Benches Uncategorized

4

The gift of music: burning a disc for fri…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I wonder if anyone can advise me here.

I want to burn a music CD and give it as a gift to my friend.

Can anyone advise me on where I stand, legally, in the following cases:

1. I own the music, my friend does not.

2. I own the music, my friend also owns the music.

3. My friend owns the music, I do not.

The first two are quite straightforward. The last is a little more complicated.

Say, for example, my friend wanted a CD of their own music burned. Is there a way they could grant me access to those files to burn it for them - I would never listen to the files myself, and they would own the disc.

This started as a practical idea, but now I am just interested in where DRM and the law stands with this sort of thing, in theory.

Any thoughts or references appreciated!

4 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    varjak paw

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Is there a way they could grant me access to those files to burn it for them - I would never listen to the files myself, and they would own the disc.

    If your friend legally owns the tracks, loans you the original CD(s) or provides you with the files, you burn the disk for them (and
    only for that friend, not for other friends as well), and then you erase any copies of the files from any device you own and don't make an extra copy of the burned CD for yourself, that should be legal.

    Note that if the tracks carry any DRM, you would have to be authorized to the friend's account for wherever s/he purchased the tracks so that you could play and burn them. This would be a grey areas for most download stores, but as long as you relinquish the the authorization once done, it would probably be acceptable.

    Caveat: I'm no lawyer and no expert on UK copyright laws. But I do work regularly with media rights issues so I'm reasonably confident in the correctness of my answer.

    Message was edited by: Dave Sawyer

  2. 0

    KingLeigh

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    That's very insightful, thank you.

    Do you have any idea where I'd need to look to attempt to verify that? Which Terms and conditions I'd be having to dig up, for example. I assume its a little outside the scope of iTunes T&Cs.

    Also, since you appear to have some knowledge of the area... do you have any thoughts on giving MP3s as gifts? Is it possible for me to purchase an mp3, with the intention of giving ownership of it to another party? Or buy it on their behalf, for instance.

    Thanks again for your input.

  3. 0

    Chris CA

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    It is copyright maerial.

    If you purcahsed it, you can keep it. You cannot make copies for friends (and vice-versa).

    do you have any thoughts on giving MP3s as gifts? Is it possible for me to purchase an mp3, with the intention of giving ownership of it to another party?

    In iTunes, you can "gift" a song to someone. Select the song(s) and at teh Buy button, select *Gift this*. You pay for it and an email is sent to the friend then they can download it. You do not get to download a gift to someone else.

  4. 0

    varjak paw

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Do you have any idea where I'd need to look to attempt to verify that? Which Terms and conditions I'd be having to dig up, for example. I assume its a little outside the scope of iTunes T&Cs.

    You would have to consult UK copyright law, or a copyright lawyer, since it's primarily a legal issue rather than a contractual one. I doubt that it will be worth your time and effort (and certainly not the expense of consulting a lawyer). As long as you don't keep the tracks yourself in any way and don't give the burned CD or copies of the tracks to anyone else other than the friend who owns them (or worst of all make them available via a web site or P2P network), no one will bother you about the issue.

    Also, since you appear to have some knowledge of the area... do you have any thoughts on giving MP3s as gifts? Is it possible for me to purchase an mp3, with the intention of giving ownership of it to another party? Or buy it on their behalf, for instance.

    In most cases no, the terms of use of the download store do not allow that. The terminology usually says that the purchase "is for your personal use only" and do not provide for any transfer of ownership. Some stores, such as the iTunes Store, allow you to give someone a track or album - they get a code which they can redeem and download the track themselves - so that is usually the best option. Note that the iTunes Store does not sell tracks in MP3 format; it probably won't be a problem, though, unless the person you wish to give the gift cannot for some reason use iTunes (in which case they couldn't redeem the gift anyway).