Benches Uncategorized

13

Definitive Highest Quality Export!

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hi.

Please spell everything out for me, because while I've read responses to similar questions, I don't understand all the steps.

Here's the situation:

• I've imported video from miniDV
• I've edited it in iMovie '08
• I'd like to export my edited movie in as high quality as possible. Doesn't have to be a standard consumer format, just highest possible quality.

So... questions!

1) Using iMovie '08 and nothing else, is it possible to export a lossless version of my movie, and if so, how? (I'd really like to be able to do this - don't mind saving to a hard drive!)

2) If it isn't possible to export a lossless version using iMovie '08, what is the best quality export possible using '08 and how do I achieve this?

3) If I am only able to export a lossless version using iMovie '06, may I work in iMovie '08, open up my finished movie in iMovie '06, and generate the lossless export? If so, how do I do that?

Many thanks in advance.

13 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    1) Using iMovie '08 and nothing else, is it possible to export a lossless version of my movie, and if so, how?
    No such animal with iMovie '08 since no physical intermediate/timeline file or rendered content exists until you actually share/export you project. You can, of course, import unedited source files directly into iDVD and burn them. This is about as close as you can get to "lossless" but even they will have to be transcoded to MPEG-2 video.

    2) If it isn't possible to export a lossless version using iMovie '08, what is the best quality export possible using '08 and how do I achieve this?
    DV and AIC/AIFF are normally the highest quality/least compressed codecs normally available on systems without pro components installed. I usually prefer AIC/AIFF as an intermediate codec.

    3) If I am only able to export a lossless version using iMovie '06, may I work in iMovie '08, open up my finished movie in iMovie '06, and generate the lossless export? If so, how do I do that?
    Even iMovie HD can only export lossless files (i.e., "reference" timeline file) when no part of the timeline has been re-rendererd (i.e., no transitions, titles, special effects, etc.). As to exporting from iMovie '08 to iMovie HD, you seem to be missing the key point mentioned above -- the fact that your iMovie '08 project only contains the instructions as to how to assemble the content when/if you actually share/export it. At that time the project creates (i.e., re-encodes the source content) the output which is not lossless. Basically, any time you compress a file you are essentially throwing away data. In cases, of redundant data, this loss is probably inconsequential. The more you compress the data, the more you eliminate data which can never be totally recreated or re-interpolated exactly as it was. If you want to export a reference timeline in iMovie HD, then open your iMoie '08 source files in iMovie '08 and do your editing there from scratch.

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Jon Walker wrote:

    Thanks for your reply.

    1) Using iMovie '08 and nothing else, is it possible to export a lossless version of my movie, and if so, how?
    No such animal with iMovie '08 since no physical intermediate/timeline file or rendered content exists until you actually share/export you project. You can, of course, import unedited source files directly into iDVD and burn them. This is about as close as you can get to "lossless" but even they will have to be transcoded to MPEG-2 video.

    I take it there's no way to trick iDVD into importing a subset of your unedited source files, and create a quasi-edited high quality DVD in iDVD?

    2) If it isn't possible to export a lossless version using iMovie '08, what is the best quality export possible using '08 and how do I achieve this?
    DV and AIC/AIFF are normally the highest quality/least compressed codecs normally available on systems without pro components installed. I usually prefer AIC/AIFF as an intermediate codec.

     

    Thanks... although I'm a bit lost. Could you provide steps for dummies so that I understand exactly what you mean?

    For example, in order to generate the highest quality export from iMovie '08, I go to the Share Menu, and choose - I assume - Export Using Quicktime and select what in the following fields:

    Export:
    Use:
    Options:

    Also, you suggest the possibility of even better quality results with pro components installed. Is this something I can easily do? If so, how? Is this as easy as buying QT Pro and, if so, what settings with QT Pro would generate better results?

    3) If I am only able to export a lossless version using iMovie '06, may I work in iMovie '08, open up my finished movie in iMovie '06, and generate the lossless export? If so, how do I do that?
    Even iMovie HD can only export lossless files (i.e., "reference" timeline file) when no part of the timeline has been re-rendererd (i.e., no transitions, titles, special effects, etc.). As to exporting from iMovie '08 to iMovie HD, you seem to be missing the key point mentioned above -- the fact that your iMovie '08 project only contains the instructions as to how to assemble the content when/if you actually share/export it. At that time the project creates (i.e., re-encodes the source content) the output which is not lossless. Basically, any time you compress a file you are essentially throwing away data. In cases, of redundant data, this loss is probably inconsequential. The more you compress the data, the more you eliminate data which can never be totally recreated or re-interpolated exactly as it was. If you want to export a reference timeline in iMovie HD, then open your iMoie '08 source files in iMovie '08 and do your editing there from scratch.

     

    Thanks, I think I now understand that point. Thanks very much for your help.

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I take it there's no way to trick iDVD into importing a subset of your unedited source files, and create a quasi-edited high quality DVD in iDVD?
    If you have QT Pro you can always open the source file, set "in" and "out" points, trim the file to what you want to keep and use the "Save As..." option to save a "reference" or "standalone" file containing the segment you want. MPEG Streamclip will also allow you to save a trimmed segment but only as a "standalone" file. In either case, the content is not re-compressed and can then be added to an iDVD project.

    For example, in order to generate the highest quality export from iMovie '08, I go to the Share Menu, and choose - I assume - Export Using Quicktime and select what in the following fields:
    Export:
    Use:
    Options:

    In the case of AIC/AIFF. I would,
    1) Select the "Export Using QuickTime" option,
    2) Select the "Movie to QuickTime Movie" pop-up and press the "Options" button,,
    3) In the new window "Video" area, select "Settings" option and set you choice of video codec/settings (Apple Intermediate/Other),
    4) Select the "Filter" option if you wish to add use any (I sometime sharpen, age, tint, etc. segments),
    5) Select the "Size" option id you want to customize dimensions (should not needed here if same as source),
    6) Select the "Audio" option and set audio codec (I prefer Linear PCM in stereo at 48.0 KHz with better quality with 16-bit sampling.
    7) No Internet streaming is needed here.

    Also, you suggest the possibility of even better quality results with pro components installed.
    Depending on your original source file compression, editors like Final Cut install additional QT components which may let you editin in the native compression format or use higher quality intermediate compression formats.

    Is this something I can easily do? If so, how?
    If you have the money and the time to invest in purchase mastering Final Cut, many things would likely be easier but at the expense of a more manual work flow -- i.e., you would have much more control over the editing environment but have to perform some tasks manually which applications like iMovie do automatically.

    Is this as easy as buying QT Pro and, if so, what settings with QT Pro would generate better results?
    No. As far as the QT export options are concerned, iMovie allows you to do the same things the QT Pro would allow you to do. (And GarageBand adds access to any third-party codecs the same as QT Pro which iMovie '08 cannot access internally. While QT Pro adds a number of features which iMovie '08 does not have (picture-in-picture, masking, layering, scaling video track content, etc.) it does not add any new QT components such as Final Cut installs. As to export results, they would "theoretically" be the same from iMovie '08, GarageBand, iTunes, or QT Pro assuming the same codecs/options are used. (I.e., they all access the same QT 7 control structure embedded in the current OS.)

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I did an experiment the other day.
    I have a h.264 file which I created from DV source using the Medium iMovie preset.

    Then I rendered the same movie using Share/Export using Quicktime. I did four cases:
    Export with no compression (keeping the original DV) with both interlacing and deinterlacing.

    Then I tried exporting to AIC at 950x540, which has been suggested on this forum. I did an interlaced and deinterlaced case of this as well.

    I then made an iDVD with these five movies. To be honest, I couldn't tell much of a difference. The movie made from the h.264 looked pretty good as did the rest. The interlaced versions seemed to look marginally better, but not by a great deal.

    My TV has really good upscaling circuitry, so maybe that is why they all looked so good.

    Or maybe someone can suggest a better experiment.

    In practice, I don't do DVDs anymore. I use Apple TV at home, and I share with others through Mobile Me. But every now and then, it is necessary to burn a DVD. Mine look pretty good, but they might look a lot worse on another TV.

    I do think it is important to use the highest possible quality setting in iDVD. You set this in the Project Info.

  5. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I think you have hit on the important point which is that if you're starting with content of sufficiently high quality it's not hard to produce output that looks great. Just because there is compression doesn't mean it looks like crap. Look at the HD trailers on the Apple site...they're doing 1280x720 video at 6000kbps and it looks amazing. That would look great on any home HDTV set.

    When I export home video from my HD camcorder for web and sharing with friends/family I use 853x480 at 1500kbps and it looks great in a web browser and in QT, even full-screen. It's not HD but my point is that it doesn't have to be lossless to look good.

  6. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Jon Walker wrote:

    For example, in order to generate the highest quality export from iMovie '08, I go to the Share Menu, and choose - I assume - Export Using Quicktime and select what in the following fields:
    Export:
    Use:
    Options:

    In the case of AIC/AIFF. I would,
    1) Select the "Export Using QuickTime" option,
    2) Select the "Movie to QuickTime Movie" pop-up and press the "Options" button,,
    3) In the new window "Video" area, select "Settings" option and set you choice of video codec/settings (Apple Intermediate/Other),
    4) Select the "Filter" option if you wish to add use any (I sometime sharpen, age, tint, etc. segments),
    5) Select the "Size" option id you want to customize dimensions (should not needed here if same as source),
    6) Select the "Audio" option and set audio codec (I prefer Linear PCM in stereo at 48.0 KHz with better quality with 16-bit sampling.
    7) No Internet streaming is needed here.

     

    Thanks for your response.

    To clarify, in:

    3) video/codec settings, wouldn't "none" be a better choice for best quality than any compression? And if compression were chosen, to confirm, you would choose Apple intermediate rather than H.264 for better quality?

    Also to confirm, you find "Movie to Quicktime Movie" provides better quality than "Movie to DV Stream"?

    Again, thanks for all your help.

    -Matt

  7. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    3) video/codec settings, wouldn't "none" be a better choice for best quality than any compression?Sure it would. However, Matt, and with no disrespect intended, I suspect you have neither actually tested this mode nor computed the storage requirements. If you will, let me play "devil's Advocate" here... An uncompressed VGA SD video with, say AIFF audio, requires about 300 mbps or abour 37.5 MBs of storage space per second. (And HD requires about 6.5-7.0 times as much.) This comes to a bit more than 2 GB/min for SD (about 13.8-14.0 GB/min for HD) which is about 124 GB/hr for SD (or 833 GB/hr for HD). I normally use 6-10 hours of source material to create a 90-120 project. This means i would typically need to store something on the order of 0.75-1.25 TBs of source files for an SD project (or something on the order of 5-8 TBs of source files for an HD project). As you can see, most iMovie '08 users would simply not be prepared to handle such an undertaking as "start to finish" native editing format and would not likely have room for more than one project at a time even if they did. However, I suspect you may be asking from the standpoint exporting your finished project here, and would have to admit that this may be a viable solution if your project is reasonably short, you have sufficient storage space, and you actually see a difference in the output quality and it is worth exporting your project at a file size/data rate 8-10 times greater than your source files.

    And if compression were chosen, to confirm, you would choose Apple intermediate rather than H.264 for better quality?
    It would be my middleground choice. DV would have a higher video data rate (about 28.5 mbps) and H.264 with an unlimited video data rate less (on the order of 16.0-18.0 mbps) while AIC is typically in 20.0-22.0 mbps range for the VGA SD material I normally use. If I had my rathers, I'd pick a quality limited Animation codec as I prefer the way it renders blacks, its saturation, and encoding speed. Unfortunately, while iMovie '08 can import and edit this codec, it cannot export it to other compression formats. In addition, if I set the quality value too high, coding to Animation tends to "choke" my older system when the data rate exceeds the 280-285 mbps range which is almost the same as using "Uncompressed." So, I usually stick with the AIC codec which was specifically designed as an "intermediate" codec in the first place.

    Also to confirm, you find "Movie to Quicktime Movie" provides better quality than "Movie to DV Stream"?
    Let's say the "Export Using QuickTime..." has the potential to export with better quality. It all depends on the codec and settings used. Also, do you prefer to export with square pixels or rectangular ones, do you like to sharpen your content as part of the export, do you age your export, add hairs, scratches, or dust, use "B" frames, etc? I do and so I usually use the extra codec, settings, and/or options/features available via this route. Besides, to some extent, quality is mostly in the eye of the behoder and I have to admit that I may not be as "picky" as other users. (I still even watch some old 320x240 ecodings on my HDTV.)

  8. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks again for all the information, I'm learning a lot.

    To continue the devil's advocate, let's toss out what is best for most users, most convenient, most reasonable compromise, etc. and only concentrate on what is best. No other consideration.

    To drive the point home, let's say, for example, you've produced a short film in iMovie '08, and a major network would like to broadcast it. You therefore want to provide them with the very best quality possible, the one that most accurately replicates the original MiniDV footage. You're happy to provide the material on a hard drive. What then would be your advice?

  9. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The best advice is to ASK the network what format they want it in.

    Broadcast specs can be quite different from amateur specs (..with restrictions on how bright a white you can have in your video, how deep the black is, etc..) and many broadcast stations will have strict requirements for the particular media and format for a piece of video. Broadcast video may need to match IBU - or other - standards.

    So don't assume that, say, H.264 will be OK for them, or DVCPRO or whatever: ALWAYS ASK THEM FIRST, rather than just speculating.

  10. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    David Babsky makes a great point. Personally, I would provide 1920x1080 high definition footage in AIC, (if the network can take it, and there are no constraints) because I find it jarring to be watching the news in high definition and then they throw up a standard definition segment and it looks bad and my TV has to stretch the pixels.

    But, then, if there were no constraints except quality, I would be shooting with my camera from [Red|http://www.red.com>

    Message was edited by: AppleMan1958

  11. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    To drive the point home, let's say, for example, you've produced a short film in iMovie '08, and a major network would like to broadcast it. You therefore want to provide them with the very best quality possible, the one that most accurately replicates the original MiniDV footage. You're happy to provide the material on a hard drive. What then would be your advice?
    Based on what you say you want, I would have taken a different route here and done my editing in iMovie HD, FCE, or FCP. iMovie '08 is based on what I sometimes call the "black" or "magic" box concept in which a first generation source file goes in one side and a second generation, re-compressed file comes out the other side. iMovie HD, FCE, and FCP, on the other hand, are all based on physical content referenced in a "timeline". This "timeline" is a file that resources video segments (in their original captured format) and rendered content based on other capture segments. Basically in a DV project, this means the timeline file is an ordered sequence of content that combines the captured DV source data with content that has been re-compressed (titles, transitions, special effects, filtered, etc.) to the DV compression format. This "timeline" is, of course, easily manipulated. For instance, you can export the file as a "QuickTime" file in FC apps or, if you open the timeline in QT Pro, it can then be saved as a "Standalone" file which contains copies of all the "resourced" content without further compression. In this manner, all content that was not "rendered" during editing process is, in fact, of the same quality as the original captured source file.

    Unfortunately, there is more than one flavor of DV. (I'm not qualified to go into specific color space difference between DV25/DVCPRO25/DVCPRO50 so lets stick to the "capture" level essentials.) iMovie applications, for instance, import DV files as DV/DV files or files containing DV video (at about 28.5 mbps) and DV audio (48 KHz, 16-bit, also 28.5 mbps). Final Cut applications use the same video but have multiple audio AIFF/Linear PCM "Easy Set-up" options. Thus, the "Standalone/QuickTime Movie" files may contain somewhat different audio content even if the video is essentially the same. Thus, in the end it may be best to direct this question to the broadcast end user who may or may not have specific preferences as to DV standards. Suffice it to say that using this work flow, you will get more "original capture quality" in your output than with iMovie '08 using any form of video "compression." As to whether it would be better than an "uncompressed" video file, I don't really know. I see no visual differences between the two versions on my system but suspect that with the proper equipment for analysis, there would be differences. I do, however, see differences between DV from iMovie '08 and from iMovie HD.

  12. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for the replies, David and Appleman.

    I realize that in the best of all possible worlds, a time machine that would allow one to travel back in time and follow a more broadcast-friendly workflow would be best. The circumstance - and of course, this is all just idle speculation... - is you've already made your movie in iMovie '08 sourced from a consumer camcorder. If a network wished to broadcast it (and had no compatibility limitations whatsoever, it's all a matter of quality, they can take whatever you give, so you want to give them the best), what would you provide?

  13. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Jon,

    Thanks again for an excellent explanation. I appreciate that not only should things be done (/should have been done) differently if broadcast is a potential outcome, but why.

    In the words of Lady MacBeth, "what's done cannot be undone," but going forward, you've convinced me to learn a timeline-based editor.

    -Matt