Creating guitar feedback within Logic?
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
What's a good way to create feedback with my electric guitar plugged directly into Logic through a Duet interface?
Also, how do I create feedback in general (ie- If I have a dry audio file of some violins playing and I want to make them feedback)?
Thanks
16 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Bee Jay ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Do you understand what the principles of feedback are? If so, you should be able to recreate that in Logic's mixer.
Be aware that digital feedback inside a software mixer is different to feedback in the real world, the characteristics are different, and it's quite tricky to control.
If you have a amp and create enough volume, you could always do feedback the old school way - an amp and a mic, and just route your tracks to the amp and record the result.
As for the guitar, many amp sims, suitably cranked, can generate feedback, especially if you are playing loud and the pickups can hear your playing.
- 0
Bee Jay ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Do you understand what the principles of feedback are? If so, you should be able to recreate that in Logic's mixer.
Be aware that digital feedback inside a software mixer is different to feedback in the real world, the characteristics are different, and it's quite tricky to control.
If you have a amp and create enough volume, you could always do feedback the old school way - an amp and a mic, and just route your tracks to the amp and record the result.
As for the guitar, many amp sims, suitably cranked, can generate feedback, especially if you are playing loud and the pickups can hear your playing.
- 0
eMagnus ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
To be honest, feedback is one of those concepts where I don't have as much of a grasp on how it works precisely or how to control it. Could you give me a quick and dirty run down?
I understand that it is a signal that is being "fed back" to create a loop of some sort but that still doesn't help me internalize it too much.
- 0
Bee Jay ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Sure. Feedback is largely created with open microphones and speakers at a high volume.
Imagine you're on stage, with a microphone, which is amplifying your voice via the PA system. You make a sound into the microphone, the sound comes out of the PA speakers, and because the mic is open, some of that sound will end up getting back into mic - which is then amplified, comes out of the speakers, and gets down the mic and... so on.
If the mic gain is high, and/or the PA volume is high, more unwanted sound is likely get into that mic and cause feedback. What typically happens is that you don't get feedback until a sufficient level of sound is getting back into the mic to hit the feedback sweet spot - the bit where each time around the loop, more sound gets in the mic, which is amplified more resulting in even more sound getting into the mic resulting in ever higher volumes getting fed back, which is when you get the classic howlround.
So, to create feedback in Logic, you need to route the signal to a channel and feed the output of that channel back into itself - you mostly do that with auxes, sending to an aux and then sending it back to another aux which sends to the first aux etc.
Another way of feedback is feedback delays - use something like the tape delay in Logic, and set sufficiently high feedback values, and the delay tails will feedback, which can be a cool effect.
Some ideas to try anyway - experiment!
- 0
Pancenter ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Bee Jay wrote:
Sure. Feedback is largely created with open microphones and speakers at a high volume.I tried holding my guitar close to computer screen and waving it around (the guitar that is).
That didn't work!
pancenter-
- 0
eMagnus ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Many thanks! I will experiment and see if I can get something happening. I'll even try to feed the signal back into my computer monitor π
- 0
Bee Jay ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I tried holding my guitar close to computer screen and waving it around (the guitar that is).
That didn't work!Try a tele with humbuckers, and turn the gain up some more... π
- 0
Bee Jay ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'll even try to feed the signal back into my computer monitor
Well, actually this is video feedback. Same principle, just with visuals. Point a camcorder at a TV, with the TV displaying the camcorder's video, and you'll get video feedback - the exact same thing is happening, just with light, rather than sound waves.
This is how the opening sequence to Doctor Who (longest running Brit sci-fi TV series) was done for years...
- 0
Vox Johnson ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
- 0
Bee Jay ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Plugin, schmuggin... π
It's good practice to learn to solve problems, and creatively play with audio. Otherwise people start to feel like any solution can be solved with two clicks - one to load a plugin, and the second to pick a preset...
Have you tried this plugin anyway? Any good?
- 0
Dr_Jezz ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Another POV/effect,
as a keyboard player who always wanted feedback, but was stuck in a world without pickups, it was the 'feedback' knob on my delay unit that always fascinated me if only for special FX at the very least π
- 0
Jon H. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Pancenter wrote:
I tried holding my guitar close to computer screen and waving it around (the guitar that is).
That didn't work!
pancenter-
No, it doesn't work like that. You have to wave the screen around. Try and keep the guitar as still as possible so the two don't cancel each other out. If you need to, hire a neighborhood kid to help. I pay the kids on my block union scale and they do a pretty good job.
- 0
timkertoy ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Just to clarify, and unless I missed it elsewhere, guitar feedback is more about the 'acoustic loop' between the guitar amp and the guitar pickups (not microphones).
Of course, guitar pickups are kinda like microphones, so it's the same idea.
But again, just to clarify, the 'classic' guitar feedback sound comes from holding your guitar close enough to the amp so that the pickups and speakers create a feedback loop.
The chain is : guitar pickups --> amp speaker ---> guitar pickups... (repeat, repeat, repeat!).
Guitarists can vary the tone of the feedback by moving the guitar around in front of the amp, and holding down different notes to change the resonant frequencies.
Fun noisy stuff. Watch any old clips of The Who or Hendrix and you should see plenty of quality feedback!
π
- 0
Pancenter ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
timkertoy wrote:
Just to clarify, and unless I missed it elsewhere, guitar feedback is more about the 'acoustic loop' between the guitar amp and the guitar pickups (not microphones).Of course, guitar pickups are kinda like microphones, so it's the same idea.
Yes, exactly... in fact, old guitar pickups can become microphonic when the coil windings get loose, at loud volumes you can speak into the pickups and a small amount of voice will come through the amplifier.
Microphonic pickups will "squeal" when the guitar is placed in the proximity of the speaker, this is caused by loose windings or by the air space between the pickup and it's metal cover. Does anyone remember the old Tele "ashtray" cover on the bridge pickup, the reason players took those off is because they would cause the pickup to squeal like mad.
The classic guitar feedback is a re-amplification of the string vibration. The string, open or fretted reacts to it's own sound coming out of the amplifier and keeps vibrating.
But again, just to clarify, the 'classic' guitar feedback sound comes from holding your guitar close enough to the amp so that the pickups and speakers create a feedback loop.
That was my joke about holding my guitar up to the monitor, just don't forget to include the string into the equation.
pancenter-
- 0
spheric ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Dr_Jezz wrote:
Another POV/effect,as a keyboard player who always wanted feedback, but was stuck in a world without pickups, it was the 'feedback' knob on my delay unit that always fascinated me if only for special FX at the very least π
clavinets get wonderful Feedback.
If the levels are right, you can control it by releasing the damper and opening the lid. π
- 0
tbirdparis ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Ask John Alcock on this forum.. trust me.. he will know everything there is to know about guitar feedback... π