Benches Uncategorized

4

CIRCULAR STRUCTURE

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Editing multiple midi regions in the Matrix editor, we received this error message in the studio on multiple G5s and G4s...

"Circular Structure!

Please report to Apple how you did this...

Try emptying the trash."

Can one not edit multiple midi performances? We were simply attempting to copy two midi performances (strings and bass in EXS) and place them two bars later in the song.

Midi fuctionality is being sadly overlooked...

After this "Circular Structure" error occurs, entire sections (LARGE portions) of a session are missing. This is VERY disturbing.

Any help here would be appreciated.

Tyler

Earle-Tones Music

4 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Mark Isham

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    As an append...

    After hitting "cancel" on the "Circular Structure" message...the following message is...

    "Warning! Not enough memory!

    This operation cannot be undone."

  2. 0

    uniquorn

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The 'funny' thing is this bug seems to have been carried over from the emagic logic 5 days. It used to appear at some point -have never been able to reproduce it really- and state 'Please report to Emagic how you did this'. In some cases I was able to actually save the song, reboot and continue work without any data loss.

    Apple obviously was able to change the warning message but not it's original cause.

    Another reminder for
    http://www.apple.com/feedback/logic.html

  3. 0

    Paul Harlyn

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Mark

    I also remember this error from logic 5. If it doesn't fix itself after re boot, I remember having to reload the files into a new song as my song became corrupted. Also you can try to go a older saved version before the message appeared.

    Good luck

  4. 0

    Mark Isham

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I posted this in another topic, but worth a shot here too. See if you can recreate these abnormalities...

    Here's exactly what creates it on our systems...

    Create several performances with an EXS, Ivory, RealGuitar, Atmosphere, what have you.

    Go to the matrix edit page.

    Double click the matrix edit so that all midi performaces are visible.

    Select a portion of the performances (so that two or more performances are selected at the same time).

    Shift + Option click the selected performances (to copy) and drag them two bars down.

    Now Control click the selected performances that have been copied and moved, and drag them around. Control click allows a free positioning, without snapping. THIS IS WHERE IT OCCURS.

    Upon Control Clicking in the Matrix edit, after having copied and moved multiple midi performances at one time, the "Circular Structure" occures.

    Anyone, everyone. Try this on your system with a NEW sequence you don't mind losing.

    Let me know your results.

    Tyler

    Earle-Tones Music