Benches Uncategorized

15

Airplane affects iPod?

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I have a 40GB iPod Photo. I use it several times a week with no trouble, however every time I get on an aircraft I have trouble with it.

When I turn it on it is slow to respond but I can sometimes get it to start playing. If I do, when it is playing it will start to skip songs. It changes to the next song, sits for 10-15secs without playing sound, then just goes to the next song. Sometimes it plays the next song sometimes not. After a while it skips more and more until it is skipping Every song and won't play anything.

If I try to do anything, fast forward, go back to the menu, anything, it freezes up and does nothing. I cannot turn it off nor reset it. I can feel the hard drive spinning continuously (pulsing almost, like it is reading for a few secs then pauses for a few then reads again) but it is totally unresponsive. If I put it down and don't touch it for somewhere between 20-45 minutes it shuts itself off. Sometimes I can start it and the whole process starts over, sometimes it starts and is immediately frozen. If I can start it and try to reset it, it resets, but when it comes back up everything is gone. All the music, all the photos, everything. And during all this it eats like 1/2 the battery.

When I get home I try to resync and the system will not see the ipod most of the time. After trying several times, reseting a couple times, it will see it, but says it needs to be initialized. If I try to initialize it using the software it starts, but the battery dies before it does anything. Again the drive is running continually. Even with the battery fully charged it dies before it can finish, or possible the software is actually hung and it dies when the battery is out. In this situation the battery dies in about an hour.

If I try repeatedly, I can eventually (minimum of 6 tries) get it to initialize and then copy all my song to it again. It is then fine again, and I can use it daily with no trouble. When running normally the battery lasts for at least 12 hours or more.

This happened with the last software version and has continued to happen since I updated to the new version in june. I have tried initializing and using iTunes on a different computer, just in case, but same things happen.

This has happened a total of 5 times now, only when on a plane and every time I am on a plane, so its not just a coincidence. (course then I can't use it for a week or so till I have had 6 or more chances to dedicate a system to it for several hours) I have tried carrying the ipod in different ways, different pockets of my carry on, in my own pocket, in the case and out, nothing seems to make a difference.

If I had to guess it seems like being on a plane somehow causes the iPod to not be able to read its drive and it it keeps trying, killing the battery as it goes, and since after the reset it still can't read the drive it deletes the song index showing me there are no songs. I am only traveling on large pressurized planes (737, airbus, etc) so I don't think it is a low pressure issue.

Happening to anyone else, or anyone got any ideas? I do use it more, but I bought it specifically to use on my frequent flights. So far I am just frustrated with it.

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Andrew Tomlin

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Welcome to the discussion boards! In less than an hour, you'll get a whole bunch of people reporting they've had no trouble whatsoever with iPods on airplanes (myself being one of them). I think you'll need to ask official Apple people about it. Perhaps take it to an Apple Store and ask a Genius.

    Best of luck,

    Andrew T.

  2. 0

    Charles Saunders

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Appreciate the welcome.

    I do realize that most people do not have trouble on airplanes, my old 15GB did not and my girfriend and several other friends with various models do not. While I would appreciate their effort to help me, those that have no trouble on planes need not post to tell me so, as I am aware this is an oddity.

    I did speak with two of the so called 'geniuses' at my local apple store and they both agreeded, "No, never heard about anything like that. You should reread the manual to be sure you are loading it correctly". When I explained everything in the above post to them and that it works fine the rest of the time, they still insisted, "It must be a coincidence. You must be doing something different just before flying." and then explained I could send the unit in for repair, but if they found nothing wrong with it, which they probably won't since they won't test it on a plane, they would charge me for looking at it and not replace/repair it. Certainly don't want to pay to get back a defective iPod, paid enough for it already.

    So I was hoping at least one other person had experienced this and had an idea, even if it was that they sent theirs in and Apple did managed to replicate the problem and replace it.

    Thanks.

  3. 0

    hiddenmuse

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    If you bring your Apple product in to an Apple store, they do not charge to look at it. The repair cost obviously will be based on the repair need.

    I am having a problem with my iBook, and the Apple phone support tech told me that I could send it in for fix. $300 would cover an problem, but if they found nothing wrong, or found that the problem was due to user negligence (ie I hit it with a hammer or spilled something in it), then I would have to either pay for the repair or tell them not to fix it and just pay for shipping.

    To make a long story even longer, you should not be charged at the Apple Genius Bar for them to diagnose your problem.

  4. 0

    Andrew Tomlin

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Wait! I've got it! Sell it on eBay or to a friend who isn't planning on flying, and buy yourself a new one.

    Andrew T.

  5. 0

    amorphouskev

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'll be that friend...

  6. 0

    QfromStarfleet

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Assuming that your iPod isnt faulty, and has the latest software upgrade, there is a faint possibility that it happens in current 'fly-by-wire' airplane technology, although other users seem not to have this problem. Anyway, its the reason that you are asked to switch off mobile phones, etc when you fly, as the EMF (electro magnetic field) MIGHT interfere with the airplane control system. It could be interfering with your iPod.!!!

    Just a thought, when all other reasons have been tried.

  7. 0

    Charles Saunders

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    True, they don't charge to look at it in the store, but they also won't/didn't find anything wrong as it Only happens when on a plane and the geniuses have no means to test anything other than pushing the play button to see if it plays.

    My fear is that I will send it in, they will test it in an environment where it does ot cause a problem, find it as ok, and charge me to ship it back, only to have it fail again when I fly again. Would just be more money down the drain.

  8. 0

    Charles Saunders

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    While I can't rule out the emf on the plane as a possibility, the reason you turn off electronics is that the planes instruments are sensitive to it. Their own electronics are shielded to prevent them from interfering with the plane as well, so I doubt it would bother the iPod. And it could not be one planes faulty wiring as it happens on different planes.

    Also the pod works fine sitting on my workbench surrounded by running computers, several monitors, speakers, etc. so emf does not seem likely.

    After some more research I am starting to think that the drive in my unit is overly sensative to air pressure changes. I found that Pods are not rated for use over 11,000ft. As with all hard drives the read heads have nothing to float on in low air pressure and that causes the heads to be unable to read the disk properly (in some cases it can destroy the hard drive as the head bounces scratching the platter or the friction burning up the head).

    On a commercial airliner the cabin is kept pressureized to 9,000-10,000ft. so this is normally not an issue for computer drives or pod drives. I am starting to think that this unit is overly sensative for some reason so its min. working pressure is under the 9,000-10,000ft. rather than the 11,000+ it should be rated for.

    Only thing so far that explains everything happening. Only way to test it would be to drive up to the mountais with a altimiter, which I don't have.

  9. 0

    btabz

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Charles,

    That's what I was thinking. Just to be sure though, you have tried restoring right...

    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=60983

    btabz

  10. 0

    Charles Saunders

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yes, I have had to restore completely each time to get the pod working at all again after the trip. It does take more than one try to completely restore it though, as I mentioned in my original post. I then update and copy the songs back and it works fine till the next flight.

  11. 0

    Toneus

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    My 60G color iPod has now done this to me on two of two fights!

    I actually bought the iPod for the trip the first flight took me to, a 6 day motorcycle ride!

    There I was trying to sleep to the tunes and it simply stopped playing and hung. I restarted it, and it came up without any music. Much like it couldn't access the hard drive.

    Since the second time I'm experiencing the long delays after clicking or scrolling. It also doesn't want to turn off by holding down the Play/Pause button.

    Any information on why this happens would be greatly appreciated!

    TIA,

    Tony

  12. 0

    Charles Saunders

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hey Tony,

    It was a hopeless cause. There was no way to prove to apple that the problem existed, and their stance was that if their 'geniuses' at the store could not replicate the problem then there was no problem and therefore nothing they could do about it. I have even had 4 different Apple employees suggest I sell it on ebay and buy a new one. So I should lose out on the difference between what I can sell a used one for and what a new one costs, and screw over some unsuspecting person at the same time. Nice attitude this company has.

    I tried explaining to one store manager that I would be fine with that really poor attitude, IF they were to make every effort to replicate the problem. I was being quite loud about the whole thing at that point. I have been nothing but pleasant to everyone up to that point. But after holding out for 6 airplane trips, several long phone calls, and 5 trips to stores, with the same bull answer, I had had enough.

    So I get nice and loud and explain the situation to Everyone in the store, and get the manager to assure me they would do anything possible to replicate the problem so they could get it all taken care of. So I ask what he plans to do? He had no clue, so I suggested since he promised to do anything possible, that he buy one of the geniuses a plane ticket. He started to laugh it off as silly, but noticed I was not kidding and that everyone was staring at him. I continued that unless he had a plan that he could tell me about right then, then a plane ride was the next logic step, and since it Was quite possible to do that, and he promised to do everything possible, I suggested we get online and book a ticket right then.

    He gave up and replaced the unit on the spot. Nice, I have had the thing since March, have done more than my fair share to replicate the issue (6 plane trips), sat on the phone for hours, sat in several stores for several hours each (a 3pm appointment can sometimes mean finally being helped at 6pm)(even had one genius that was helping me just up and leave without saying a word, because it was the end of his shift. After sitting for 30 minutes, I asked where he was and they said he went home for the day. When I said he was in the middle of helping me, they suggested I wait for the next genius to have an open slot. I waited for another hour)and after all that they still were not willing to help me till I raised **** in a store.

    Best part, I get the unit home and start to register it and it is already registered in someone elses name and the warranty on this unit was up end of September.

    So I paid full price, spent a ton of my time and energy(and gas), have not had a working unit for over 7 months, and in the end I wind up with a used product and my warranty is effectively voided.

    Last Apple product I ever buy.

  13. 0

    Katrien Riem

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi,

    This exactly sounds like the problem I encountered this morning with my 60GB, only I was not on the plane but on my daily busride to work. I have been resetting and trying to update the ipod and am getting really frustrated. I have only had this thing for 6 weeks and it freezes and starts dumping the battery, driving me insane.

    Now while plugged to my computer, I've had the do not disconnect sign for almost two hours. Plus it's still not detected in my itunes as connected. How long do these software updates take???

  14. 0

    Room 237

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    11,000 ft? Uh oh.. I guess I'll be able to test this out when I go to South America next month. La Paz, Bolivia is over 11,000 ft.

    Could it be a gravity issue, as crazy as that may sound? Gravity IS slightly less at that altitude. Can't be measured without precise instruments. We're talking practically no difference at all... But enough to affect the hard drive?

    I am scared to use my iPod on a plane now!

  15. 0

    Spencer Hayes

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi,

    I'm not 100% sure this is the problem, but from what I read I'm 99.9% sure that this is what's happening. I recently read in Flying Magazine that MP3's with hard drives (in this case your iPod)don't function well at high altitudes. This is due to the fact that for a hard drive to work, the needle that reads the information has to be an exact distance above the disc. Hard drives are engineered so that at normal pressure, the needle (I don't know what else to call it, but it's the little thing that looks like a needle and reads info from the hard drive)is at the perfect elevation above the disc. However, as you go higher in the atmosphere, pressure decreases resulting in a change of distance between the disk and the needle (most likely closer than normal). Even on a pressurized airplane, the pressure may still be less than needed for proper functioning. Because of this, the hard drive cannot be read properly and won't function at it's best, although it might work some. Although it won't harm your iPod, correct pressure is still nessecary for your iPod to work right. That is why iPods that have flash memory (such as the nano) never experience this problem. I hope this answered your question 😉