Benches Uncategorized

7

All my Logic synths are in omni mode!!!

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I'm unable to get software synthesizers in Logic to respond to only one MIDI channel. Regardless of what I select in a track's "MIDI Channel" pulldown in its info tab, the synth still responds to note events on all channels. I'm sending MIDI data through the CoreMIDI IAC Driver Bus from a sequencer app I'm writing. I -know- I'm sending on only one channel, I can see it in various monitors, including monitors in Logic's environment. Notes are coming in on Channel 6, say, and the Logic track is set to say Channel 2, but the synth plays regardless. What I'm ultimately trying to get is a bunch of synths/samplers, each on a separate mixer track, each responding to only one channel. An Environment Channel Splitter won't work because there's only one Sequencer Input in the Environment so all tracks would be on the same channel. QT/DLS synths are an unsatisfactory workaround because you can't (I don't think) run them through a regular mixer strip for all its FX etc. Plus I want more sound options than the QT/DLS synths offer.

I feel like I'm missing something really fundamental here but have been banging on this problem for a few days now and it still eludes me. Any help would be much appreciated, thanks.

7 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    iSchwartz

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The name of the MIDI Channel parameter is a bit misleading. It's function is to channelize MIDI data going into the synth. If you select "All", data won't be channelized, but any other value will channelize the data. It doesn't serve as a MIDI channel filter at all.

    You can see this for yourself: connect a monitor object to the output of an instrument and assign that instrument to a track. Play the instrument from your controller (or from a region) on ch. 1, but set the instrument's channel to 2. You'll see the channelized information appear in the monitor on ch. 2.

  2. 0

    Bee Jay

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    And further to that, most monotimbral instruments don't care about MIDI channel either, because there is no need to. If it is monotimbral, and it's the only instrument on a channel strip, who caes whether a channel 5 or a channel 16 note is coming? Most will just play the notes you send it, and just ignore the MIDI channel.

    There are exeptions - eg the EVB3, which uses three different channels to target each of the three manuals, and multi-part plugins, say the Korg Legacy M1, obviously care about the incoming MIDI channel.

    Otherwise, it's fine that most monotimbral synths are permanently omni - a lot of new software users are exactly that clear on what MDI is these days anyway - they plugin in their USB keyboards and expect to hear sound...

    To do what you want, use the environment to split incoming notes into different streams for each channel, and directly cable these streams to the instruments you want, bypassing the arrange page. This gives you the added advantage of being able to use many more than 16 channels at once...

  3. 0

    Foxboy71

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi,

    did I get you right?

    You want to have an external midi controller trigger the Logic Software Instruments by using different channels - is this correct? In this case, which is a kind of live situation i guess, MainStage could help.

    If you don't have to perform live, you could easily record all synths one after the other.

    Fox

  4. 0

    juliadee

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Eureka! Without getting into "why would anyone want to do this", I'm grateful to you for having pointed me in the right direction. I wasn't seeing through the "layers" of the environment and didn't realize I could patch MIDI channel splitter outputs into individual environment mixer channels (they look like outputs, not inputs). Thanks.

  5. 0

    juliadee

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yes, it is misleading, thanks for the clarification, now I get it. They should label the control "MIDI Output Channel".

  6. 0

    iSchwartz

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    juliadee wrote:

    Yes, it is misleading, thanks for the clarification, now I get it. They should label the control "MIDI Output Channel".

    Mmm... not exactly. Here's why:

    Say you had an EXS-24 sound where different groups were assigned to respond to different MIDI channels so that it acted as a multi-timbral plug. Setting the MIDI Ch parameter to anything other than "all" would mean that all incoming notes would trigger only a specific group (the one assigned to that channel, natch). So really, that parameter does indeed channelize MIDI data received by the plug, as follows:

    MIDI Data--->Instrument--->MIDI Channel [ all = no channelizing, or, channelize to 1, 2, 3...16 ]--->plug

    -----------

    @ Bee Jay, I puropsely used the EXS-24 as an example because I know your views on whether or not it can be thought of as a multi-timbral instrument, and since you got the star and not me I'm being childishly spiteful. So there! 😉

    -----------

  7. 0

    Bee Jay

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    la la la la la I can't hear you la la la dum di dum...

    😉