Benches Uncategorized

10

G5 Failures With UPS

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

It appears there may be some folks that are experiencing what seem to be unexpected failures of a G5 tower.

Anyone that takes the time to do a search in the forums can easily see that their are those that have repeatedly stressed the use of a properly rated, automatic voltage regulated uninterruptible power supply, or UPS.

Seeing that the world's power grid seems to be getting worse by the day this is sage advice but I digress.

I'd like to hear from users that have experienced failures while using a UPS. What were the circumstances? Did you have all of your peripherals attached or just the computer? When you did have a failure did you contact the UPS manufacturer with regards to their insurance coverage, if any, for damage to your system and if so what were the results?

For those of you that have experienced failures I know that it is an unpleasant experience and often makes you want to beat your head against wall. However, in an effort to establish a real cause, I'd like to know a little bit about real world experiences involving a UPS.

10 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You of all people know we had huge threads on UPS when the G5 came out; again when the Quad debuted.

    And of course what else is on the same circuit.

    People are often surprised and don't buy adequate VA for what a system requires, and it depends on the quality of PSU and how or if it handles inrush current properly.

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Agreed, thus my comment with regards to doing a search.

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'm subscribing to this thread.

    And, of course, surge protected power strips don't count......

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    "And, of course, surge protected power strips don't count"

    Of course. We are looking for sag-protection here.

  5. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    if the ups is so critical, particularly for G5's, I would think Apple would announce this loud and clear so all of us would have one less hassle. Is the purpose of this thread to determine whether ups is effective? or how effective?

  6. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I wasn't around here when the Quads debuted but I don't doubt that for an expensive piece of electronics, fellow Mac users would advise other users on protecting their Macs to the best of their ability. But I don't recall Apple doing so. I don't recall anything in my Quad manual saying a $200+ device was necessary for keeping it working.
    And I don't know how a UPS would prevent cracked memory slots, poorly designed LCS's that leak, and a processor so hot that even Apple itself knew that something had to go. It's getting hard to take this knee-jerk defense of Apple when they themselves threw out the PPC processor and went Intel. The result? Fairly trouble free Macs. And to have almost a quarter of G5s have some kind of issue, is, just too much. I'm sure Apple would have put notices out saying a UPS would be a cure for all the above listed problems.

    Too, when someone gets another Mac every two years, I sincerely doubt they have ever encountered the problems that other users have over a period of years. I believe that info should have been right up front. (not you, hatter)

    Apple learned from their mistakes and made some drastic changes. The Mac Pros they make now are extraordinarily fine, built like a rock. But according to some of the comments I read, why did they ever do anything different when their previous G5s worked just fine?

    I know threads about dead G5s are tiring and there are tons of them. That should say something right there. I know especially because I used to fill these pages myself about my ailing G5s. But I have a hard time forgiving those who pointed the blame right back at me without a doubt in their mind that Apple played the biggest role in my problems. If that's the attitude one takes then just come out and say it, "You wrong, Apple right", and go away quietly.

    <Edited by Host>

    Message was edited by: Samsara

  7. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    As you can see I have several questions around the use of a UPS, and I am curious as to what effect using one has had on PMG5 longevity and what the results have been when the machine fails. Some of those UPS manufacturers offer $25,000 insurance against computer damage.

    I've never heard of a car manufacturer telling someone that they needed auto insurance either. Why in the world would someone spend a few grand on a professional level computer without $200 worth of insurance?

    Interesting, though, that not one user has yet reported a dead Mac used with a UPS. That should tell you something.

  8. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    interesting yes, but I'm not seeing where your data comes from;
    was this common knowledge from previous threads? Maybe folks did not know to mention that part in their earlier complaints about their problems. Is it really possible that the lead-free solder (and those other known faults) would deteriorate so much with those little voltage fluctuations? Cuz G5 chips are way hot regardless.

    "Why in the world would someone spend a few grand on a professional level computer without $200 worth of insurance?"
    Did everyone know this ups was so critical? I would have been glad for ups had i known.

  9. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The older questions often had to do with BTU, WATTs, how much VA is enough, and whether a SMART UPS is worth the extra cost.

    Even APC had to revise their calculator estimate of what such a system required.

    When I had to buy my own DSL modem (10 yrs ago?) for $200 the first thing I did was look at how to protect it from the severe storms we get - and neighbors that have had theirs fried (and 9600 baud once went for $1K, and back in the '80s 4-5x even that). So protection has always been high on my list.

    Does a UPS take some of the work or load off a PSU so it always gets an even and maybe 'cleaner' current?

    A couple people thought their ENET port was 'taken out' by a storm. Even if your modem is protected, there is or can still be more amps coming down from a switch on RJ45 than your ethernet port is designed to handle.

    And "protection" means any and all sources of current.

    When Firewire first came out, there were $29 Firewire isolator cable plugs that were (suppose) to prevent problems due to hot-swapping FW devices. I read of one person that saw corrosion and shorting. Cheap firewire cables still seem to rule the market rather than Granite Digital and Isolator.

    Considering the state of affairs in backup, disk maintenance, and even OS update "procedure" I'd say that you'd be expecting much more hand-holding and need a serious manual, not a short picture-booklet to go with every Mac, maybe a coupon to "Missing Manual" or other reference book.

  10. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Sorry Pere.

    I was way out of line. I know you want only the best working Macs for everyone. I truly apologize.
    Bizarrely out of line, considering the way you've helped me personally and taught me about Macs over the years. Incredible. All I can say is that I wasn't feeling well or in control and some dark muck came up from my soul. You weren't it's only victim. I have lots to make amends for.

    Peace, my friend, and thank you for being such a resource when I so badly needed one in the earliest days of my time here.

    Moderators: Please remove my posts