Benches Uncategorized

2

My 2 cents regarding album artist

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I am exceptionally anal when it comes to file naming and tagging so it came as quite a surprise when I discovered Apple decided to call the TPE2 id3v2 frame "Album Artist". The definition, according to the standard, is "Band/orchestra/accompaniment" (see
http://id3.org/id3v2.3.0 for reference.) It is intended to hold additional information about the performers in the recording. On the other hand, TPE1 (aka "Artist") is intended for the main artist(s).

Issues surrounding the TPE2 tag are primarily those involving compilations and featured artists.

iTunes provides an option to mark tracks as being part of a compilation and does so using a non-standard "TCMP" tag. Extending a standard is a bad idea. Further, I've seen discussions where people suggest using the TPE2 ("Album Artist") tag to indicate the name of the artist who created the compilation. Ignoring the id3 standard definition for TPE2 is also a bad idea. It is totally unnecessary to provide a mechanism to mark tracks as being part of a compilation - if the name of the album matches on a set of tracks but the artist does not, then it must be a compilation.

Regarding featured artists, there is an article (
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=7491444&#7491444) which suggests that both artists should appear in the TPE1 ("Artist") tag, and the actual artist of the album should appear in the TPE2 ("Album Artist") tag. This is incorrect. TPE2 holds additional information about the performers in a recording, such as additional artists! Given a track like "Tosca - Oscar (Featuring Anna Clementi)", the TPE1 ("Artist") tag should be "Tosca", and the TPE2 tag should be "Anna Clementi" (the name of the track itself is "Oscar".) In addition, TPE1 should be the primary sorting tag. iTunes likes to sort by TPE2 if it exists, ignoring TPE1 - a result of Apple's incorrect implementation of the id3v2 standard.

Note that there are two additional artist-related tags - TPE3 ("Conductor/performer refinement"), and TPE4 ("Interpreted, remixed, or otherwise modified by".)

It would be nice to have Apple make these changes though unlikely at this point.

2 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Chris CA

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Keep in mind you are discussing an informal standard (ID3 tag version 2.3.0).

    Regarding featured artists, there is an article (
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=7491444&#7491444) which suggests that both artists should appear in the TPE1 ("Artist") tag, and the actual artist of the album should appear in the TPE2 ("Album Artist") tag. This is incorrect.

    PT is talking about how to get iTunes to display songs with "featured" artists in the same album, using iTunes. The actual tags (TPE1, TPE2) are irrelevant to the user.

    a result of Apple's incorrect implementation of the id3v2 standard.

    Since it is an informal standard, they can't get it "incorrect". They can do it different than this informal standard proposes.

    Since Apple does not follow exactly ID3 tag version 2.3.0, users need to set the tags so they will work according to the application (iTunes) they are using.

    You can send Apple feedback here ->
    http://www.apple.com/feedback/itunesapp.html

  2. 0

    freelancer

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Doc_ wrote:

    It is totally unnecessary to provide a mechanism to mark tracks as being part of a compilation - if the name of the album matches on a set of tracks but the artist does not, then it must be a compilation.

    Not at all. Two completely different albums by two completely different artists can have the same name.

    Note that there are two additional artist-related tags - TPE3 ("Conductor/performer refinement"), and TPE4 ("Interpreted, remixed, or otherwise modified by".)

    The problem is that the standard is wholly inadequate for music organization. Apple's implementation is, too, of course, but I'd rather have Apple do it right than have them follow a standard that isn't up to the task.

    What it needs is the ability to have multiple artists on a track. Multiple entries for Composer, too. I also want a field for Arranger, which is at least as interesting as Composer. And multiple genres for a song -- it's really annoying that this isn't present.

    I don't care in the least, slightest bit about the standard, since the standard doesn't get it right, either.