Benches Uncategorized

3

MP3 to AAC

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Sorry to ask (I am sure this has been covered a few times).. can't seem to find anything quickly through search..

Anyway, I would like to make some room on my HDD (mainly for upcoming iPad) at the moment my library is around 117GB. Now a lot of the tracks were 320 Bitrate MP3 or 256VBR. I have already made a smart list with 'bitrate greater than 240+ and started to convert the tracks to 192VBR (saving space)

Now, someone told me that 128AAC would have been a better option (smaller file, better or similar quality)

Question is, because I have already converted down to 192VBR once, would converting 'again' affect the quality?

What I mean is should i have just gone to 128AAC from the original file (320/256 etc) in the first place?

I really, really don't want to import from the masters again..

I have backed up my library so I could go down to 128AAC from this or hopefully someone will say converting once to 192VBR and then to 128AAC won't make any difference to the quality.

Sorry, one more thing... should I use 128AAC 'VBR'

Appreciate

3 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Jolly Giant

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    ashtongate wrote:

    ... someone told me that 128AAC would have been a better option (smaller file, better or similar quality)

    you cannot
    gain quality by converting from one lossy audio format to another.

    Question is, because I have already converted down to 192VBR once, would converting 'again' affect the quality?

    yes.

    What I mean is should i have just gone to 128AAC from the original file (320/256 etc) in the first place?

    yes.

    I have backed up my library so I could go down to 128AAC from this or hopefully someone will say converting once to 192VBR and then to 128AAC won't make any difference to the quality.

    it will.

  2. 0

    ashtongate

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for the reply...

    Got all your points.. just picking up on the first one.

    I certainly don't want or expect to gain quality but if saving more space by going to 128AAC compared to 192VBR MP3 without affecting quality (I mean 128AAC is comparable to 192VBR MP3) than that will probably be the chosen format for me.

    Can anyone advise on the above?

    And if it should be 128AAC should I choose 128AAC VBR

    Sorry in advance for my questions..

    Thanks so much

    Message was edited by: ashtongate

  3. 0

    ed2345

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    ashtongate wrote:

    I certainly don't want or expect to gain quality but if saving more space by going to 128AAC compared to 192VBR MP3 without affecting quality (I mean 128AAC is comparable to 192VBR MP3) than that will probably be the chosen format for me.

    Can anyone advise on the above?

    Most people find that 128 AAC is fine for iPod use. But I suggest that you do a few and see how it sounds in your own listening conditions before converting 1000's of tracks.

    And if it should be 128AAC should I choose 128AAC VBR

    In iTunes, VBR is interpreted as the minimum bitrate, so a 128 AAC VBR will be a bigger file than a 128 AAC CBR, by about 10%. Personally I use CBR, but again you should do a few and listen carefully and form your own judgments.