Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Mail 3.5 seems to randomly choose accounts to reply from. For example, I get a message on account "me@FIRST_ISP.com," hit "reply," and it sends the reply from "me@SECOND_ISP.com." For business reasons I need to reply consistently from the same account, and I sometimes fail to check in the course of my busy day.
This is a very poor choice for default behaviour, in my opinion. I can't locate a setting other than "send new mail from," which doesn't quite fit the bill. Is there a way to fix this?
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Sounds like corrupt prefs. You've obviously tried; +Mail>Preferences>Composing>Send new mail from.......+
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi Gumsie,
Thanks, but this isn't a new mail message problem; this is a problem when replying to a mail message.
If you send to me at Account A, I need the response to come from Account A, automatically.
If you send to me at Account B, I need the response to come from Account B, automatically.
But this isn't happening. Most mail replies default to Account A, even if the originator sent to Account B. Sometimes when the originator used Account A, the default reply is from Account B.
This makes no sense. And it's been happening at least since 10.4 (I am now on 10.5.6).
Sean
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Oh ya. Did you use the migration assistant to upgrade perchance? Have you tried moving the prefs file to the desktop.
Having said that the options in preferences should do the trick. Remember there is one to send from +'Account of last viewed Mailbox'+ so that would suggest that if you'd just read a mail from acc A it should reply by acc A.