15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
- 0
David S. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
There may be plans, but Apple hasn't told anybody externally.
- 0
tedtv ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
the real question is whether or not you can buy a blu-ray burner with software that will run on a mac? does the latest Toast provide burn support for blu-ray on a mac? most blu-ray come with the eSATA connection, so it should be possible...right?
- 0
Shawn Birmingham ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yes you can buy a Blu-Ray burner right now for your Mac and use Toast 9 to create Blu-Ray discs. A single burnable Blu-Ray disc cost between $14-22.
The Blu-Ray specs allow for a much higher level of interactivity and options than the DVD spec. Programs such as Encore and Toast are only using the DVD specs with HD material. Currently there are no programs that utilize the full potential of Blu-Ray for under $10,000. One would hope that Apple is not working on DVD Studio Pro with Blu-Ray capabilities, but instead a Blu-Ray Studio Pro. But Apple does not pre announce their development plans, so there is no way to know for sure. Grumbling about it isn't going to get Apple to pre announce.
- 0
Jeremy Hansen ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi all. I'm waiting eagerly to put our HDV footage onto Blu-ray. Currently, we are archiving the footage on a hard drive. Here's a question that may be answered now:
HDV has a bitrate of around 26mpbs. Does anyone know if we should be able to simply mux the footage with reencoding, without any playback problems? I'm hoping that the HDV is pretty much ready to go since it is mpeg2 video, but I worry that its native bitrate is too demanding, even though it is within the technical max spec. Can anyone shed light on a typical mpeg2 bitrate?
Jeremy
- 0
James Behl ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I too will add my 2ยข worth on the need for Blu-ray support in DVD StudioPro. I am able to author Blu-Ray disks using Adobe Encore. The process is to say the least painful. Encore is buggy and qwirky and sloooooooooooooow. I would settle for the interim ability to be able to offer DVD spec HD in Blu-ray for now. Just so I didn't have to suffer using Encore. If Blu-Ray StudioPro came later, so much the better. This is an evolving format. It seems as though Apple is betting on downloading media. I agree that in the long run this will be the future but for small productions in the near future the business model does not work. School programs, weddings and similar projects have no reasonable way to get to the end user than physical disk for the near future.
I just finished a project for a local school that has been doing a program for 70 years. We have recorded this program for the last 20 years. First we delivered the program on VHS then for the a combination of VHS and DVDs and three years ago we discontinued VHS delivery, offering only DVDs. This year we offered DVD and Blu-ray (yes they can afford it.) The Blu-ray results were unbelievable. It was the jump from VHS all over again. The down side was I had to use Encore to author the Blu-ray version. Ouch! Any change at all and you go back to the beginning. Very poor coding in the program. Just like the bad old days before Final Cut Studio; Premiere 5.0 that would crash on launch. So I too hope the kind folks at Apple will help us and bring us the ability to do Blu-ray and not have to suffer from high blood pressure for too much longer with an inferior.
BTW, Toast 9 does work but is what you would expect from a program in its price range; somewhat limited.
- 0
Infotech 24 7 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
James is spot on with the Toast 9 comment. I've used it just to finally get a Blu-ray movie working on a Playstation 3 but it's more like an iLife disc than anything you can do with something like DVD Studio Pro. It's still good to see HD from your camera on an old fashioned silver disc though. I still think you're better off exporting for Apple TV if it's your own home movies but I emphasise with everyone who needs something for Pro jobs because it's just not there at the moment without investing in Encore which is awful.
- 0
Equus ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
As far as I've heard, sure, you can plug a Blu-Ray burner and author a disc with Toast 9, but you won't be able to play your finished product because Leopard doesn't support Blu-Ray playback.
It boggles the mind...
- 0
James Klatt ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I bought Final Cut Studio 2, new operating system, & invested in a Mac Pro so that I could move my business to an HD product.
It has been all for naught, though. They sure advertise the **** out FCS 2 as an HD solution for people, but it should have a big fat asterisk next to it. What's the point if you cannot deliver in anything but SD?
I wish I could go back in time and keep all the money I invested in cameras, software, hardware etc., and just stay SD.
Sure, I know I have a Mac Pro and there are alternate routes, but they look way too painful for what you get.
- 0
David S. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Where has Apple advertised DVD SP as a HD definition authoring application?
Haven't seen that advertisement.
In fact, the lack of blu ray support has been absent all along
We regularly create HD DVDs that are glorious -- much better than the blu rays discs I've tested out of either Toast or Encore.
The HD capabilities that Apple touts are for Final Cut Pro. In fact, it supports just about every HD format currently available including RED, AVCHD for the most part, XDCAM, DVCProHD, etc.
Most HDV cams are supported.
When we create SD DVDs with solid DVCProHD footage, they look absolutely fabulous to our clients -- and many cannot tell the difference between that footage and HD footage.
But we shoot a 100 mbps DVCProHD 1080/24pa and reduce that to SD DVDs.
It would be great to get some blu ray support out of DVD SP.
But given the fact that only 600,000 blu ray set tops were out last year and there are less than 500 titles available and most look like you know what, it isn't and isn't likely to be a "must have" item for some years.
If you got clients and they want blu ray, then pony up and go with Encore.
- 0
Eric Pautsch1 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
David S. wrote:*
and many cannot tell the difference between that footage and HD footage.
I hate it when I hear comments like this ๐
I agree David....Apple puts out a great product. The industry knows it and so does Apple. There simply is not enough demand for Apple to add BD support.
Message was edited by: Eric Pautsch1
- 0
Drew13 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Eric Pautsch1 wrote:
David S. wrote:*
and many cannot tell the difference between that footage and HD footage.
I hate it when I hear comments like this ๐
Like I said before, it seems many people cannot even tell wheen 4:3 is stretched to fit 16:9 TVs, nor do they know how to set it up.
Dang them, they do not know how much we suffer to try to makes things properly and they throw it to the curb.... ๐ ๐
- 0
StingRay67 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
im just about to do the same as you James.. I got a mac pro FCS2 and all the bits but as yet have not gone High Def with my cam.. So im holding off on the cam side. But to still film in low def is a real pain as one cannot take advantage of the new high def cams. Sure I could downcovert and burn later, but until the hard/software is available and tested on mac I'd prefer to chose my new high def cam on the principle that I know the computer gear can handle it .. Also, and as you imply.. whats the point in investing in high def with such a system! Format wars are a bloody pain in the arse.
- 0
James Klatt ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
+We regularly create HD DVDs that are glorious -- much better than the blu rays discs I've tested out of either Toast or Encore.+
HD DVD has been discontinued. It is the loser of the format war. It is useless to me.
+When we create SD DVDs with solid DVCProHD footage, they look absolutely fabulous to our clients -- and many cannot tell the difference between that footage and HD footage.+
When a potential customer calls and asks if I "do" HD. I have to explain to them that although all my equipment is HD-capable I cannot actually deliver HD discs. Click and dialtone.
I also cannot advertise in good faith that I have an HD product, since I cannot deliver. This affects my prices, my clients and this affects the future of my business.
The whole point in investing in HD equipment and overhauling my entire studio was so that I can downconvert to the the same format that I just spent tons of money to move up from? This is madness.
Yes, FCS 2 is awesome. I love it. The most crucial step, however, is the delivery of the product to the people. Without it, all the advances are useless to them.
At this point, I would advise people to get PC's if they want to do HD work, 'cause Apple does not have an answer for them.
- 0
Andy Neil ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
James Klatt wrote:
HD DVD has been discontinued. It is the loser of the format war. It is useless to me.HD DVD was only discontinued a month or so ago. How fast was Apple supposed to provide Blu-Ray support? It's kind of ridiculous to expect something so soon. That being said, I don't doubt that Apple saw the writing on the wall and is likely in production to provide Blu-Ray support. You just need to be patient.
James Klatt wrote:
When a potential customer calls and asks if I "do" HD. I have to explain to them that although all my equipment is HD-capable I cannot actually deliver HD discs. Click and dialtone.
I also cannot advertise in good faith that I have an HD product, since I cannot deliver. This affects my prices, my clients and this affects the future of my business.You need to alter how you explain the situation to clients. Blu-Ray DVD is not the only HD delivery format out there. Not even close. There's HDCam, there's D5. If you're only service is DVD authoring, then yeah, you're out of luck with DVDSP for now. If however, you are full service, or an editor, then you're only real issue is you need to sub-contract someone who can author Blu-Ray until support comes. If you can injest HD, you can output HD.
James Klatt wrote:
The whole point in investing in HD equipment and overhauling my entire studio was so that I can downconvert to the the same format that I just spent tons of money to move up from? This is madness.If Blu-Ray was your chief concern, then you shouldn't have bought FCS 2 to begin with because you would have known that FCS 2 supports only HD-DVD authoring. If HD was your chief concern, then you just ended up on the losing side of the format war just like Apple. Quite beyond your control (and Apple's I might add). You should be mad at Toshiba.
James Klatt wrote:
At this point, I would advise people to get PC's if they want to do HD work, 'cause Apple does not have an answer for them.Good Luck. I'll just take my HD video to a dub house or Blu-Ray production facility, but good luck to you with Premiere Pro and Adobe Encore.
Andy