Benches Uncategorized

6

Is iPhoto '09 still "non-destructive" by …

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

In '08, iPhoto would handle edits to files by creating new JPG copies (thereby non-destructively editing the original). I'd love to use the new Places feature in iPhoto '09, but don't want to have copies of the approx 16k images I have. So...

1. Does iPhoto '09 still make a copy of the file for editing or does it store instructions in a database (similar to Adobe Lightroom).

2. If all I want is the location feature, could I just import all my photos with the "copy" option unchecked and enjoy the map while making edits in Lightroom or other program to avoid duplicate files?

6 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    LarryHN

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Xian Rinpoche wrote:

    In '08, iPhoto would handle edits to files by creating new JPG copies (thereby non-destructively editing the original). I'd love to use the new Places feature in iPhoto '09, but don't want to have copies of the approx 16k images I have. So...

    1. Does iPhoto '09 still make a copy of the file for editing or does it store instructions in a database (similar to Adobe Lightroom).

    iPhoto '09 handles the library exactly like iPhoto '08 did - all modified photos are saved in a modified folder

    2. If all I want is the location feature, could I just import all my photos with the "copy" option unchecked and enjoy the map while making edits in Lightroom or other program to avoid duplicate files?

    Yes - if you never edit any in iPhoto and none of the photo have auto rotate instructions imbedded in them - if iPhoto is happy with what you are doing in Libhtroom - previously there have been some problems with iPhoto not reading Lightroom edited photos - and if you can live with the iPhoto thumbnails not matching the photo if you have edited it after importing it - and knowing that Light room will not see the location information unless you export the photo with location data included

    LN

  2. 0

    NU - Apple

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    it still makes the duplicate file, and i believe that iPhoto also makes duplicate when you tell it to edit in an external editor.

    Please not that "Places" does not store the location in the photo file itself unless it was import with GPS data in place prior to import. It stores it in the database.

  3. 0

    LarryHN

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Xian Rinpoche wrote:

    In '08, iPhoto would handle edits to files by creating new JPG copies (thereby non-destructively editing the original). I'd love to use the new Places feature in iPhoto '09, but don't want to have copies of the approx 16k images I have. So...

    1. Does iPhoto '09 still make a copy of the file for editing or does it store instructions in a database (similar to Adobe Lightroom).

    iPhoto '09 handles the library exactly like iPhoto '08 did - all modified photos are saved in a modified folder

    2. If all I want is the location feature, could I just import all my photos with the "copy" option unchecked and enjoy the map while making edits in Lightroom or other program to avoid duplicate files?

    Yes - if you never edit any in iPhoto and none of the photo have auto rotate instructions imbedded in them - if iPhoto is happy with what you are doing in Libhtroom - previously there have been some problems with iPhoto not reading Lightroom edited photos - and if you can live with the iPhoto thumbnails not matching the photo if you have edited it after importing it - and knowing that Light room will not see the location information unless you export the photo with location data included

    LN

  4. 0

    Xian Rinpoche

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks you both for the responses. I would be using iPhoto solely to read previously geotagged photos so I could make the "Places" map. It's more of a "toy" then a useful app, but that one map feature is something I've wanted (in offline form) for a while. I'm just going through each of the iLife '09 apps bit-by-bit to see if it's worth upgrading now or trying to wait for a package when Snow Leopard is released.

    Thanks for the responses.

  5. 0

    Daiya

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    What do you want the Maps for? I was very excited about the feature also, but am kinda thinking I could have waited.

    Showing the photos on a map requires an internet connection, so it's not offline. Although you can still do the column browsing (just tested this).

    If you create a page in a book, then that would be offline, but depending, I'm not entirely happy with the visual appearance of the book pages, see more here:

    http://discussions.apple.com/message.jspa?messageID=9114166#9114166

  6. 0

    Xian Rinpoche

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Ahhhh. I didn't know it wouldn't work offline. I wanted it purely because it looked fun. I'm firmly committed to Adobe Lightroom and Nikon Capture (NX2) so the maps on iPhoto just looked like a fun thing to play with. Since I had been considering an upgrade anyway (iWeb has some enhancements I've been waiting for), I thought I'd check into it. Your comments are kind of leading me in the "wait" direction. Since I'm hoping Apple with have an iLifeiWorkSnow Leopard upgrade kit like the current Leopard one, I may just hold off until the summer.