Would you believe that I was just about to place an order for the DAC-200 and the Handycam pretty much "gave up the ghost."
When it rains...
Looks like I'll need to locate a service that can transfer the Video 8 tapes to DVD directly for me instead. Since I will still like to do the final editing in iMovie '08, what format would you recommend that I ask them to convert them into?
A tough decision. To reasonably fit the material on DVD, it has to be moderately well to highly well compressed. This probably requires something in the MPEG2 to MPEG4/AVC (H.264) compression range. MPEG2, of course, would likely require secondary conversion for editing in most DV based editors which can be both time consumming and furher limit final quality. H.264/AAC data DVDs could, of course be editied directly in iMovie '08 but is even more highly compressed to begin with and makes me cringe when I consider that iMovie '08 will re-convert it to an even more compressed version of the same codec in its most useful "publishing" options.
Personally, I would price the cost of such services for your entire Video8 library and compare it with the cost of purchasing Video8/Hi8 digital device which can play both analog tape formats and has the ability to digitize to DV for firewire capture by any editor or dedicated video capture application. This technology is well proven and old enough that there might find a real bargain out there if you look around. (If nothing else, got a friend with something like an old DCR-TVR520 or GV-D200 just laying around you could borrow?) I.e., anything that combines Video8 transport, conversion, and firewire delivery in a single device. Suspect that if you have a large Video8 library, it may be cheaper to buy a player/digitizer here than pay a digitizing service. Haven't really looked around to see what is available but here is a link to one example that retails for about $400 (i.e., less than my Canopus ADVC300 which I also got through B&H Photo). Don't suppose you live in the South Jersey area, do you?
Sony GV-D200 C/NET Review
