Benches Uncategorized

3

G5 Dual 2.5 Liquid Cooled - Repaired and alread...

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I own a G5 dual 2.5 Ghz. This computer suffered a liquid-coolant leak in March 2009. In April - after much pressure - Apple agreed to repair the entire computer at no charge. Now, less than one year later, the computer is exhibiting all the signs that it's "bleeding out" again: - excessive fan use for the simplest of tasks, inability to zap PRAM, "pinwheel of death" and otherwise unusual, inexplicable system behavior.

Has anyone else also experienced a repeat liquid coolant failure? I'm getting pretty burned out that I'm once again facing the replacement of a major investment. If anyone has experienced a repeat failure have you attempted to have Apple repair?

3 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Maybe it would be in the AYM article:

    http://www.xlr8yourmac.com/systems/G5coolantleaks.html

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi NFM,

    Welcome to the Apple Discussions.

    I haven't been to these forums in a while since I moved on but it's sad to see the same issues being reported now as were back then when I was here trying to figure out the problems of my owns G5's, 3 in all.

    I'm not all that surprised you're experiencing these problems again, though like you I would think a fix like you had would last longer than this has. On the other hand since Apple gave up trying to fix the G5's and their heat issues and went Intel instead, what parts and designs they have to work with are still the poor parts and designs that were originally used. So essentially they just replaced junk with junk.
    Almost a quarter of all G5s made were dead or dying around the 3 year old mark. And while Apple attempted to deal with some of problems as they arose, they pretty much knew from the start that PPC CPUs could not handle the stress and heat required of them. There are other design flaws as well.
    To put perspective on this you have to remember that when the G5s came out Apple and Intel were still in a running battle about who made the fastest computers and who could get them to you the fastest. Short sighted decisions were made on both sides. The implications for Apple though were machines that burned bright for a time but burned out fast. Anyone who still has one that works well should consider themselves lucky and start saving money for a new Mac.
    But while a lot of people knew what Apple knew, that the machines were seriously flawed, in terms of longevity at least, Apple never said a word admitting anything and hasn't to this day. The truth is they owe a lot of people enormous sums of their money back for buying them.

    Last I was here this number, 1-800-767-2775, an Apple customer satisfaction dept. number, was the only way people were getting some justice from Apple. I believe it's this number that people on the page the Hatter listed, used to get their Macs fixed for free, at a lesser price, or sometimes even replaced with a new MP.
    I think it may be a hope for you also to get some, but probably not enough, satisfaction on your issues. It's sounds like you've already played the game well once with them. The best results are obtained by being persistent, mannered and stone cold calm when you're on the phone with them. Just call and call, and call.

    Yes, I loved my G5's, and my earlier Macs, but my previous Mac fanatic glow has been gone ever since that time. Discovering later that Apple knew almost the whole time that there were unfixable problems with the G5s and they continued to sell them anyway and reap heavy profits from their most loyal customers,... still sickens me to this day.

    So far though, it seems Apple has learned a few things since that time. The current Mac Pros and those a little earlier are fantastic machines. The kind that people expected on faith in Apple to see back then, but never did.

    Good luck,... get Apple to do what they will, and in my opinion get rid of it, or keep it as a backup for a much better MP, as tainted by Intel as they are.

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    PowerMac G5 internal take-apart photos

    http://nysoyan.free.fr/Eaglefour/PowermacG5.html