Benches Vintage and obsolete

15

Logic 7 :: BAAAD Programming

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hi All - maybe one of you can relieve me of my agony!

we have a large Logic 7.1 / Digidesign PT Mix4 setup. And in general it worX! However, following BUGZ are killing us and our customers are gettin' agitated when we keep getting continuos errors like:

grouping 4 or 5 channels only to find out that when moving one fader in the group the others wont follow untill you ungroup and regroup...hehehe. Then (god forbid it) should you deceide to discontinue this group and make a new group from other channels then make sure that you dont assign the groupnumber from before cuz... the channels having had that particular group number assigned before will now still follow the new group even though they have no group assigned......

This problem haunts me all the time and I dont trust Logic further than Saddam Hussein.

Problem 2 : Recording / BOUNCING

we have a lot of studio musicians working for us and they cant stop smiling. >This is why! In a for example guitar session where the player have to play a rythm ac guitar on the chorus: We cycle record thhe chorus and let the guy play and get into his thing.....The only stone in the way is Logic AMATEUR 7.1

Logic will randomely quit shortly before reaching the end of the cycle...This situation have the foollowing work around: Reformat your drive and use the outer rim partition, then delete the record path of song, the tell logic to use global recording path without max rec. time, the go to audio window and refresh the following: Overvies, file information... THIS IS A JOKE!

The when using the cycle as locator for bouncing logic will bounce if you choose .mp3 format or interleaved format for aiff. Should one however choose SDII file in split stereo then Logic will bounce until one inch from end of cycle/song and then stop the bounce, thus having bounced nothing at all.

Then - this is the biggest pain in tha butt. for one mix we generally create like 8 different Room simulations e.g. reverb one or Oxford reverb ....This BS takes time cuz all have various decay times and pre delay and so forth...These plugs are instantiated in the AUX inserts which according to apple should be safer that bus objects....only when entering the next day I open logic to find out that it has not saved any parameter that I have entered in the reverb plug. So what logic does is to save the location of the plug but nut the specific parameters....This stuff never happens in protools. This problem also happens on audio channels with various plugs and the worst is: It happens only randomely......Sometimes it saves sometimes it dont.

There are many other problems like after having given a group a name the curser remains the shape of a text edit curser and so on::::

this is why I say that ever since Logic got into the hands of apple it lost its PRO touch and morphed into a badly(but hey - good looking) programmed AMATEUR application.....

PS : Should any of have solutions for a.m. insidents please write:-)

Regards - 25G'S

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Jonathan Christensen

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    There are many other problems like after having given a group a name the curser remains the shape of a text edit curser and so on::::

    Out of everyting you've mentioned here, this is the only one I've ever seen in years and years of using Logic. Have you tried the usual removal of the Logic prefs folder and Autoload? Starting from the Logic default song gives the same results?

  2. 0

    Jee

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Same here, also seen that it comes in a different shape somtimes, but really it doesnt bother me. The other things you are writing about (your problems). They really DO work fine for me, it seems like there is something else that causing the problems. Can unfortunately not tell you why...

  3. 0

    25G'S

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks guys - is seems natural that you dont share my problems - since you are not working with digidesign and TDM (Time Division Multiplexing) the problems I mention dont happen on our "Native" G4 wit a MOTU interface...Logic works fine "Natively" but with TDM it's a whole other Ballpark - H* it aint even the same sport:-)

  4. 0

    Jee

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yeah, Digidesign and Logic isn't really friends, I know that. Even the little b*stard Mbox doesnt work well with Logic, while all the other interfaces on the market does. On the mbox Digidesign doesnt bother to make proper core audio drivers as en example.

    It's just an approach on who to blame aswell 😉
    joke

  5. 0

    Rohan Stevenson1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    well, i can't see that some of these problems should be related to morten's PT setup, but i could be wrong. other's of course might be - in particular record path.

    if there is a problem with bouncing, does the same thing happen using in-built audio coreaudio? (obviously if you are bouncing, using it won't impact on quality of the bounced file).

    like others, i have not come across any of these problems apart from the cursor one, which also doesn't bother me much.

    the main thing is the saving of plug-in settings. that should have nothing to do with digi hardware. corrupt song? dodgy prefs? have you been practising safe hard drives? ie disk perms et al? again that is not something i have seen.

    can i also suggest posting this at logicprohelp.com. you will get in touch with some real guru's there, in particular david eager who has digidesign setup and will probably know what issues are your's and what are digi's. or he might answer here.....

  6. 0

    G_Unit

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I agree with Rohan here again - it's something other than Logic that's causing problems. I've been running my copy of LP 7.1 at the studio I work at on one of the HD3 systems without any problems yet. At a glance, it would seem that your software/OS/audio drivers are not properly configured.

    A. Assuming you have followed the TDM recommendations and have PTools installed, I don't believe that MIX is supported above PT 6.4 AFAIK. Additionally the latest DIGI coreaudio driver for that software is core audio 6.7 which is not officially approved for 10.3.9 either.

    B. PT MIX is old technology and it would not be a total surprise if Emapple focused their TDM hardware compatability on HD systems.

    Remedies = check your PT version, DIGI core audio driver version, Apple pro app support version, then cross reference your DIGI software/drivers on DIGI's compatability support page.

  7. 0

    Merged Content 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    must be the PT Mix Setup, Logic and PT HD works quite well,

    there is a little less stability then in Pro Tools 6.9, but I'm fine

    with my Logic - Pro Tools HD Rig.

    Wolfgang

  8. 0

    Ron Marinelli

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I've experienced the Grouping problems too. I've not had any of the other non PT related problems though.

    But I don't think you can rightly blame Apple/Logic for 'bad programming' because you're having problems with an old PT Mix system. No software/hardware company can support every legacy product back that far. Does PT still support Mix systems?

    That's no basis for insulting a great program either, by calling it amateur. And when Apple bought Logic, they didn't fire all the programmers and replace them with their own people. Come on, get real - it's the same people working on it, and probably even more now that they have more resources.

  9. 0

    tbirdparis

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    yep, logic 7x with HD has had a couple of bugs, such as realtime bounce not working for TDM tracks.. but these have been fixed and I'm finding it really nowhere near as problematic as morten suggests.

    to be honest, a lot of it looks like pilot error, particularly the stuff about saving plug in settings.. sometimes you need to use a plug in's own save dialogue to save parameters, sometimes the logic one will do it. this isn't necessarily a logic thing, it is a third party standards missmatch.

    still, I do agree that there are lots of frankly dodgy things going on in logic that do not inspire as much confidence as they should.

  10. 0

    25G'S

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    To Ron M.,

    I was not insulting Logic/Apple!!! I was spilling my frust!!!! We have a large production facility and we dont have time to write as much as other people in here!!! HOWEVER, I do know that other large production facilities have similar problems and that customers are sitting in the Control room and asking what kind foolish app we are using.... We dont have any pilot errors here trust me...Only an erratic application. LOGIC PRO does support Mix and mix aint old. We run large sessions with a lot of plugs and Logic is not satisfactory. However, from the answers that I have heard here I choose the wrong platform for getting help. I get answers from people not using Digidesign.... I just wonder if Digidesign works why dont Logic. And please Logic have worked for more than 10 years - RELIABLY - only after Apple got their greedy fingers in - Logic got reincarnated - THUS - AMATEUR...

    PS . for those who like PRO discussions and cool answers - go to Logic TDM Groups on Yahoo.com - this apple support is sonding like Karl Marx and commies:-)

    PEACE

  11. 0

    Eddy Currents

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Morten,

    I sympathise with you. I really like Logic . I think it could, in conjuction with Apple, become the finest audio platform available. But at the mo, it does feel like keep your fingers crossed. I've been running 7.1 with Hd3 accel/ os 10.3.8( Digi recommended) recording and mixing an entire album. Stability is a great concern. Thankfully our enviroment had some leeway with regard to this. I understand how frustrating it would be not to have that.

    We're fortunate not to have suffered the problems you have but we've had our own peculiarities.( My favourite is how digis' tdm dly seems somehow to crash the whole song in cycle record/playback, something to do with cpu overload, and then reload the song with no memory of your preset!...ever! ooh and it makes a wicked sound when it crashes)

    I'm afraid I can't help you with the problems your having as I've yet to suffer them myself. I'd just like to hope that Apple are listening to the pro user.

    Some seem to have relative success with TDM, myself included.Some not. So many plugs and third party handshakes , what are we to do? Surely it is in all parties best interests to create compatibility. I worry whether now , at this time, we'll need to upgrade to get it. It's amazing how technology's come on. My G4's not powerfull enough.Do I need to upgrade? Our G5 still has problems though.

    There are so many permutations, it's clearly very difficult for Apple. I'm hoping thay can sort it.

    Apple should be the hub, and I hope they realise this. TDM/ Motu/ Waves Apa / Tc or any other third party compliment should always be fully supported by Apple should they not?.

    It's still early days.

    But it can clearly be deeply frustrating that we have to wait.

    I think it'll be worth it though.

    I wish you luck

    Cheers Eddy

    (Generally enjoying stable tdm if I can compromise a bit!)

  12. 0

    spocintosh

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hello Morten,

    from my widespread adventures with the combination of Logic and digi i can tell you of a lot of frustration too !

    But in your case I agree most with G_Unit's reply. Please check your system as some of your problems seem very unusual, especially your cycle problem. Actually this is something I never experienced. As you can see from my profile being a user of native, MIX and HD, I can be arrogant enough to dare say this...

    PT MIX is in fact, whether you like it or not, an "old system", as digi doesn't care to support it any further. So you know who's to blame here.

    They released a final version (6.4.1) for MIX users that even incorporated quite a few of the latest PT features. Unfortunately it requires to keep OS 10.3.4 which seems a bit out of date now...but on my Quicksilver everything's running smooth. I always swap all of my projects between the systems without any problem. HD in the studio, the MIX at home and the Powerbook when I'm "on the road".

    And as I don't necessarily check stock exchanges or temperatures of Bali's beach resorts while in a creative process I don't feel like upgrading to Dashboard-equipped Tiger on the QS...I rather go for the "never change a running system"-approach. And it IS running, i can tell. So I might recommend to check if maybe there's something wrong with the disks. It might be something that restricts your data flow, like for example having "Journaling" enabled or too much daisy chaining of Firewire drives ? Just an idea...i agree with the other poster who said that the record path problems are a strong hint to that !!

    The grouping issues in fact are a well known bug...happens on native CoreAudio as well. And it IS new since version 7, you are right.

    With SD2-bouncing i couldn't find a problem. I even do SD2-bouncing to SplitStereo on my Powerbook working native, as this is of course the file format of choice to keep interchangeabilty between all of my systems.

    And it works seamlessly.

    What else comes to my mind is that there are a few issues with UAD-cards and another one when having Melodyne installed, but as I don't run both of it myself I can't really tell. I had terrible problems once I installed Melodyne, found out about officially approved ⚠ incompatibilities with the Melodyne-bridge in conjunction with Logic and deleted it right away. It may have changed now though, never tried it again.

    Feel free to get back to me. Maybe you can get somewhat closer to the problems. I could try to reproduce it.

    But first get back to what digi specifies: PT 6.4.1 on 10.3.4.

    Digi is EXTREMELY picky about their compato requirements !!!

    Be aware that the TDM streaming drivers are very closely connected to the OS, and Apple changed a lot between 10.3.4 and 10.3.9.

    Good Luck !

  13. 0

    spocintosh

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Ah and one thing I forgot : Logic 7 is CLEARLY developed for Tiger. We must not forget that. Logic on panther and Tiger are just not the same !

    I had a virtually unusable system with running Logic 7.1 on the HD3 G5 before Tiger. After the 10.4 switch, however, it is now faster and more reliable than ever before. The latest Pro Application Support Software Update from Apple ( which doesn't come up necessarily by automatic Software Update) played a crucial part too. Logic 7.1 needs it badly !

    So maybe getting back to a super-smooth LogicPro 6.4.3 on a Panther machine is an option too, can depend on your specific setup or optional software.

    I have 7.1 installed on my QS 10.3.4 but prefer working with 6.4.3 whenever possible as it is so much more responding in direct comparison.

    Different story on G5 and PowerBook with 10.4.2, though.

  14. 0

    Eric Jackson2

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    to be honest, i've given up on trying to make the esb/tdm thing work. I find my system is much more stable just using core audio for logic and dae for pro tools hd. Having both on the same computer is fine and less headaches. Also it is easier to import sessions and share files with other logic users without haveing to worry about universal track mode and hoping that some of my plug ins won't become deactived when I have to switch audio engines. I'm planning I planning to pick up a firewire interface just for logic and keep my apogees for pro tools (i'll probably get another apogee). one guy I know tracks his files from logic to pt via optical from his 828 to his 192 with no problems on the same computer. I've got epic tdm working in pt and editing audio in pt is easier. I see no reason to mix in logic but I do love it for what it does.

    on a side note to morten carlsen...have we met??? you sound familiar. if so the please give my regards to adam a.

    eric j from L.A.

  15. 0

    spocintosh

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Eric,

    you're absolutely right with getting rid of the DTDM/ESB connection.

    Did that some time ago, too. It really is just unusable.

    DTDM bussing still suffers terrible unity gain and latency problems.

    THIS for me is the exact contrary of what I call workflow, and always with the high risk of the spinning beachball of death...no thanks.

    But even though we will always use our AMEKs here, I set up my PT systems similarly to your friend, just that I feed a some more tracks back to the system.

    And now I'm about to getting used to always start working mainly on native with the Hammerfall DSP cards and output 8 ADAT tracks and 2 SPDI/F to the 192 via dedicated Input Channel Objects just for playback. With the RME Digiface I can extend this to 26 digital outputs routed into the 192 if necessary that can then be output to the desk separately again. As the home system with the 888 I just feed 2 channels back. I may be start looking for the ADATBridges that must be rusting somewhere in the closets...

    The benefit of this ??

    In the studio - the sonic quality of the Digi/Apogee Hardware while working on native, that's the reason why I'll never trade in the last 888's, they have so much juice compared to the 96's and 192's, especially on drums and bass...

    But the main benefit is of course, I can jump on the train and work on the mix with the powerbook because I can hear everything !!!!

    And honestly, except maybe for the SoundToys and Eventide Plugins you can find everything for AU nowadays. There are even some free Plugs now that I fancy over super-overexaggeratedly expensive Digi-TDM-sh*t. And what Logic 7 brings in is definitely worth a try - how glad I am to get rid of AutoTune finally because Pitch Correction is so much more subtle !

    So "BAAAAAD Programming" ? Not really, I think. You just have to find your way to handle the Digi-beast...takes some time, but now it's definitely possible.