stop vs. pause
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
This is a question I see a lot. I am very disappointed that apple has not step up to the task of creating a stop function. tsk tsk apple.
First every one knows that the play pause button does just that it plays and pauses the selection you are on. And if you hold it for a couple seconds it powers down you unit. That being said.
Here is the only way that I have found to stop current selection from playing. You keep repeatedly pressing the back or rewind key. What this does is takes you back through all the selections you have played recently. Now please remember if you have played an hour worth of songs you will have to go back to the first song before the rewind button actually stops the ipod from playing. Also if you have used the forward button several times then you will have to rewind through those also even tho you didnt play them.
Again it ***** there is no stop funtion for the Ipod only a state of pause or unpause, or skip backwards through all of the played selections since the last time your devise was in a state of pause.
Please make yourselves heard let Apple know they need to update the software of all ipods to give a stop funtion weather it be through a selection screen or making a double tap of the rewind button.
10 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
R C-R ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm not quite sure what it is you want from a "Stop" function that the "Pause" function lacks. Basically, the difference in the two functions is quite significant for devices that have a relatively long delay after hitting "Play" before a "stopped" device actually plays anything. Typically that would be something like a CD or DVD player that has to spin up a disk before it can play anything, so a pause function that does not spin down the disk or return to its first item for the next press of the "Play" button is quite useful.
But for a device like an iPod with essentially no lag between hitting "Play" & a selected item beginning to play, there isn't much difference between "Stop" & "Pause." At best, a "Stop" function would reset what next plays to something other than where "Pause" resumes playing, but in a device that can store thousands of items organized in quite a few different ways, what item would you want the Stop/Play sequence default to? The first item of a playlist? Of an album, artist, or an entire alphabetical item list?
IOW, the "first" item has many different possible contextual meanings. I'm not sure it is such a good idea to have a single or double click return to the first of what might be a very long list of items that vary by context -- it is probably less confusing to leave things as they are.
- 0
jason wayne johnson ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Or the fastest way to do this is go to the menu for songs. pick the very first one and play it then double click the rewind button. Then you dont have to back skip through all the other songs. I just figured that out. by the way the asterisks in my post are covering the word s u c k s.
- 0
Matthew Smith ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm confused. Are you saying you want it to pause at the beginning of the first song? Or in other words, when you press play you want it to start at the first song.
- 0
jason wayne johnson ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
No Mathew what I want is when I am done listening to the Ipod to press a button and have it stop playing music and not be in a state of pause. Like when you press stop on a cd player or tape player. Because when you press pause on an Ipod it is just paused in the middle of a song. It is still using battery life, and, when you power it off it always comes back to the same place you left off last time. I want it to be in a state of stopped as in doing nothing not being paused.
So what I was saying in my last post is no matter where you are in your playlist you can always go to menu>music>songs> pick the first song on that list and double click the rewind button. If you try that you will see the difference between paused and stopped.
I am not the only one who wonders the same thing about the ipod. Before I got mine for christmas everyone I know who had on said the same thing---there is no stop button.
- 0
jason wayne johnson ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
R C-R, I see what you are getting at. What the stop function does I have explained. Where i want it to return the Iopd to would be the menu screen. Cause I listen to my Ipod like a CD player. I usually listen to a whole album. So when I press stop I want it to default to the menu. The main menu. I understand that you can just hit one button and be at that menu. But stop is just that it is stop. If you were to connect your Ipod to your computer let it sync then disconnect it, it is then in a state of stopped. That is what I want from a stop button. I am not the only one that wants this. I have searched the discussion boards and have found a few topics about this.
Some people may not understand why, however there are a good amount of people that do. Just like a cd player when you hit stop it stops. Where as a dvd player stops but leaves you in a place where you still have to get back to a root menu before doing anything besides playing the movie or changing what point in the movie you want to resume at. We just want our Ipods to stop. And I have figured out rexactly how to do it. Just read my reply to Matthew's reply.
- 0
Matthew Smith ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
You're not going to get a stop function on an iPod.
When you pause on a CD player the disc keeps on spinning, so that when you press play it can start back where it was paused. Pressing stop stops the disc from spinning. On an iPod nano there is nothing to stop spinning. It's solid state.
If you want to mimic a stop button you can press pause and then the menu button to get back to the top menu. The next time you want to play you can then navigate the menu to where you want to start. Why create a separate button just to do that?
- 0
R C-R ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
jason wayne johnson wrote:
Where as a dvd player stops but leaves you in a place where you still have to get back to a root menu before doing anything besides playing the movie or changing what point in the movie you want to resume at.Actually, it is very common for home entertainment center DVD players to resume playing from where they were stopped when one next presses "Play," as long as the DVD has not been ejected, which clears its playback-point memory. Some even tout as a premium feature a three or more disk memory that does this for the last several DVD's they have played. Most computer-based CD/DVD players typically do this for all disks, at least as an option, since computers have lots of hard disk memory in which to store playback-point info.
For these players, stop just spins down the disk, but does not reset anything that causes pressing "Play" to take you to the main or disk menu. To reach those menus, you have to press an appropriate button, just like with iPods.
What you want is more analogous to the way most CD players next start playing at track 1 after "Stop" is pressed, but even this is no longer true for many MP3/WMA capable players, which remember the stop point for CD's in those formats, which typically contain far more tracks than do conventional CD's.
Basically, a "Stop" function is a necessity only for playback devices with removable disks. Beginning or resuming play at some default starting point (be it a track, movie, menu or whatever) is a necessity only for playback devices that cannot remember the last played or any other index point. For devices like iPods neither is a necessity, & their user interfaces (UI's) reflect this. Equally important, when the number of playback items goes from around a dozen to thousands, & the choice of playback order goes from a single default choice to a multiplicity of them based on an arbitrary number of playlists plus several category-based ones, UI's that would otherwise be adequate can easily become confining, tedious, & confusing.
If you consider iPod's & iPod-like devices in this context, it seems to me that what you want is not really a conventional "Stop" function at all, but something more like a "Reset" function that pauses playback, displays some menu screen, and resets the play/pause function to next do ... what? If this was a CD player capable only of playing a single CD at a time, it would make sense that the next press of the play/pause button would start track 1 ... but it isn't a CD player & playback order isn't defined only (or for most users, regularly) by album track number.
As it is, if you want to access a menu to change playback order, you just use that button to do so ... & you can do this even while something else is playing. If you want nothing to play while you make the change, then tap the play/pause button. If you want a real "Stop" function that stops everything from using power, press & hold the play/stop button until the unit powers down.
Bottom line: The "state of stopped" is neither necessary or of any real value for devices like iPods, which offer more flexible ways to do more than devices for which that state is actually just a limitation we get used to because we have no other choice.
- 0
R C-R ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Matthew Smith wrote:
On an iPod nano there is nothing to stop spinning. It's solid state.I suspect that the idea of "stopped" as a playback state is so ingrained into the minds of so many users because of their familiarity with spinning media-based players that for some it will never seem "right" not to have a way to implement it, even if it has no separate meaning from "paused."
Maybe one way to partially overcome this is to start calling the button the "Pause/Resume" button, which is actually a better description of its function in iPod-like devices?
- 0
Burningrolls ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Sorry, but I must disagree with this statement ! I have just given my 10 year son an ipod Nano for his birthday...and you know what...his first question about the devices interface was 'where the stop button' ? This kid is a very good 'Litmus Test' for this kind of issue / discussion, as he has not been exposed to much technology before....Now if a 10 year old Techno-Virgin with a Non-Analogue Engrained mind is asking for a stop button...I think Apple should possibly be reconsidering this pause / play thing !
Of course, for me, not having a stop button as laid out in the original posters question simply defies belief ! But then again I'm totally tainted by Analogue Habits....Yukko !
- 0
R C-R ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Ask your son what he thinks it is that should be stopped by the button. I don't think it has anything to do with analog vs. digital but with the idea that something in the device must be started to put it in playback mode or stopped when it is not. Young or old, few people living in a technological society have not seen devices that require this, especially conventional disk-based CD or DVD players.
Even those that have somehow missed seeing such players are almost certainly familiar with the concept from a ubiquitous item of all technological societies, that being vehicles powered by internal combustion engines. We don't think it is odd that engines require a start/stop switch that must be toggled before the vehicle is ready to go; but many think it is odd that the switch is missing in an electric or hybrid vehicle until they become familiar with that technology.