book connected, powered up and downloading (eg. podcasts) overnight. When I get back to the laptop in the morning it appears to be in sleep mode (which I would expect) but has in fact shutdown and is frozen. It has to be restarted with the power button, and even this doesn't work first time every time.

This happened regularly over a couple of weeks and I recall hearing a whir from the hard drive, which I'd never noticed before. Eventually the whir developed a few clunks and stopped and started intermittently. At the same time I got the chimes, followed by a grey screen for several minutes followed by the dreaded flashing folder with a question mark.

So what I need to know is does this sound like I need a new hard drive (what else can it be?), and can I fit this easily myself? I saw an item on TV recently which showed how 'easy' it is to replace a hard drive as they are all a standard size for laptops – just open the case, pull the old one out and slide in a new one. Knowing Apple there is probably more to it than this, so what problems should I be aware of, and can I upgrade the hard drive to a bigger capacity at the same time? Mine's got an 80GB drive at the moment.

Sorry this is so long, but there seems to be so much background I needed to give you. Thanks if anybody is willing to help me.

Bruce

6 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    until you change it you can't be sure it is the drive, but from what you describe it seems likely, although the death while sleeping is a bit worrying

    you can certainly put in a larger drive

    there's a step by step guide here...

    http://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Mac/PowerBook-G4-Al-15-Inch-1-1-5-GHz-BT-1-1/Hard-Dr ive-Replacement/54/9/Page-1

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    If Disk Warrior can't put the drive back into working order, with the symptoms you described, it does sound like new hard drive time. If you're reasonably good around computer innards, you can replace the drive yourself. Here's a hardware guide: http://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Mac/ . Pick your system and then view the chapter on hard drive replacement. When I replaced a drive recently, I used these directions, and used yogurt cups to keep the screws organized by each step in the instructions. You'll need a small allen hex tool and a size#0 phillips screwdriver. The directions called for a torx screwdriver, however, mine needed a small allen hex key.

    You'll want to buy a 2.5" parallel ATA hard drive, and cannot use a serial ATA (SATA) drive in a Powerbook. Most drives spin at 5400rpm. Seagate drives have a 5 year warranty while most others have 1-3 years. If you scan the discussions for 'powerbook hard drive replacement' you'll find more details on the surgery, initializing the hard drive, and reloading the operating system afterwards.

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks to 'um' and BGreg for the helpful replies. I think I'll go for a new hard drive now. Although I'm not entirely confident inside the guts of a laptop (having looked at the iFixit guide, which does show things fairly clearly) I am less confident with my local Apple Centre for returning the laptop as 'fixed' when it clearly wasn't. They want about £50 to do the work on top of the drive cost too.

    I'll get myself the torx screwdriver – not familiar with the small allen 'hex' key. I have a set of allen keys, so I assume hex keys are similar in having the right angle bend but with the star shaped end? Wouldn't the torx screwdriver do the job just the same? Don't see why I would need to hunt down a small allen hex key, but I would hate to end up stripping a screw head by having the wrong tool.

    Western Digital do a 250G parallel ATA drive I hear, but only give 3 years warranty. Suppose that's a decision I'll have to make for myself. I've done the "powerbook hard drive replacement" Google search and there's loads to read. A quick glance over one article spoke of the 'horror' of lost screws so I'll find some empty yogurt pots as you suggest BGreg.

    Lots to read, then order the drive. After that I've got to fit the thing, and my work shifts don't leave me much free time right now, but I'll drop back online when it's done and let you know how it went – or maybe ask for help if it goes pear-shaped!

    Thanks a lot guys!

    Bruce

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    hex key is the same as allen key, when i've opened apple stuff it has always been torx and/or various screwdrivers

    i have had some problems on a macbook pro with memory bay screws that had locking compound on, they were so tight and so small it was tricky getting them out without damage, exact fit with screwdrivers helps a lot

    if you have space, try laying out the screws in positions matching where they came from, it avoids the angst that occurs when you find different lengths of screw with the same thread and no idea which hole they came from

  5. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks "um' – good tips, and I'll do as you suggest. Found somewhere in Nottingham which has a full range of torx drivers (Maplins), so that problem's solved. Just need to choose the drive now. I'm going to study the iFixit guide and work slowly and carefully.

    Bruce

  6. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I eventually purchased a Western Digital Scorpio 250GB ATA drive. I had no trouble installing the drive following the instructions at ifixit.com, as you suggested, BGreg. I purchased the Torx 6 screw driver, and had the correct size Phillips driver to hand. I prepared carefully by labeling enough small containers with the stage number, so the screws went back in the correct sequence later. I worked slowly, and had no problems at all.

    To get the computer back to how it was I used Time Machine, together with the Leopard install DVD, but decided to partition the new drive into a smaller 80GB sector and a larger 152GB sector. This was so I could install Leopard on the larger, and my old Panther on the smaller. I did this as I discovered my licensed copies of some software (including Photoshop 7 and Microsoft Office) wouldn't work in Leopard. Rather than having to purchase new software I installed these on the smaller sector, and they work fine. When I need to use them I just hold down the Option key and select Panther at startup. I use Leopard at other times.

    I've been working with this new drive for a few weeks now, and not had any problems.

    Thanks to both BGreg and um for your help.

    Regards,

    Bruce