Benches Vintage and obsolete

4

SuperDrive scrambles names, refuses to burn

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

12" G4 PowerBook, 10.3.9 (and 10.4.11) with Apple-labeled UJ825-C SuperDrive.
Refuses to burn DVDs, but that's not the half of it. Weirdest thing..... commercial CDs mount (home made ones don't), but the weird thing is this: Disk name and all file names are scrambled.

For example: A commercial CD mounted in other Macs contains seven folders named:
"edge, files, mac, images, scripts, styles, webpull." These appear on this PowerBook, in order, as:
"adce, bihes, iac, imagas, scripts, stylas, sebpqlh."

This happens when PowerBook is booted from its internal 10.3.9 hard drive, and when booted from a 10.4.11 FireWire hard drive. Even with internal drive disconnected and booted from a 10.3.9 FireWire drive. (Hard drives are all fine; permissions, verify, no errors or issues.) Reset PRAM, tried all the usual suspects, then I replaced the original UJ825-C with another Apple branded UJ845-C, thinking the optical drive's firmware was at fault, but - +I got exactly the same scrambled file names!+

Trying to burn a DVD results in "unsupported drive" errors 0x8002006D, 0x80020023, and 0x80020025. First SuperDrive was machine's original, replacement drive is from another PowerBook. If the problem is not on the hard drive, and two optical drives act the same way, that leaves something on the logic board - right? Can an ATA controller scramble file names and disk names? And why would it apply only to optical drive? Ribbon cable? I sure hope someone out there can shed a little light on this wacky situation. Thanks! - Mike

4 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    No suggestions, hints, clues? Can't say I'm surprised, it's such a strange problem. I think the only solution is to replace logic board, but I was hoping to gain a little understanding of the ATA bus and how/why file names might get scrambled between optical drive and screen while HDD functions flawlessly. Only other clue I can offer is the odd fact that the disc's name appears on desktop - mispelled, naturally - in ALL CAPS on this machine only. Reminds me of the HAL 9000....

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Wrong - Disc name was in all CAPS, so that's not a symptom. Still misspelled tho, and I'm still afraid that if I stick a Rolling Stones CD into this machine, I'll hear Hal singing Daisy. Update: Both optical drives work perfectly if connected to another notebook, which only confirms that this issue resides somewhere in the ATA controller/firmware.

    I've long suspected that upgrading from 10.3 to 10.4 modifies machine firmware; true? Might that fix the ATA bus? Anybody? Thanks.....

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Wow, the silence is deafening. Alrighty then, here's the bottom line and end of story:

    PowerBook was thoroughly tested, every test passed except the optical drive bus. Two Apple-branded SuperDrives (UJ825 and UJ845) were also tested independent of the 'Book and worked perfectly. Both drives produce the same scrambled file names and errors when connected to the 'Book's internal ATA bus.

    I found a nifty little FireWire enclosure made just for these notebook optical drives from MCE (mcetech.com; specifically, GEN-5ALFWU2SLIMPortable FireWire/USB 2.0 Slim Optical Drive Enclosure), and put the 'Book back in service with an external (bootable) SuperDrive. It's kinda like a poor man's AirBook now. Just thought I'd pass this along and wrap it up, the end of a really weird problem.

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I myself will never buy from MCE Technologies again. The worst service you can imagine. First they didn't send the power cord. Then a MONTH later they sent it but the drive was defective. Now they say I have to return it myself and pay for shipping and insurance just to get a refund. I'm certainly never buying from them again.

    doug