I-Movie 09 is a Big Bummer!
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Am I the only one who is really let down by Apples reconfiguration of I-Movie 06? As a video instructor who start's his kids off with I-Movie 06 I was awfully disappointed with 08, and never installed it. After hearing the bugs were out of 08, I bought 09. Well i think apple has taken steps back, not forward. My students really hate 09. It takes more steps to do what was easy to do and easy to understand in 06. I don't get it? Who at apple wanted to change this platform? The audio rubber banding was in front of you and easy as pie, the apple T trim function was awesome, placing effects a breeze. Insert editing, extracting audio, stacking & locking audio was easy and effective! Saving the project to the desk top was cool, now that's gone, choosing wide screen is gone, I and my students, are still very disappointed with the release of 09, and all my kids download 06 once buying their new mac's, and do not use 09. My 2nd year students use final cut express, but even them when pressed for time, go back to 06 to pump out projects running late. Does anyone else feel this way? I herd they are going to let 06 go the way of the trash? Real bummer man! I do like the new effects in 09 and some of the titles, and that's it. You cannot even run 06 and 09 at the same time! Apple what the ???
Thanks Steve
14 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The first time I saw iMovie '08 I stated: "It was hate at first sight", then I started to actually use it, going through all the tutorials on line. I was up and running in less than an hour.
When I finally detach myself from the emotional attachment to all that I know of iMovie HD, embracing the change, the only thought I had was... I wish they called it iStoryboard... but who cares.. It works and it does the job I need it to do.
The main reason why I love iMovie '09 and iMovie '08 is that is a visual application.
It makes my life easier not only when I need to create a project and post it on the internet in a very short time, but also when I teach digital media to children and adults from several non-profit organizations.
What's amazing about children is that they absorb information, particularly visuals, like sponges. To them there was no iMovie 06 or 08 or 09 obstacles, but just the desire of sharing their incredible stories of survivals in a very short period of time without using any manuals. - 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
You have invested a career in learning iMovie 06. Most people haven't. Now your students can pick up iMovie quicker than you can because they don't have to unlearn how to do it the iMovie 6 way.
I remember buying my Mac and being excited about being able to create movies from my extensive backlog of unedited VHS and miniDV tapes. Then I did my first project in iMovie 6 and I was terribly disappointed. It had a terrible architecture. It did not handle the storage of assets efficiently. It got around destructive editing by doubling up and keeping two copies of everything. Project sizes balloon. Editing was sluggish because you were always waiting for rendering.
But the worst thing was, it was not intuitive. I had to create my movie with David Pogue's book in my lap. By the time I finished my movie and burned it to DVD, I realized that I could never use this tool to work through my backlog of projects in my lifetime. When Imovie 08 came out, I found it much easier to use, there was no slow rendering every time you made an edit, and I could edit as fast as I could think. And I have worked through over 30 AVCHD projects, as well as all my minDV backlog, and I am quickly catching up in my VHS backlog.
Further, iMovie 08/9 makes it simple to do things that were not possible in 06. For example, I was able to make a happy birthday video for my daughter combining current AVCHD events with footage from her 18th, 17th, 16th, 8th, 5th, 4th, 3rd, 2nd, and 1st birthdays, and complete the 13 minute project in less than a day. Then I could show it to her on Mobile Me later that evening, (and watch her reaction through Video iChat.)
I am very happy that I am no longer constrained by iMovie 6.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I think, Appleman1958 is right, although I have never been able to use iMovie 08 properly. Most actions I took were wrong. But I think, the reason is that I am not able to unlearn. Like most of the people.
I have bought iLife 09 and will start again. I might be able to unlearn everything about video editing I have been learning and practising for about 20 years. Anyhow, before you blame Apple you should ask people who made their first cuts with iMovie 09.
By the way, I have been using the first ever iMovie (cost 0 $) for ages. It was such intuitive that I have dumped my Premiere for which I had paid something like 3,000 $ (long ago) in addition to the 2,000 $ for the card. I have never missed them.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
My students really hate 09. It takes more steps to do what was easy to do and easy to understand in 06. I don't get it?
I started using iMovie 05, then iMovie 06. I never read the manual or looked at the tutorials. I basically sat down and started using it. iMovie 06 was completely intuitive to me. It seemed very similar to the "old days" of editing film mechanically.
I have a natural bias towards all things new, so when iMovie 08 came out I eagerly started to use it. But after many hours of using it (and studying tutorials and manuals) I found that what I could do quickly in iMovie 06 took longer with iMovie 08.
When I have a short project I will do it with iMovie 08 (and now iMovie 09). But for a project more than about ten minutes I still prefer iMovie 06. I know that many people prefer iMovie 08/09 (like the honorable Appleman1958). Perhaps this difference of opinion is a good demonstration of how the human mind is "wired up" in different people.
Because of my disappointment in iMovie 08/09, I tried movie editing programs that run on Windows as well as Final Cut Express. And in all of this I have learned that iMovie 06 is similar to the other editing programs I've tried. Whereas iMovie 08/09 seems completely different from everything else.
One of the problems that I see in teaching with iMovie 08/09 is that when your students advance to more sophisticated software they will have to "un-learn" iMovie 08/09.
I continue to use iMovie 09 for simple projects hoping that someday "the light will come on".
Fortunately Apple has taken nothing away from us. When iLife 08/09 is installed, all of the old iLife applications are automatically deleted EXCEPT iMovie 06 (and this is no accident).
If you like iMovie 06 better, as many do, you can continue to use it. I find that it works perfectly with my Mac Pro, iDVD 08/09 and the latest Mac OS.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm in the camp of those loving iMovie '09. I was very disappointed with '08, not because of the interface, but because of the missing features from iMovie HD. Now I have all the features of iMovie HD, plus the easily interface and sheer speed of iMovie '08. No more waiting for clips to render plus easy file management all wrapped into one.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"And in all of this I have learned that iMovie 06 is similar to the other editing programs I've tried. Whereas iMovie 08/09 seems completely different from everything else.
One of the problems that I see in teaching with iMovie 08/09 is that when your students advance to more sophisticated software they will have to "un-learn" iMovie 08/09."
IF iM06 had Mark IN and Mark OUT -- it really would be like every other NLE at any price range. The drag-to-select makes no sense IF you have been editing since Premiere 4. So I didn't like 06.
Because 08 was so radically different -- there was nothing to unlearn. And, other than the lack of rubberbanding audio it offers quick editing. IMHO iM08 is visually obvious. The Force is with you.
I'm less sure I like iM09 because after clicking on the single "button" on a clip you must choose WHICH operation you want. That's an extra step for EVERY operation!
Worse, I -- like I bet many -- have hours and hours of DV I want to edit someday. (Or, VHS xferred to DV.) iM08 and iM09 fail at this task. I sure don't need less quality! Bad move by Apple.
Also, iM08/09 still will not import anything not "popular" like AVCHD, You need to use a program like MPEGStreamclip or iPhoto. (With Avid Media Composer, I can import ANYTHING QT can import because it uses the QT import function. No separate program to run. This is how IMPORT should be!)
If you are teaching -- your students get locked into the Apple way. And, your library of photos and videos are locked into Apple. And, now your AVCHD archeive is locked into Apple. With Apple having such a limited world-wide market share of computers this sounds like not a good place to put students. Keeping OPEN is the smart way to go. In fact, if Adobe ported CS4 to Linux, there would be no reason not to go this way. I'd love to escape from both Apple and MS.
I think the case can be made that with Windows 7 --running on a Mac (bootcamp) or Sony -- offers a less risky future. Applications like EDUIS (better than FCP) or Vegas from Sony or Premier/Premiere Elements from Adobe are less exciting than iM08/09, but over the long haul may be better for students who are LEARNING EDITING. (And, anybody in media uses Adobe apps and "everybody" uses Office.)
However, if kids are just editing to tell a story -- then iM09 is fine. (Likewise iWork is fine for writing student reports.) So it depends on why they are learning editing.
PS: There are those who think that IF there is an FCP 6 it will be very much like iM. Now that would be interesting in Hollywood.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I wasn't exposed to '06 until after I bought the manual for '08, which explained what i was going to be missing from the upgrade. But, the author mentioned '06 was available as a free download. I downloaded and saw all these juicy effects and audio tricks and probably like most, started importing video into '08 for speed and selection and editing in '06 for effects and audio. Seems like '09 is going to save alot of time.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Steve Mullen wrote:
Worse, I -- like I bet many -- have hours and hours of DV I want to edit someday. (Or, VHS xferred to DV.) iM08 and iM09 fail at this task. I sure don't need less quality! Bad move by Apple.Please help me understand this. I still use a mini-DV camcorder at times. Will iMovie 09 not connect to my camcorder?
I have a Canon Elura 100, which connects via Firewire and iMovie HD controls it perfectly, importing video without any trouble.
What would I have to do if I were to get iMovie 09? Will the camcorder connect and import the video or would I have to go through other steps?
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"iM08 and iM09 fail at this task. I sure don't need less quality! Bad move by Apple."
Please help me understand this.
iMovie 08/09 uses 'single field processing' meaning every other horizontal line of the video is thrown out, which reduces the sharpness of the footage. iMovie 06 uses ALL of the image to form the video.
If your primary workflow is editing DV clips and making DVDs, iMovie '06 is better suited. Your movie will arrive at iDVD in DV format, which is an ideal match for making a DVD: same resolution, same pixels aspect ratio, and original quality. If you share your movie from iMovie '08 / 09, it gets re-rendered at 640x480 or less, and then iDVD upscales it back to 720x480. The end result is obviously not as good.
iMovie 06 and iDVD 08/09 is a terrific combination.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
It's cool to see all the responses of my original post. You all have valid points, so I cannot discount those. However the loss of a dedicated edit time line is something that most all pro applications have so I still do not like that they thew it out. I am not attached by the hip to IM-06HD but the proof is in my students, who get to choose weather they want to edit on 09 or 06? Most all take 06, for editing student films. It's not because of me and my bios against 09, they just think it's easier to understand. Also my advanced students use mostly Final Cut, and being introduced to editing in IMHD 06 it makes sense to them when they move up. Most all (good) dedicated editing software runs on the premise of a dedicated storyline/time-line, Avid, Media 100, and more. This 09 stuff reminds me of the old Videononics editng stuff! My kids are taking the class to learn to make short films, and edit on the type of gear used by professionals. I know 06" was not designed as pro-software for filmmakers but heck it worked really, really well and followed the structure of editing software that people make a living on (clip bin)(time-line)(audio under the time-line) I think the bottom line is since Apple has Final cut pro/express they decided that they needed to turn i-movie 08 into a soccer Mom venue, upload your footage add birthday titles and there you go. I say bummer! But that's just me. I would of rather seen them keep the 06 layout, (with the time line) and add all the new cool stuff that that they have in 09. I have been doing this teaching gig for 12 years, worked in LA as a professional for some 30 odd years and have seen edit platforms come and go so I can suffice. This was just one of my all time favorites that I watched 8th to 12 grade kids flourish in, understand, and carry those learned aesthetics to bigger platforms. I love Mac's, i probbly am responsible for introducing/selling more Mac's to kids over the years than anyone I know because I loved these programs. It's not the learning curve that bothers me, as a 50 year old **** I have gotten used to that, I'm just listing to my kids in the trenches man. Thanks for your response, it was all cool to read.
Steve - 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"However the loss of a dedicated edit time line is something that most all pro applications have so I still do not like that they thew it out."
Again... iMovie is not by any means a pro application. And it wasn't conceived to be one.
I have been using Final Cut Pro for professional editing projects and iMovie '09 for semi-professional and on-line videos creating over 500 projects between iMovie 1.0 to '09.
And I don't consider myself a "soccer-mom."
When a client asks me for a storyboard of a training video/documentary/commercial/music video, I quickly do so in iMovie '09, faster than hand sketching or taking snapshots and printing them on paper.
iMovie open the door (for me at least) to produce a series of inspirational videos on how to visualize storytelling in the digital era and so many more projects.
I think iMovie '08/'09 is also great because it allows you to see all the content you shot by skimming and grabbing what you want to see in a first cut, in no time. Without losing your original source. That, I am sorry, it was a major royal pain in iMovie HD. Causing other issues as needing to reimport what was accidentally cut out on the editing time line, for example.
Also, in iMovie '09, I can find all those effects/transitions and Video Controls that I missed in '08.
I have been an iMovie user for 9 years and 4 months now and see the difference in usage and could understand, from an editor point of view, the need for a time line.
But again, I think iMovie 08 and 09 were not designed for editors with 30+ years experience on their backs, but rather for everyone who always dreamed to put together videos in no time.
Children can only benefit from learning a new method of editing, that focus on visuals rather than a structural way of constraining the flow of their storytelling.
I guess what it boils to is do you want to try and edit in a totally different way or not?
I do, as I completely understand now why I really don't need a time line to visually compose a short, simple storyboard, or any short video project that doesn't require frame accuracy.
For that I would definitely use Final Cut Pro. - 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Good comments all!
What I don't get in '09 is why it is required to reduce the quality of the source during import -and to do that again at export- to get a good user experience.
These steps seem to be totally unrelated, and possible were even programmed at an effort. Surely the export to iDVD this way must cost more CPU time than keeping the DV resolution native.
Is it so much to ask to not mutilate the recorded material on purpose, and still have the nice editing features?
I don't need the complexity of Premiere etc for my home videos. I do need them to look as crisp as they were shot though, unless I consciously mangled them myself.
Now I can buy all these applications and try them all for size, but that is a lot of invested time that I'd rather use to control a decent application well and get through my piles of old home video materials.
I was hoping '09 was the answer, but I miss metadata during import (footage shot date) and now it appears i will have to use a different import and export function.
Vote for the import function seems to be iMovieHD or Final Cut any version, and than continue in iMovie '09.
How can I export to iDVD without the downscaling-upscaling feature?
Tips welcomed!
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Points taken, Never said it was for 30 year + veterans. I stated it was for kids starting learning to make short films and was my favorite entry product into editing. I also stated that my advanced kids use Final Cut just fine. I am playing with 09 and I must admit the scrub tool is very cool, the whole interface seems very fast, so I can dig it. One big short coming I noticed today (unless I can't figure out how)is there is no way to dip audio up or down in the middle of the track or video clip?? You can at the edit in/out point for fades or change the whole level of the clip but is the rubber banding is gone? Even my 8th graders use that quite often. Is their a way to perform this task? How would even a beginner editor on "09 start a scene off with a good volume of music on a title then dip it down to the background very low as the talking head speaks? That is a elementary task my friend, please enlighten. As to losing the original clip in the bin in "06" if you just copy and pasted it on the time line it would stay there forever. I am open minded, don't you think I want 09 to be the best ever? As I said their is some cool new things, the more I play with it, I like it, but audio control is as important as the rest of it and right now i miss the rubber banding.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I find the comments on whether the programs are intuitive very interesting indeed, as, I had a very similar conversation with a freind of mine not long ago.
I've worked on PC's since I was 16 (CAD / Engineering) and I first got to grips with iMHD6 probably about two years ago. To me it lept out at me and was totally obvious. I needed a bit of research to get around some bugs and to find out editing tips like 'Extracting Audio' but it all fell into place like a 6-piece jigsaw.
I decided to move (in part) to iM08 cause I wanted to use it for cataloguing (as ALL my stuff goes to DVD it was useless to me apart from small movies to online content), I still use iMHD6 for the reason of sharing to iDVD, I found the whole Garageband solution utterly ridiculous.
It was a fair enough program but I really struggled with it as far as it being intuitive. I would argue that it just wasn't at all, not one bit, but, that friend of mine who's older, into his Mac's / home media centre type scenario and home networking in a major way (but probably not experienced as I as getting to grips with new programs without a manual) found iMHD6 unworkable and couldn't get used to it, producing a technicolour disgrace to video editing
He found iM08 a breeze and liked it, it did what he wanted it to do and he could stitch together a few clips and be done with it.
I just find it so interesting that some people get into iM08 whereas iMHD6 is a complete mystery to them, with others, vice versa. I'm interested in iM09 but the loss of quality to DVD is very, very disappointing.
Luke
Message was edited by: lukethegooner