Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
There has been much discussion about the new ProRes codecs and that has raised a few questions concerning my workflow. How can I ingest my XDCAM files using the log and transfer? I have been using the Sony XDCAM transfer and would like to try to edit in ProRes LT. When I try the log and transfer, it does not see my disc that is mounted on the desktop. The reason for wanting to use the log and transfer is I have been told I can use that method to transcode to ProRes on ingest. Is that correct?
And, that brings up the BIG question. Will my editing day go smoother if I edit in ProRes LT as compared to staying native XDCAM HD? Shane? Jerry? Andy? Patrick? I could ingest using SDI in and the Kona card, but I have really become a fan of file based input. Many questions, but I hope some input from you guys will settle once and for all.
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hey Thomas
How can I ingest my XDCAM files using the log and transfer?
If you're working with the XDCAM EX variant of XDCAM HD then you use FCP's built-in Log and Transfer to do it, but you need Sony's FCP Log and Transfer plugin for the format (PDZK-LT) which you can get here; http://www.sony.ca/xdcamex/software.htm
The reason for wanting to use the log and transfer is I have been told I can use that method to transcode to ProRes on ingest. Is that correct?
Nope that's not correct ... just like the XDCAM Transfer app, you can only can only rewrap the XDCAM codec essence (the actual video/audio data) as Quicktime movies. If you want to work in ProRes then you need to transcode the native ingest after the fact, or capture direct using Log and Capture (baseband capture via suitable I/O hardware eg SDI and your Kona card)
And, that brings up the BIG question. Will my editing day go smoother if I edit in ProRes LT as compared to staying native XDCAM HD?
The majority of folks who work directly with native XDCAM HD have no issues whatsoever, its a natively supported codec in FCP, it looks gorgeous and has a low data rate ... but nonetheless its a Long GOP (MPEG2) based format and that makes it a computationally intensive format for your system to handle. Would working in ProRes be "smoother" ... yes, I think it would.
Best
Andy
0
Thomas Whaley·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Andy. Thank you. That answered it perfectly! I will stay in XDCAM HD and not ruminate about it. Now if I can get those pesky Motion files to play nice in the timeline. What preset should I use when I create Motion files? Again, thanks for all of your expertise.
Best,
Tom
0
Andy Mees·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Cool. If you're going to work in XDCAM HD as your source and sequence format then you can still enjoy some of the benefits of ProRes along the way... I'd recommend switching your Sequence Settings >> Render Control tab >> Render Codec to Apple ProRes 422. That'll gain you some advantage in interim render time whilst working in the timeline. Similarly when you export your final master then I'd recommend exporting as Apple ProRes 422 as well, no need to use XDCAM HD as the mastering format unless you are archiving to XDCAM HD disc. As for what format to use for your Motion files ... you guessed it, go with Apple ProRes 422 again. ProRes works really well in an XDCAM timeline.
0
Thomas Whaley·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Andy. Thanks! I can sleep better tonight. Always so much to learn. But it is still fun. I have been editing since the days of Sony 1/2 inch tape, then U-Matic, Time Base Correctors, M-II and all the rest. Still enjoy it. And it is because of pros like you guys that it IS still fun. Thanks again.
Best,
Tom
0
Andy Mees·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
You're very welcome Thomas ... the tools evolve constantly, but a good editor is like a fine wine.
Take care, and keep the edits coming 🙂
Best
Andy
0
dedit·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
HI. i was wondering the exact same thing. I thought that I could log and transfer my xdcam ex footage to apple pro res 422. I will stick with the ex codec. It looks great. I guess this will be ok for broadcast?
These forums are amazing. You can find pretty much anything. Thanks guys.