Benches Uncategorized

2

Setting up an external HD for trouble shooting

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hello, I put this question out in another forum (for powerbook G4) but haven't gotten any responses, so I thought I'd try here. If I'm transgressing any forum rules by doing this, please let me know!

I need help setting up an external hard drive which I want to use for trouble shooting and repairs. I have a 250GB LaCie rugged portable HD. I want to be able to use it to boot up both PPC and Intel based Macs running either OS 10.4 or 10.5. This is the range of Macs in my home and family. Laptops, towers, Minis (no Airs--yet!!)

I want to use Disk Warrior and Tech Tool and perhaps other utilities. I also want to be able to make temporary backups of perhaps 100GB in size (if a failing HD needs rescue).

I'm imagining making several partitions...but how many and how big? Would I need a separate partition for PPC and Intel, 10.4 and 10.5 (therefore 4 partitions). Can I leave a 150GB partition with nothing on it for backup? Where would I put my utilities? I guess I'd need multiples of those as well (though I don't need to be crazy about it, I can always use the disks). Does each OS need it's own partition and how big would each have to be?
I'm in a muddle.

David

2 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You'd probably have to make a system clone of each
    computer's installed system in order to have a bootable
    Intel® Mac & a PPC Mac system for both architectures.

    Disk Utility can make partitions on an external hard disk
    drive; and clone utilities can be helpful in a variety of
    ways to move and make bootable system copies. I use
    Carbon Copy Cloner by Bombich Software, it runs free.
    You could also use Disk Utility to handle Disk Images
    and Restore content. I have not used restore, like that.

    So as to not confuse the issue of PPC and Intel® Mac
    systems on an external hard disk drive, you may wish
    to consider getting a second unit, perhaps a known good
    bootable FireWire externally enclosed hard disk drive.

    Also, at times, one that has its own AC power and not
    reliant on the computer port's power can be helpful.
    There are companies who sell the enclosures and also
    the different drives which may be installed into them.

    Be sure whatever drive enclosure you get, the drives
    are compatible with their circuitry; some are OK with
    SATA drives and others PATA. A few, can use both.
    The computers on the other hand, generally are limited
    to the type they were engineered to work with.

    Each system should have its own partition; and if you
    do complete computer clones (not just system) this
    can be a great reason to consider more than one
    external hard disk drive unit. There are other ways to
    make backups and such, on the fly; they'd require a
    bit more research and investment into hardware.

    There are some cloning ideas in places such as the
    carbon copy cloner page, the icons in the header go
    to some information; & also searches for OS X clone
    can get you ideas. Some of them should be workable.

    For newer computers, you could try the new Time
    Machine and other stuff. Not sure how all that works.

    Good luck & happy computing!

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks,

    now that I recall it, PPC and Intel based Macs use a different partitioning, so I don't imagine you could use a single external HD to boot to both......that simplifies things a bit and increases my $$$ investment quite a bit....I have only ONE external HD! But are you suggesting a work around to this may be had by using a system clone instead of just trying to install OS's?

    OK then. Suppose I wanted to be able to use this HD to boot into a Mac running 10.4 or 10.5, would each version of the OS require it's own partition? And as I'm thinking of it, would I need 2 OS's in order to do repairs on any PPC, even if it were running say 10.5, but I had 10.4 on my external?

    If I had 2 partitions just for the OS's, how big would they have to be, 10GB? More? And would I need to have Disk Warrior inside that partition or could it be by itself in another partition?

    I could just experiment with all this I suppose....but it takes so long to install OS's and all, I'd like to at least have a partition plan.

    One thing more......if I have a HD that is partitioned to a PPC plan, could I still use it as a non-bootable external HD on an Intel Mac for the purpose of an emergency backup of a user folder, for instance?

    David