Benches Uncategorized

13

Using multiple midi controllers simultane…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

This may seem like its got an obvious answer, but I am trying to figure out how to use MS with multiple controllers in a live situation. Is there a way to have 3 to 4 keyboards playing sounds independently in MS and control all changes independently? Perhaps utilizing something like the MOTU MIDI Express 8x8?

THANKS!

13 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    gr8handsman

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I am using two yamaha controllers, one 88 key, and one 61, in the layout window I started with a blank screen. You start by adding the keyboards first, then set the midi channels for each keyboard you are using. I have one on channel (1) and the other on channel (5). Then above each physical keyboard on the workspace you assign the knobs , sliders and buttons. You have to learn EVERY SINGLE ONE.

    Hit the save button often. I would start with one keyboard at a time. And then add the second and then the third. You must have 4 gig of ram to play two or three sounds at the same time.

  2. 0

    aerol

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    - Go into Layout mode and add a keyboard object for every physical controller

    - Select the first keyboard on screen and hit the Learn button on the left

    - Play a note on the physical controller

    - Select the second on-screen keyboard (you should still be in Learn mode) and hit a note on the second controller.

    - Repeat for all 4

    - Switch to Edit mode

    - Add channel strips to the mixer for all the sounds you want, lets say you add 4.. one for each controller

    - Select the first channel strip

    - Select the MIDI Input tab along the bottom

    - Use the Keyboard popup in this tab and choose the controller you want to play that sound using

    - Repeat for all 4

    This will allow you to play all 4 channel strips form different keyboards.

  3. 0

    drumthumb

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I did it by trial and error and ended up doing it just like Aerol suggested. It is a very intuitive program (thank god).

    But the only problem I have now is trying to figure out how to have each keyboard change patches independently.

  4. 0

    rdellapi

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I had a hard time with this too, originally. You have to change your way of thinking. Don't think about each keyboard having its own patch. You'll have one patch at a time in Mainstage, that all keyboards use. I've found that the best solution is to set up each patch (I have one patch per song but you can do it however you want) with multiple channel strips, each strip with its own MIDI channel, and the on-the-fly changes that I make are actually to change the transmitting MIDI channel of the controllers. You have to add as many keyboards (or MIDI activity indicators in MS2) to your layout as MIDI channels that you'll use, and name them appropriately so that in the your channel strips you'll know which channel is assigned.

    To make things easier on my CPU, I put some channel strips at the set or concert level (then used aliases when I upgraded to MS2). For example, piano is at the concert level on MIDI channel 5, so I always know that I have piano on 5 unless a specific patch overrides 5 for some reason.

    Let me know if that helps!

  5. 0

    drumthumb

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for the ideas. It sounds like that will work perfectly. There are some times, however, that I have 3 separate keyboardists each on a different patch and they need to control their patch changes independently. I think the only way around it is to come up with some fancy patch changing or have each keyboardists on their own Mac w/MS

  6. 0

    dhjdhj

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You can't have it both ways --- either your keyboardists agree to sync to a master controller (MainStage) or they do their own thing. Anything else will be chaos.

    I'm using 7 keyboards live, (some are just controllers, some have internal synths) and about 5 other external sound modules as well as softsynths inside MainStage.

    I've programmed everything based on songs rather than on sounds and so MainStage is configured to just send whatever is needed to switch every single synth (or keyboard) used by a particular song to a patch associated with the song. This is true even if the same sound is used on a single synth for multiple sounds....the sound will be defined on multiple patches for that synth, named by the song.

    That way, it's very easy to glance at all devices if necessary to check that everything is set for the desired song.

    E.g, if I'm playing Red Rain, every single synth/keyboard in my rig had better say "Red Rain". There's also the useful side benefit, if for some reason something didn't change (which has happened), it's much easier to manually change a synth to a patch representing the song name rather than trying to remember what sound that synth is supposed to be doing.

  7. 0

    Fabian Barbin

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    what are you using to send patch changes. Mainstage? how is this all set up. I used to use 4 keyboards and 2 modules on stage but I used a Roland A90 to send all patch changes and midi merges. Now i'm starting all over and was thinnking about using Mainstage or Ableton Live for patch changes, midi merges, sounds. etc. Help I've been out of the loop with new equipment. Kinda scared of using computer on stage.

  8. 0

    dhjdhj

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    MainStage sends bank and program changes out to all the external MIDI devices as its patch is changed.

    I change the MS patch itself either from a foot controller (up and down) or by just clicking on the desired patch from the set list. In some cases, I have added a "chaining" button so that depending on what patch I have up, pressing the SAME button on one of my controllers will cause MS to switch to the patch referenced by the first patch.

  9. 0

    torsig1967

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Actually there's a way to have each keyboard controlling their own "patch" changes, which is a good thing when playing highly improvised music.

    The trick is to use third party plugins that responds to program change. Usually these are plugins which have their own program banks. Examples are plugins from G-force, Waldorf, Korg and (I think) NI.

    Then what you have to do is assign a Midi CC which you are not using and map that to Program Change in the plugin.

    Assign it to a knob and then in edit mode assign this knob to:

    Plugin>Midi Controller>Program Change.

    In EXS 24 it's also possible to route midi action to next/previous instrument in a similar fashion.

    Message was edited by: torsig1967

  10. 0

    valgreen

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    There is even a simpler way for many keyboards players change their patch independently... I heard that if you duplicate Mainstage application and change its name (e.x. MS n1, MS n2,..) you can run many of them and use a file dedicated for each player (assigning the right MIDI input and even using independent audio output if needed, by conecting a multiple outputs audio interface.

    I dont know how many instances can a single computer hold, it might depend on overall memory used and cpu demand for some plugins, but it's worth giving it a try.

    valgreen

  11. 0

    torsig1967

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Using a multiple output interface should work even when running one instance.

    Anyway, it sounds a bit risky to do this. There might be conflicts if they are trying to share resources at the same time. And what about preferences, will an update of the preferences in one instance overwrite the preferences of the other one?

    Anyway if tested thouroughly without trouble I might try this.

  12. 0

    Fabian Barbin

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    i can't believe nobody answered your question. I'd like to know too. When i start using mainstage. Doing my research now.

  13. 0

    Doug Zangar

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Aerol's way is the best way to do it. The only thing I can add is if you want to save on screen real estate and don't need a keyboard icon, you should be able to use the MIDI activity button instead.