Benches Uncategorized

5

Revisted topic: Optimal, normal temperature for ALL MDD dual processors

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I know this has been brought up at the beginning when I jumped on board to the MDD DP 1.25 Mac, but I MUST know now more than ever the truth in terms of what the normal operating temperature should be. I phoned Apple's G4 tech support(Yes, they still support the G4) and they told me that the optimum operating temperature for the processors was between 50 degrees to 95 degrees Fahrenheit. I am not sure what this is in Celcius though.

Ok, currently with nap tools running, the PCI fan card running, and the small-med size fan running in on the floor where the front drive cage is, the temperature of the cpus is now at: 104.06 degrees fahrenheit. When I just did a refresh(time done: 9:53pm 10.25.07) the temperature rose to 106.0 degrees fahrenheit.

When I told Apple the temperatures I was getting before (w/out chud tools), they told me that I am lucky the machine is still running. 125-138 degrees fahrenheit to them seemed like doomsday for my computer - Is this true? I doubt this seriously since my system works like a charm /w no lock ups or freezes.

So, what is it then? 95 degrees fahrenheit or ball park upper 100's(125-135 degrees fahrenheit)?

Also, the good news is that I called to ask them if they have the REVISION B PSU and pabst fan in stock - they do, but they told me I couldn't order them that I had to goto an Apple authorized repair center. When they told me FlompUSA(I hate CompUSA), I immediately started to get annoyed.

I wouldn't take anything to compusa let alone my beloved Apple computer. I want to get a reasonable response for this topic, as I think maybe there is a margin of error which is being blown out of proportion.

Nadav

As for the thermal compound? It seems to be doing its job.

5 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    japamac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi-

    Your temps seem to be within the average for the majority of users who have made reports of their CPU temps. For example, the following:

    http://www.xlr8yourmac.com/feedback/MDDCHUDfeedback.html

    CPU temps of 38-50° C/100-122° F are excellent norms for CPU operation. Anything lower is a bonus. Maximum temps, where problems occur, seem to begin around 59°/138°. Of course all CPU's/system have their own "personalities" so a little "plus/minus" on the temperature range is to be expected.

    I phoned Apple's G4 tech support(Yes, they still support the G4) and they told me that the optimum operating temperature for the processors was between 50 degrees to 95 degrees Fahrenheit. I am not sure what this is in Celcius though.

    For an "operating temp" of 50° F you would have to have the machine in a refrigerator!!!

    I'll stick by "real world" reports from "real users"!! Get real......c'mon guys!

    +50°F- *I can't believe the* ....(he mutters to himself).........+

    Just for fun, try a little experiment. Open "Chess", and have the computer play itself. This is extremely CPU intensive, and you should be able to see what the higher temp ranges of your CPU's are. As well, this will also test your cooling. At some point, if all is well, the temperature should flatline, as the games continue.

  2. 0

    Nadav

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Japanmac,

    We meet again! Are you going to stand in line today and pick up Leopard? I am going to wait until 10.5."1" to come out. Anyway, so what you are saying is no matter how hard I try, or no matter if I do/don't replace the cpu case fan, my system will never be below say 80 degrees fahrenheit? Then also, why did Apple tell me their optimum temperature for the processors was a max of 95 degrees? Doesn't make sense.

    I wish I did not have to run chud tools nap mode, but it seems that its a healthy thing to run nap mode. Is changing the CPU fan worth my time then? As far as power supply, I am going to assume that all efforts in communicating w/Apple about this at this present time are fruitless and not going to accomplish anything. They probably don't have any left overs from 2003 it seems.

    So what to do?

  3. 0

    japamac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi-

    I'm not gonna' stand in any lines. I'm waiting for Leopard to be delivered. Easier, and cheaper- one of the strange realities of living in Japan.....Whether or not 10.5 works in my set up, remains to be seen...all for the fun of it! 🙂

    Really, I don't see how a processor can possibly operate at the temp's that the service rep told you. Common sense dictates that an electrical device (enclosed) cannot operate lower than the ambient air temp being passed over it. Add to that, the demands of load, and the stated 50-95°F are
    impossible for an "operating" system. With the exception of a few brief moments upon first start of the day, a normal processor, with normal cooling, in a normal room (say 78°F) will easily reach 95-100°F soon after startup.

    Add to this that the MDD has
    always had cooling issues (if not, then why PSU fan mod's, etc.) then the evidence to the contrary for the stated operating temp range is overwhelming.

    As I told you in an old post, the temp's around 100°F that you are experiencing are very good, especially for the MDD. These temps are, by no means, dangerous to the integrity of the system. Temps exceeding ±138°F, though, could potentially lead to major problems. I have even seen user reports of temp's exceeding 144°F, though this prompted the user to make extreme mod's to correct cooling deficiencies (and rightfully so).

    As far as PSU, and other fan mod's, there are lots out there, but you are on your own. Of all the mod's that I have seen, adding a fan(s) to the rear of the case, to help pull air through the CPU heatsink, seems to be one of the best options for helping the physical cooling of the processors. Some mod's follow:

    http://www.xlr8yourmac.com/systems/mddcooling_mods/MDD_coolingmods.html

    http://bitsandpieces.info/MDDG4CoolingMod.htm

    http://www.macmod.com/content/view/119/193/

    http://coolstuff.wordpress.com/2007/02/19/powermac-g4-mdd-cooling-and-noise-redu ction/

  4. 0

    Nadav

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Japanmac,

    If you goto the website you gave me at xlr8yourmac.com, I believe it is
    http://www.xlr8yourmac.com/systems/MDDcopper_heatsink_swap/mdd_copper_heatsinkswap.html#storytop

    You will see the exact picture of the thermal heatsink compound I used with my processors. According to this guy, he had no problems at all. But, I might try

    Arctic Silver in the near future.

    Hey, do you know a place other than ebay where I can get just the COPPER heatsink from the 1.42 model? That might be my last mod for this machine. I guess I will have to make due with what I have, as I have no modding experience. I could buy some smaller fans for the top and mount them on top of the power supply or something, or get smaller fans for the heatsink back.

    I haven't decided what I want to do at this point, but replacing the Pabst fan is another mod that I would like to do.

  5. 0

    -JC- Padilla

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I think something got lost in translation somewhere. If you check out the specs, 50º-95ºF is the environmental operating temperature:
    http://support.apple.com/specs/powermac/PowerMac_G4FW800.html

    My new (used) MDD that I got almost 2 weeks ago had a CPU temp running at about 137º-139ºF. I've since applied a kext mod which makes my fans run faster/louder (applied as a -5º mod, any more than that and it's way too noisy), added a Radeon 9800 Pro, an ANTEC LED PCI expansion slot video card fan to help cool it down (still can't tell if it works good), and I even got a Targus Chill Mat to blow some air into the G4's intake (propped up the G4 on a couple pieces of wood to get enough clearance and into the right postition). Right now my CPU temp hovers around 129º. I wouldn't mind getting one of those copper heat sinks, though.