Radeon 9800/256 MB for Sawtooth?
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hello,
Can anyone verify if [this|http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=270269208676&trksid=p3907.m32&trkparms=tab%3DWatching] Radeon 9800/256 MB Pro is compatible with the Sawtooth? I should say with my Sawtooth for which I do have a 550 watt PSU; I just haven't installed it yet.
The specs for the 9800/256 MB Pro state it is not compatible with 2X AGP; but it has two gaps in the connectors which indicates it would work on the 2X AGP Sawtooth running 10.4.11.
If the 9800/256 MB Pro is compatible, is it really worth getting over the 9800/128 MB Pro (which is compatible with the Sawtooth)? Mostly I use my G4 to do fine art graphics work in Photoshop and Aperture......Although I do appreciate really fine graphics on my display no matter what I am doing.
Also, will the 9800/256 Pro cool efficiently enough with all three PCI slots being utilized?
Thanks!
8 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Other Sawtooth owners have reported no 2x AGP compatibility issues, when using the Radeon 9800 in their computers. This is contingent upon having an adequate power supply - which you will have, after installing the new one. Did you modify the 550 Watt ATX power supply for use in your Sawtooth? This recent topic covered many of the questions that you might have about the 9800 in a Sawtooth. The page that Japamac linked contains useful spec comparisons about the various versions of the 9800.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Jeff,
Thanks for your answer. I read over Japamac's post, and it was helpful. It looks as though there is not much of an improvement with the Radeon 9800 Pro 256 MB over the 9800 Pro 128 MB on a Sawtooth. It is interesting that ATI states the 9800 Pro 256 is not compatible with the AGP Sawtooth.
Good question about the ATX 550, and, no, I haven't modified it yet. The modification is easy enough though, I just haven't had time to do it.
The only question left for me is whether or not there will be adequate cooling for the 9800 with all three PCI slots being occupied? Will the 9800 even fit into the AGP slot with a card in PCI slot next to it?
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi-
The 9800 Pro will fit with the OEM cooler on it, allowing use of all PCI slots. It will cool properly as well.
Problem is, these little fans that ATI uses aren't very good, and do seem to fail quickly.
As long as the fan is working, though, the card will cool properly, though there isn't any overhead to allow overclocking.As a backup, or from the get-go, this little cooler from Vantec has full copper construction, and has better cooling specs than the OEM Radeon fan. Best of all, it is only 14 mm tall, so it will allow you to use all of your PCI slots.
Another sure fire way to get better cooling, is to use Arctic Silver MX-2 thermal compound. The stuff is great, and gives up to an *additional 4ºC (±1º) cooling*.
I pulled apart anything that has a heatsink in 4 of my machines, and put MX-2 in all of them after I first tried it. Everything cools better.The 256MB version of the 9800 Pro used to be produced for 2x/4x AGP systems. About 2 years ago, they were dropped, and when the Mac Edition 9800 Pro returned, it was only 128MB.
Flashed PC 256MB versions can only work in a 4x/8x AGP systems. But, as you have read in my other posts, my practical experience shows that the benefit of the doubled VRAM doesn't justify double the cost, so it's not a big loss.
If you find a used 256MB for a good price, by all means get it. After all, the more the merrier. But, it's not that much over the 128MB version......nothing to break the bank for.
Remember, a pre-flashed 9800 Pro 128MB version regularly sells for $89 on eBay...........
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi Japamac
Thanks for the info.....I know what to do now.
Is the fan installation easy, or is it tedious?
Any tutorials on applying thermal compound?
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi again medinaray-
If you do go with a third party cooler, though the one that I linked is good, I think the Vantec Iceberq 4 would be better (and only 15mm thick). It has a higher CFM rating than the other Vantec, and still uses an all copper heatsink. Used with the MX-2 thermal compound, it should cool much better than the OEM fan would ever hope to.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi-
The fan install isn't difficult. The hardest part is getting the OEM fan off. It uses two push pin type fasteners, that are spring loaded.
If you're game to replace a PSU, then you can do this!Seems I have managed to break at least one pin on the ATI fans on most attempts at removal....
But, then again, no one ever told me how to do it.........What the ATI heatsink fasteners are, is a hollow retaining stud, with a spring around the stud to maintain downward pressure on the graphics processor chip (maintain good contact). Then, a pin is inserted into the stud to expand the bottom of the stud in the graphics card board.
Carefully push the pin out of the stud from the back side of the board. A blunted off tooth pick can be used for this (blunted to protect you, not the card ) Then using small needle nose pliers, or hemostats, squeeze the protruding portion of the stud so that it slips back through the hole in the graphics board, releasing the heatsink/fan from the board.
If you don't care to salvage the pins, use a small pair of side cutters and clip the stud off from the back side of the card. Definitely not tedious, this method.......
Careful, though, as the spring will launch the other end of the pin to the nether regions of your room!Once the assembly is off, using a soft cloth, dampened with isoprophyl alcohol (only if necessary) clean the surface of the graphics processor chip off, leaving no residue.
Place a small amount (about 5mm diameter x 1-2mm thick) of the thermal compound on the processor chip, and then test fit the new heatsink (simply place and remove). From the footprint, you will be able to see if you need more compound, or if there is too much. What you want, is an evenly dispersed, thin coat over the entire mating surface.
MX-2 is thick and sticky, so better to have to add than to have to remove.....
Don't worry too much about excess, as MX-2 is non-conductive, and won't cause any shorts like other compounds can. You can remove some excess from the perimeter of the chip and heatsink with a soft clean cloth.
From there, follow the instructions included with the VGA cooler, and everything should be fine.
The Vantec should use screws, so it is easier to assemble/disassemble.Pay attention to maker instructions on fastening the heatsink. Proper fastening, neither too tight nor too loose is important.
That should about do ya'. Remember, if you get a flashed card, since you are using it in a Sawtooth, the typically taped #3 and #11 pins (on the backside) don't need to be taped, or otherwise altered.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi Japamac
Outstanding my friend! Many thanks.
These Sawtooths are a lot of fun, aren't they!? My Sawtooth is like the Ever Ready Battery...it's a workhorse that keeps on going, and going, and going.
I realize, though, that it is about maxed out in terms of expandability, and I'm going to soon pick up a Quicksilver, or an MDD.
¡Adios!
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I realize, though, that it is about maxed out in terms of expandability, and I'm going to soon pick up a Quicksilver, or an MDD.
Funny, after I maxed this machine out, I picked up one, and then another QS2002.
Outstanding machines.......big drive support, 4 PCI slots, 4x AGP, and no cooling problems.
But I still like this ol' girl!Take care!