Benches Uncategorized

12

Upconverting SD footage to HD

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

We shoot live theater in SD and are starting to feel the HD crunch - even though only a couple of TV stations broadcast in HD, they are getting more and more vocal about wanting HD footage. Today had one publicist tell us that one station won't use the footage unless we upconvert it to HD for them (the fact that another of the news programs on their network does this all the time with our footage without problems...doesn't seem to factor into their thought process).

So I'm looking into ways to best turn our 16:9, DV/DVCPRO NTSC 29.27fps footage into an HD format. As I haven't done much work with HD (and it has all been in reverse to this - turning HD into SD), I need a bit of help.

My thought process now is this:

1) create a new sequence that is 720p HD.
2) Drag the clip into the sequence (which is automatically changing the scale to 150% end embedding it into the sequence with black on all sides)
3) Render it
4) Print to video and export it to our Sony HVR-V7U camera via Firewire and record it on HDV tape

Is this correct? Any settings I should use instead?

Thanks in advance for any help on this!

12 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for the link to the link to the project.

    I guess my further question would be is this a better way to go than to do it directly in FCP, since I have to export/print to tape to an HDV tape? Is it better to use compressor and then drag the upconverted file to FCP?

    I'm assuming that the only way I can get footage to the station is to print to HDV tape via the Sony HVR-V7U camera (the project is only 10 minutes long, if that helps)

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    FCP is the LAST software you should use to upconvert SD to HD. The scaling it does is not good. Nope, you need to use After Effects or Compressor.

    1) create a new sequence that is 720p HD...export it to our Sony HVR-V7U camera via Firewire and record it on HDV tape

    This won't work at all. Sony HDV is 1080i, not 720p. But you want to convert DV to HDV? Get ready for a LONG render time. Converting from or to HDV and the GOP format will take hours, if not days.

    Will the station take an HDV master? That is an important question to ask.

    And really, DV blown up to 1080i won't make it look any better. In fact, it will make it look worse. You are blowing up a 5:1 compressed format to ten times its normal size. Just because your dimensions are HD, won't make your footage HD. Might be time to look into moving to HD production...start shooting HD. HDV.

    Shane

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    It's not a case of wanting to do this, it's being forced to by a station that is being too frackin' lazy (or doesn't know what it's doing) to take SD footage and work it into an HD program.

    And as it's impossible for us to change all our cameras and reshoot this in HD at this point (may have to next season, but of course none of our clients want to pay for the privilege of HD...)

    So right now it's a case of looking for options. I know that blowing it up to HD is going to look bad (I've seen too many instances of people taking footage off of a DVD and blowing it up to HD...this is what I'm dealing with...sigh...). But need to figure out how to get our SD footage into a format that they will accept.

    Isn't there a way to basically do their job for them? Embed the SD into an HD sequence so it doesn't loose quality, but is basically 'pillar boxed?' So I can then play the sequence into our HD camera (which we only use for interviews as it's easier to lug)?

  5. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    it's being forced to by a station that is being too frackin' lazy (or doesn't know what it's doing) to take SD footage and work it into an HD program.

    It isn't laziness. It is highly technical. There are issues with mixing SD and HD programming. Big issues.

    Embed the SD into an HD sequence so it doesn't loose quality, but is basically 'pillar boxed?'

    You will always lose quality. SD to HD is a huge bump...as I said, DV to 1080i is blowing up your image by a factor of ten. There are good ways to do this, and bad ways. The best way would be to use a Terranex to upconvert the footage. That is a high end box that many post houses employ for this purpose. Then there are capture card options, like the Matrox MXO2 and AJA Kona 3. Then there is software, After Effects or Compressor.

    But taking an individual frame format and converting it to HDV, a GOP format, is troublesome. The formats are pretty incompatible. The test I tried was horrible...HORRIBLE. Weird ghosting. The only way to really get to HDV would be to output to an HDV deck, but none of the decks I have seen have SDI inputs, nor Component...only Composite or SD SDI. That won't work either.

    You can TRY to convert to HDV...the only tool you can use to do that is Compressor. And you MUST convert to HDV if you want to try to output via firewire. Good luck.

    Shane

  6. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    "It isn't laziness. It is highly technical. There are issues with mixing SD and HD programming. Big issues."

    I'm sure, and I appreciate it. Really. I do. But I am a bit bemused by how this week alone the same footage this one editor is refusing was used by The Today Show and similar footage of ours was used by several other HD morning shows. And it looked great (and pillared into an HD sequence). And since I'm sure this person is being paid a heck of a lot more than I am and should be dealing with his on a daily basis...

    "The best way would be to use a Terranex to upconvert the footage. That is a high end box that many post houses employ for this purpose. Then there are capture card options, like the Matrox MXO2 and AJA Kona 3. Then there is software, After Effects or Compressor."

    Thanks for the info. It's giving me options to give my boss (who is balking at shelling out $16K for new cameras for what is essentially a limited request at present...limited but growing)

    "You can TRY to convert to HDV...the only tool you can use to do that is Compressor. And you MUST convert to HDV if you want to try to output via firewire. Good luck."

    Thanks...keeping fingers crossed while I process overnight...

  7. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yeah, those shows are upconverting on their end. For some reason your client is looking to avoid that in the future. Sheesh, the TODAY SHOW should be able to absorb THAT cost.

    Good luck.

    Shane

  8. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks (it's not the Today show that's the problem, just to set it straight...it's one of their competitors...which may be why Today is #1

    Ah the joys of learning a new skillset...in a late night frantic phone call manner!

  9. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Out of curiousity...how does Magic Bullet Instant HD (regular or advanced) compare with converting via Compressor (both in time and in quality)

  10. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Aja FS1 is a good option for your purposes. I'd also think the Aja Kona LHi would be a good choice. Both products will up/down/cross convert till the cows come home.

    I really like the FS1; anything in, anything out and I wish I had a reason to own one. The only way I see to make it better would be to add paint handles on the frame sync side of the thing.

  11. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    since you are mobile, a MXO2 on a laptop would make a lot of sense. let the MXO2 upscale on input, record to prores or dvcpro depending on format... done. you could also record in SD, and the play out via the MXO2 to a HD capture after edit too.... not the most elegant workflow, but its realtime and in SDI, its as good as it gets.

  12. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    What's a "pain handle" when its at home?

    I read that as painting handles on the box in an effort to make it more portable...

    ...too sunny today.