Will Apple ever support the µFT-System (G…
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
It seems like Apple is ignoring the Micro-FourThird System for more than one year now - even the Panasonic G1's RAW-Format, the first of all µFT-cameras isn't supporte bei Apple! This is quite scandalous because this system is so well-accepted by the photographers' community that even the manufactures are overrun by the demand and you've to wait to get some. I would not say that µFT changes the market for photographic gear but what we could see is that its obviously filling a long-opened gap between the bridge-cameras with their small noisy sensors and the heavy and bulky SLRs. With a small lens attached µFT bodies like the PEN or GF1 still fit into a jacket's pocket but offering a nearly SLR-quality and the flexibility of interchangeable lenses and the short FFD makes µFT camera bodies as flexible to adopt other lens types as no other interchangeable lens system.
I don't want to blame other camera concepts - what I want to point out is that µFT is a smart niche as is the Mac, too. A lot of people who think smart buy a Mac and a lot of smart photographers bought µFT equipment in the last year. Every Mac (except for the servers) comes with a really great software setup to make amateur photographers happy and for less than 200 € they can go professional with buying Aperture. Of course, they also could buy Lightroom instead, but that's only half as smart - no system-wide RAW preview, no easy integration into iLife, iWeb, MobileMe etc.
+Come on, Apple - are you blind and deaf? Listen and see what your customers demand - a smart support for a smart camera system in their favorite OS!+
15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Yer_Man ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Welcome to the Apple Discussions.
Do you remember the Terms of Use at all? You agreed to them when you signed up and there's a link to them on the right hand side of every page. As they explain, this is a forum for Users to discuss technical issues with other Users. Apple's developers aren’t here. They don’t promise to read anything here.
No one here knows what Apple may support in the future, or when that may or may not happen. Even if some folks did then the Non-Disclosure Agreements would prevent them from commenting.
Aperture menu -> Provide Aperture Feedback is the route to the developers.
Regards
TD
- 0
Jeremy Henderson ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Terence Devlin wrote:
Welcome to the Apple Discussions.Do you remember the Terms of Use at all? You agreed to them when you signed up and there's a link to them on the right hand side of every page. As they explain, this is a forum for Users to discuss technical issues with other Users. Apple's developers aren’t here. They don’t promise to read anything here.
No one here knows what Apple may support in the future, or when that may or may not happen. Even if some folks did then the Non-Disclosure Agreements would prevent them from commenting.
Aperture menu -> Provide Aperture Feedback is the route to the developers.
And there's no evidence at all that Apple developers read or take the slightest notice of "feedback".
As far as I can see, the OP was not doing anything other than making a rhetorical plea for Apple to wake up and support an important class of camera. I'm sure that he is under no illusion that it will lead to anything other than helping his blood pressure.
- 0
rshammaa ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I am as incensed as anyone on this matter.
It seems though, because these cameras do not write DNG RAW files which Aperture says it can read, a DNG file converter from Adobe will convert RAW images from your camera into DNG files readable by Aperture. It's a workaround solution of course - not the ideal solution.
Someone better versed than I am ought to offer comment on this possibility.
- 0
F Shippey ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
And there's no evidence at all that Apple developers read or take the slightest notice of "feedback".
As far as I can see, the OP was not doing anything other than making a rhetorical plea for Apple to wake up and support an important class of camera. I'm sure that he is under no illusion that it will lead to anything other than helping his blood pressure.
The Feedback route is the way Apple has designed to let users address issues with Apple Engineers.
http://www.apple.com/feedback/aperture.htmlYou will not get a reply, but at least you have submitted your information/request in a more useful manner than posting in these Forums.
- 0
schmidt9 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thank you for this advice - unfortunately, DNG is a moving target in terms of compatibility. The DNGs converted by the Adobe DNG Converter are not supported by Aperture in a lot of cases. Probably there are a thousand additions to DNG like lens distortion characteristics or vignetting correction of specific lenses which are not supported by Aperture.
I had the same problem with my Sony DSC-R1, which was finally supported by Apple when Sony already stopped selling this model. The DNGs from the Adobe Converter did not work with Aperture.
Unfortunately Apple is often slow in supporting not-so-popular camera modells. I had that the first time with my Lumix DMC-L1 - the support in Aperture/iPhoto came so late, that my camera was close to it’s retirement.
- 0
Charles E. Flynn ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
- 0
Jeremy Henderson ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
F Shippey wrote:
And there's no evidence at all that Apple developers read or take the slightest notice of "feedback".
As far as I can see, the OP was not doing anything other than making a rhetorical plea for Apple to wake up and support an important class of camera. I'm sure that he is under no illusion that it will lead to anything other than helping his blood pressure.
The Feedback route is the way Apple has designed to let users address issues with Apple Engineers.
http://www.apple.com/feedback/aperture.htmlYou will not get a reply, but at least you have submitted your information/request in a more useful manner than posting in these Forums.
I don't think the OP was addressing an issue with Apple engineers, so the feedback route was not relevant. Whether it is more useful to submit requests via that route remains to be seen - I'm sure plenty of people have requested that their MFT camera be supported, and the response has been zilch.
At this point it seems just as valuable to do something useless but therapeutic as it is to send blind messages to /dev/null at apple.com.
- 0
F Shippey ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
At this point it seems just as valuable to do something useless but therapeutic as it is to send blind messages to /dev/null at apple.com.
Since this is a 'user helping user' forum, the result will be the same with either approach.
The Feedback page is the appropriate way to go. Of course, there is never any guaranty that all 'wishes will be granted'; most of us learned that before we turned 10 years old.
- 0
Yer_Man ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
1. This is the poster's first post on the forum. I have no idea if s/he read the Terms of Use or not. Hence I suggested the route that Apple recommends for getting through to them. I have no more idea than you if it is of any use, but it is what's recommended by them.
2. If the only purpose of these threads is to vent, then henceforward can we label these threads "useless but therapeutic"?
Regards
TD
- 0
Jeremy Henderson ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
F Shippey wrote:
At this point it seems just as valuable to do something useless but therapeutic as it is to send blind messages to /dev/null at apple.com.
Since this is a 'user helping user' forum, the result will be the same with either approach.
Possibly, but if you were the Aperture product manager, arguing for resources to support MFT cameras, what would you do? First, show the sales figures for those cameras, and point out that each one represented a potential customer who was not going to buy Aperture as it stands. Second, point out the number of threads like this one, with existing Aperture users - potential upgraders - ****** off by their camera (not new, not obscure) being ignored.
The Feedback page is the appropriate way to go. Of course, there is never any guaranty that all 'wishes will be granted'; most of us learned that before we turned 10 years old.
Good to hear about your life skills. I think most of us are pretty familiar with what wishes are worth. But now we can do something about it when our dreams don't come true - we can go play with the toys at the Adobe house.
- 0
William Lloyd ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
So what if you do the research on the micro 4/3 cameras and see that they are < 5% of the market? How many of the "each one"s does it take to justify the effort? Because everyone has an Internet voice, and each person can kvetch here, but I don't know whether the numbers would justify the effort.
I can't say, as I don't have the market data. Though I don't think that a few threads, or maybe even 100 threads, here will do much more than make the signal:noise ratio tiring to those that try and assist, even though we have nothing to do with creating Aperture itself.
- 0
schmidt9 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thank you very much for this very warm and friendly welcome here...
... it was mostly as warm-hearted as the siberian winter we have actually in middle europe.
As a user - more clearly: as a long-time Apple user - I've got a problem: my preferred camera system is not supported by my preferred computer maker. I'm not alone in the middle of the dessert, I've got a good number of friends with the same problem.
As this board claims to be a ›discussion‹-board, I'd thought to write about my problem and my thoughts at this place. Some User might find it relevant and might come up with some nice little hints or some gossip... Except of one(!) helping hand I've got a treatment like I've burned the star-spangled banner. For some Apple user it might be the same to criticize Apple or to burn the U.S. flag - but in Europe with got this nice tradition of constructive criticism. I didn't expect something special when I posted my thoughts a few ours ago - but I didn't expect anything like these reactions.
If there is someone out with more news on support or at least workarounds for µFT cameras on the Mac - I'd be lucky to hear from you to discuss the real issue. For all the other: Good night, and good luck!
- 0
Jeremy Henderson ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
As an interim measure, I import both RAW and JPG, and for my best shots I process the RAW files in CaptureOne and import the TIF files to Aperture.
I have some investment in Aperture, in terms of time, and money (plugins) so I won't ditch it just now, but the time approaches.
- 0
Jeremy Henderson ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
William Lloyd wrote:
So what if you do the research on the micro 4/3 cameras and see that they are < 5% of the market? How many of the "each one"s does it take to justify the effort? Because everyone has an Internet voice, and each person can kvetch here, but I don't know whether the numbers would justify the effort.You could well be right, and your comments apply just as much to feedback requests. Apple can see the numbers plain enough, and seem to have taken the decision that it's not worth their time to bother with the lens correction, or whatever. Hopefully this is a temporary situation.
I can't say, as I don't have the market data. Though I don't think that a few threads, or maybe even 100 threads, here will do much more than make the signal:noise ratio tiring to those that try and assist, even though we have nothing to do with creating Aperture itself.
No need to be tired. These threads are easy enough to identify and avoid, if that's what you want to do. I'm sure that the readers of this forum are grateful to you for sharing your knowledge, but on this topic I (personally) think that "Apple right or wrong" is not a useful approach.
- 0
grizzly marmot ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I do not know if the current model of a RAW converter and DAM application all-in-one has much future. At the dawn DLSR popularity there was a cry for a universal format for RAW (i.e. DNG). If we had moved in that direction all would be well with Aperture and new cameras. But as we have moved forward, RAW has become even more complex - it now includes noise reduction and multiple lens correction factors and probably even more. The only way I can see Aperture as viable for the foreseeable future is if there is some kind of plug-in RAW converter where the manufacturer supplies the plug-in. This may not be a good option due to workflow speed issues. If any corporation has clout to get the camera manufacturers to create plug-ins that can work with Aperture - it is Apple.