Benches Uncategorized

9

How to avoid iTunes imposed character lim…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hello,

I am hoping to get some feedback on how to avoid the character limit iTunes imposes on files when ripping music using the software.

I touched on it a little in this thread...

https://discussions.apple.com/thread/250092789

...I thought the Keep iTunes Media folder organized box might address that but it appears it does not.

The album titles and song titles I rip no matter how long they’ve been show up fine in iTunes and even when I pull them up on Apple Music and listen to them the entire song and/or album title shows up but the file ripped to my computer is shortened if it goes past a very small amount of characters.

It has messed things up when i rip a CD from the same artist and the beginning of the album name is the same as another one it will put everything in the same folder even though it is a different album. For example

SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series Vol 1

SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series Vol 2

turns into

SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Ser

SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Ser

obviously they are two different albums and those were just an example off the top of my head. Thus it will also shorten the song titles if they are longer and for something like a live album I will include (Live at xxxxxx, in city, state, date) on to the end of the song title and iTunes when ripping and shortening an album title will also do the same with a long song title. So it would end up being for example

This is the Song Title (Live at xxxxx, city, st

I was thinking that the keep iTunes organized tick box had something to do with shortening titles but I guess that was mistaken.

I tried to manually change the file file names after iTunes ripped them but then it isn’t able to find the file.

I don’t know why they shorten these as such but I wish there was a way to change that without having to do extra work or use a different ripper - which in turn would be extra work as well cause then I’d have to still get it into iTunes after I rip it with something else. Plus I’ve been ripping as Apple lossless since iTunes doesn’t support flac.

Thanks in advance.

9 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    the fiend

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You've stated that you want this to be simple, but I have to say, currently it's anything but...

    One question I need to ask is: the SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series is not on CD, is it? Or at least - they're not commercial CDs, are they?

    • If you import a commercial audio CD into iTunes, let iTunes do the work for you. The most obvious time I can think of when album names conflict is Greatest Hits albums. When artists release an album simply named Greatest Hits by <band name>, they can all appear in iTunes as one album. However - each album would be in its own Windows folder under the name of the band; i.e. Greatest Hits by Santana would be in a folder named Santana, while Greatest Hits by Alice Cooper would be in a folder named Alice Cooper. Completely separate and easy to find. Once you recognise this minor issue within iTunes, then the thing to do after each album has been imported, is to rename it in iTunes, not in the file manager, as Greatest Hits {Santana} and Greatest Hits {Alice Cooper}. And do each album before importing the next one. I've done this myself - the screenshot below is a view in my iTunes Library:

    The filenames remain as they were. There is separation and no confusion.

    Now back to your Sirius collection.

    Presumably, these are in fact already digital files when you receive them, in which case, you can rename them yourself before adding them to your iTunes Library. I would start by ensuring that there is no colon in the filename. It's the sort of thing Windows might not like and if you notice, in your examples, every time it's where the filename change begins.

    A definite and guaranteed cause of problems is renaming the filename after importing into iTunes. So why do it then when you could do it before adding to the Library?

    I don't use the iTunes Keep Folders organised feature, nor do I experience iTunes renaming any of my files. So supposing that it's the Keep Folders organised that is renaming the files (and I have yet to be convinced), then let it do so. It's either that, or don't use the Keep Folders organised, or don't use iTunes. Why? Because in the end, you're the one who's doing something out of the ordinary. Everyone else manages without a problem.

    I might sound as though I'm being callous. It's not that, I'm trying to get straight to the point.

    File naming:

    • iTunes gets information about commercial CDs from Gracenote. If the CD is listed in Gracenote, then the tags (including the filename) are dependant upon Gracenote, not iTunes and that information should be good for any computerised music player. I accept though that some Gracenote entries are poor, but that's due to careless work by record company employees, enthusiastic fans of the artist, or even the artists themselves, not iTunes. Those are now few and far between, even with a collection of 10,000 songs.
    • Commercial digital files should also already have suitable filenames and tagging information, accepted by all or most of the industry.
    • Other digital files, such as an artist's self-released digital files, YouTube rips, radio station downloads etc, are dependent upon the producer giving the files unique names. If they haven't , either it's because they don't realise the issue within music players such as iTunes, or they don't care, especially if they did not intend the end use that you have for them. In any event, you will simply have to find your own work-round.

    nacho220 wrote:

    As you can see it also shortens the song titles...which are in fact longer and have more characters. These album titles and song titles show up properly and their proper length when I pull them up through Apple Music (once they are uploaded into the iTunes Match and/or the cloud. But they are getting shortened by the iTunes software when creating the actual file name and file onto my hard drive.

    To be clear, you are referring to the Sirius material, aren't you? How do you "get that though" Apple Music or iTunes Match? Does that really work? And even if it does, why are you using Apple Music if you have all these CDs and Sirius shows? It doesn't make sense, especially if you want to keep things simple.

    it's nice to have my music alongside the Apple Music library.

    Personally, that's not an combination I would choose, it sounds far more complicated than it needs to be.

    I don't know what else to tell you: I find it difficult to believe iTunes is renaming files on the grounds of excessive length. Did you not notice the length of the filenames and songs titles in my Los Tenggas selection?

  2. 0

    the fiend

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    nacho220 wrote:

    I tried to manually change the file file names after iTunes ripped them but then it isn’t able to find the file.

    Of course, because the file is no longer where you told iTunes that it was located, but instead is under its new filename.

    If you change the filename after adding the file to iTunes, and the entry in iTunes then has an exclamation mark to the left of the song title, you can manually look for it:

    The locate will look in the folder it last found that song in. Once you find it, select it and click the Open button. iTunes will now be able to play that song again. Here's the file manager view of the folder's contents:

    ... and the iTunes file path info for the song:

  3. 0

    the fiend

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Uuummm!

    It's just dawned on me.

    In Windows file manager, if the column isn't wide enough for the text in that field, it simply gets truncated. Look...:

    As you can see, all filenames appear to be Los_Tenggas-

    However, if you place your mouse at the right-hand edge of the column header...

    you can drag the column wider and reveal the rest of the field. Is that the issue?

  4. 0

    nacho220

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    It doesn't have anything to do with dragging the window or tab wider, no.

    I had to change the name of the first album

    SiriusXM Dave Matthews Band Radio Friday Night Concert Series: West Palm Beach, Florida, July 28, 2018

    is what the first album is...but as you can see iTunes shortened it to

    SiriusXM Dave Matthews Band Radio Friday

    I had to change it to that because it was supposed to be

    SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series: West Palm Beach, Florida , July 28, 2018

    but that conflicted with the album that is titled...

    SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series: West Palm Beach, Florida , July 27, 2018

    which iTunes shortened to...

    SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series_ We

    so if I were to name this particular live album the same, only titled with the different date it would shorten both albums to

    SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series_ We

    SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series_ We

    and import songs from both albums into the same folder when in fact they are two different albums.

    As you can see it also shortens the song titles...which are in fact longer and have more characters. These album titles and song titles show up properly and their proper length when I pull them up through Apple Music (once they are uploaded into the iTunes Match and/or the cloud. But they are getting shortened by the iTunes software when creating the actual file name and file onto my hard drive.

    Hope all that helps with my explanation a little better.

  5. 0

    nacho220

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for your reply, the fiend.

    Yes, I know I can have iTunes then locate the file. However, I'm not going to do that for 10,000+ songs. Plus, when I locate the file it automatically changes the file name back to the shortened file name. So it's pointless, really.

    I'm wanting to use iTunes as my media manager and rip my music with the iTunes software. I like having my Apple Music library alongside my own personal digital library. At the same time I'd like to manage the files/folder/library I create when ripping my own music onto my hard drive. I have things set up so that should I choose to move to something like Plex (or even use the WD apps) to access said files directly...they are already properly managed.

    But the iTunes character limit is causing a problem with a number of my releases I am importing and I'm hoping there is a way to get things to work accordingly.

    I know not everyone has the same needs so it isn't going to matter to some people...but just wondering if there is a way to do what I am hoping to achieve here. I'd rather not use 10 different programs and take extra steps I don't have to take if in fact I don't have to take those.

    Right now I'm using these steps to import my music...

    iTunes import CD / iTunes edit info >

    WD Cloud Drive (add tags to files with Windows Explorer) >

    listen via Apple Music app OR listen to files directly on Plex OR WD Cloud App

    I've tried Media Monkey, Music Bee and some others, but all a little overwhelming for what I am looking for. Just trying to keep it simple and like I said, it's nice to have my music alongside the Apple Music library.

    Thanks for any continued discussion.

  6. 0

    the fiend

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I've just seen your reply.

    I have 20,000+ songs in my library. I rarely muck about with the file names - I let iTunes do the donkey work.

    Plus, when I locate the file it automatically changes the file name back to the shortened file name. So it's pointless, really.

    I've never know that to happen (because there are times when I do muck about with the filenames... ).

    But back to your point about the length of filenames. The reason I chose to show you the songs I did was because of their long titles and consequent long filenames. Are your filenames, including the filepath to them really that long? If so, I think you may find it's a Windows limitation, not an iTunes one.

  7. 0

    nacho220

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hello again...

    Well it should be pretty simple. I just put a CD into my CD drive...edit the info of the CD in iTunes and then click import CD. Can't think of how it should be any simpler.

    I know that iTunes pulls information from a database for CDs that are inserted into the disc drive. I edit most or all of the information using the iTunes edit info button regardless. If there is no info found I'll have to add, artist, album, song, etc. If the info is there I usually add my own genre and some tags to the comments section. And again... simply insert disc, edit info and then click import CD.

    SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series is a release found digitally that I burned to CD. It is not readily available on a commercially released CD, no. However, I'm just using that as an example. I have lot of music I import be it digital releases I burned to CD or commercially released CDs... in this case there are several Dave Matthews Band commercially released live CDs that fit the same mold as this particular SiriusXM release I used as an example.. and get cut off in the same manner.

    I couldn't rename the particular examples I provided you in iTunes regardless because as I illustrated Windows cuts off the album title at the same point for two albums that are similarly named. And anyways... I should be able to name the albums accordingly without them being cut off. Not having a library full of extremely weird and custom characters just so I can figure out which is which. I should be able to figure out which is which by just reading the album title, in full.

    I understand if the album title is the 255 (or whatever the exact number is) character limit that is imposed by WINDOWS. But I don't have any albums that exceed that character amount.

    The : in the album title is not the cause of the separation. I know Windows compensates for that by putting an underscore...which is fine. I can provide you other examples without a : where it cuts off just the same. So its just that particular example has a : in it...so that's not the matter here.

    I'm not sure I'm doing anything out of the ordinary. Like I said at the top of this reply here... I'm simply putting a CD into the CD drive. Editing the info with the "edit info" option on iTunes and then clicking import CD. I imagine that is the most ordinary thing to do with the software. In fact... even if I didn't edit the info, which I alluded to above... it is still going to cut off the album/song titles in the file name.

    Having my own music along side Apple Music isn't very complicated at all. Not sure where any complication would lie. If I cease using iTunes for managing my digital library of music I own...then I'm still using iTunes to manage Apple Music. So then I'd be using 2 media managers...when I can just use one to manage both...seamlessly alongside each other.

    I'm not sure what else to explain. The conversation is getting a little too complicated I think, in speaking of complication. The problem I have is that when importing a CD through iTunes...the software shortens the file folders and file names it creates.

    Let me ask this then... what other software would be suggested to use to import my music from CD and create digital lossless files that I can then manage in iTunes.... without having iTunes create those digital lossless files?

    Thanks for on the ongoing dialog though. I would guess at some point there could be a way to figure this out so it works correctly since you say iTunes does in fact not truncate folder and file names on your end.


  8. 0

    the fiend

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Well it should be pretty simple. I just put a CD into my CD drive...edit the info of the CD in iTunes and then click import CD. Can't think of how it should be any simpler.

    I agree (for commercially produced audio CDs). So the fact that you find it necessary to...

    edit most or all of the information using the iTunes edit info button regardless

    ... means that you are doing something out of the ordinary. Most entries on Gracenote are now fairly good, but with a library as large as yours, I suggest that what you're doing is maintenance: a bit of cleaning up of the occasional errors. I have to do it. It's simply a fact of life with a large library - mistakes happen.

    SiriusXM Friday Night Concert Series is a release found digitally that I burned to CD.

    As I thought, that's not a commercially produced audio CD. Therefore, you cannot use iTunes to import from your home burnt CD - unless you specifically burned a digital file as an audio CD and then ripped from that CD into iTunes. Please tell me that you're not doing that, but that you are simply adding the digital file to your computer and then using the iTunes command File/Add File to Library, or File/Add Folder to Library. If you take a digital file, put in on CD (either as an MP3 file or as an audio CD), you are making work for yourself and introducing a possible drop in quality. Every format conversion is likely to introduce a drop in audio quality.

    Note that a home burnt CD (burned as an audio CD) will not and cannot be recognised by Gracenote unless you submit the information to Gracenote and clutter up their servers with information specific only to you.

    I'm at a loss as to what to suggest to you. You appear to carrying out a lot of unnecessary steps and have a somewhat complex setup for managing your music. As I stated previously, I have more than 20,000 songs in my Library, including radio shows from various sources and yet I have a simpler setup than you appear to have. I find iTunes does almost everything I need to manage my music. The possible exception is that years ago I purchased a piece of software that catalogues my CD collection, but even that now takes second place now to iTunes.

  9. 0

    the fiend

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    ... and yes, I was making a point about long song titles and their consequent filenames.