Benches Uncategorized

16

Why are my prints so terrible from apertu…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I have mentioned this before when trying to print to an HP printer.

Basically I have printed to:

canon ip300

canon ip4000r

canon ip5200r

HP all in one printer

Epson r360

In all instances prints from say iphoto or preview are just fine.

However from aperture they are terrible, they are super dark and look for all intent and purposes like a sheen of grey has been painted over the top.

I have tried all number of settings in aperture to get a decent print and in all instances the output is simply terrible.

I have aperture on my macbook and imac. Both output the same rubbish.

So in the print dialogue of aperture I have set the colour management to system, adobe and the epson printer I am using, all unacceptable results. In all cases colour management is switched off on the epson settings. I have also tried it with colour management on.

To hopefully illustrate my problem please see the attached image. The larger one is from photoshop and although not perfect with what I see on screen is closest. The bottom left image is with aperture colour managment set to the printer and on the right colour management is system managed.

I know its difficult but I hope you can see just how terrible it is from aperture.

http://homepage.mac.com/garethirwin/.Pictures/colour.jpg

Although on different sized paper, in each case its on glossy photo paper on best setting in th epson settings and the paper is exactly the same brand and quality.

Really what I want to know is, where do I go from here. It seems crazy to have to output my images to the desktop to open in iphoto or preview to print, this is supposed to be an expert application.

Many thanks

Message was edited by: Gary i

16 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Taverner

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Have a look at this text here and follow the instructions:

    http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1017&message=16506560

    I think there is also a Podcast on the Inside Aperture Website from O'Reilly with Joe Schorr explaining in detail how to get the best prints.

    THE most important thing to know is to switch OFF Colormanagement for the Printer itself. This seems counterintuitive at first, but the point is that then Aperture will take over the whole Colormanagement which is optimal since it takes everything into account going directly from the RAW file to the piece of paper.

    I get excellent results from Aperture printing on a Canon iP8500.

  2. 0

    jpgrove

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You need an ICC profile for your printer, that will get you the best results.

    What this generally means is that you have to stick with the same driver, ink and paper and settings you used to create the profile.

    It took me my first set of 8 ink cartridges in my R1800 to get it right.

  3. 0

    Gary i

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Why do I get such good results from EVERY other application?

    The profile I am using is the one that was installed with the epson drivers, is this wrong?

  4. 0

    GTCBrown

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Gary;

    You and I have the same problem. In my case, the prints are dark and reddish. Like you I see better printing results from iPhoto or Preview, etc. Like you, I have tried every combination of settings and print options to no avail.

    I will tell you what I have discovered with my system. This is a very frustrating issue.

    I use an HP PhotoSmart 8250 printer. During installation, several files are put into the /library/printers/hp/photosmart folder. Inside one of those files is a huge number of custom ICC profiles for various printer/paper combinations. Aperture is able to access the three appropriate profiles available for my printer.

    When soft-proofing with Aperture, you have you pick of a whole list of output profiles. When I used any one of those three HP profiles, the image on-screen would go dark and red - just like the printouts. I suspect if you do the same, you'll see dark and green.

    After many posts on this board with the very helpful Janet Taylor, and many wasted 4 x 6 images (and several replaced ink cartridges) I moved the offending profiles out of the installed HP file in the /library/etc folder. This had the pleasant effect of preventing Aperture from using them, either for output or soft-proofing.

    However, my prints were still not up to snuff. I think that if I manipulated the image on-screen some more, I could probably get them closer to what iPhoto is putting out. It was at that point that I stopped trying and started looking back at iPhoto.

    So, my advice to you is to locate the ICC color profiles on your system (the COlorSync utility will tell you where they are) and either delete them or just move them elsewhere to prevent Aperture from finding them. Then run a few test printoffs.

    Now, this isn't saying that it will work, but hopefully it will get you closer to what you want. Yes, I know that what I'm saying doesn't make sense. The printer is supposed to work with the software and the ICC profiles are supposed to work perfectly with the matching paper and everything is golden. But in my case it wasn't. HTH. Good luck.

  5. 0

    Gary i

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for that, I am getting to the nub a bit now. The profiles I have are indeed for the various papers epson do. I have a couple of photo glossy 4x6 samples that came in the box and have tried them out using the correct profile and switching off colour management in the actual epson print dialogue.

    Result: Crap print.

    So long and short is I am doing everything it says to do and its rubbish, but great in every other application. What is a laymen like me to think?

    I will try and remove the ICC profiles but presumably if I simply do not choose them in aperture then aperture will not use them surely?

  6. 0

    Richard Seldomridge

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I've got the same issue. Using a Canon iP1800 (cheap printer I know) I can get good results out of photoshop (or any other program) using the supplied profiles. In Aperture the prints are always washed out no matter what settings I've chosen.

    It's simply an Aperture bug (that Apple doesn't seem to care about fixing.)

  7. 0

    GTCBrown

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    It is a bug then? What a load of BS. I busted my head against the wall from Christmas to the end of January and never solved it.

  8. 0

    Darren House

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have exactly the same problem and can't solve it!

    Tried everything i can think of!1

    Any ideas? Please !!!

  9. 0

    Otis Fuentes

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yup, same problem here (and yes I've reported it).

    In my case, Aperture will only let me print to the Standard print settings. Changing the settings to (say) the settings I use with every other app (ie High Res, No color management, no gloss optimizer, etc) the settings don't "stick". Which is to say that the second I go back to them, they revert to the Standard print setting. So basically, I can't print from Ap. Every other application is fine, of course.

  10. 0

    scott nichol

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    aperture and photoshop rely on a color manage workflow for best results. i'm not sure what's going on behind the scenes in iPhoto, but i get rock solid consistent results from prints when using a standard color managed work flow:

    calibrate your monitors to a Gamma of 2.2 and a D65 color space

    when you print then, you need to choose the PAPER profile that corresponds to the printer/paper that you're using. this is usually something like "SPR2400 EnhMatte BstPhoto.icc". this is the color profile for the Epson Stylus Photo 2400 when using Enhance Matte Paper with the print quality set to Best Photo. once you have the proper paper profile chosen, you need to set the print up to print to that paper (and use that paper), and then (and this is the most important step), you need to turn off color management in the printer driver. you get there in Aperture by pressing the "Print Settings" button in the print dialog. for my Epson R2400, i choose "Color Management" from the pull-down and choose the "Off (No Color Managment)" radio button.

    this is a standard color managed print process. if you monitors are not calibrated, what you see on-screen will not match what your printer will produce. calibrating to gamma 2.2 makes your monitor slightly darker than you would normally expect. and if your monitor is set too bright, you will get prints that are darker.

    good luck.

    scott

  11. 0

    mac fangirl

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I think you are missing something critically important: For the BEST prints, do NOT select "system managed." "System Managed" means that you want your Printer, NOT Aperture, to manage your prints. If on top of that you then go into "Printer Settings" and turn OFF color management, then what you are doing is having no color management at all.

    So, first: For an HP printer, use HP paper. Go to the HP website for instructions on how to download and install the ICC profile for your particular HP paper. Then, select the specific ICC profile from the dropdown menu in Aperture INSTEAD of "System Managed". Then, turn OFF color management under Printer Settings. Now try printing again.

    Try this approach with Canon too, exept of course that you would use Canon paper, and print with a Canon ICC profile. BTW these profiles are probably already on your computer, and will be present under the dropdown menu that begins with "System Managed."

  12. 0

    Gary i

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Please please please understand that I am reading your posts and the posts from previous moans from me.

    I have switched OFF system managed and selected the correct ICC profile for the paper I am using.

    I have selected the correct paper from my paper drawer

    I am using the genuine ink

    I have switched off colour management by the printer

    I get great results from photoshop without touching the colour management settings.

    Please please please understand this is a bug, its nothing else but that! I am so glad its not just me tht has totally given up on printing from within apples 'Pro' photo app.

  13. 0

    mac fangirl

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Gary I know you are saying that you are not using "System Managed" but I am quoting here from your original post which says that you ARE using "System Managed":

    <So in the print dialogue of aperture I have set the colour management to system, adobe and the epson printer I am using, all unacceptable results. In all cases colour management is switched off on the epson settings. I have also tried it with colour management on>

    If you use System Managed you are having the Printer manage the colors, not Aperture. And the results will not be good.

    I can tell you from personal experience with Aperture using both Leopard and Tiger, printing to Canon as well as HP printers, using a color calibrated monitor (Eye One display 2) that my prints using Aperture, ICC profiles matched to paper, etc -- are gorgeous. They are virtually identical to the screen with the exception of the obvious brightness difference that you will see via monitor vs paper medium.

    So if you are continuing to have problems it is certainly not an Apple bug but perhaps something unique about your system. First, have you downloaded the latest printer drivers from the printer websites? That is essential. Second, what are your other settings in the printer dialog? Are you selecting the specific paper you are using within the dialog? Are you keeping Gamma at 1.0? If your prints are too dark, try increasing the gamma slightly.

    There is a solution here, I am sure of it.

  14. 0

    Richard Seldomridge

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I've read everything there is on what settings to choose in Aperture and I've never gotten a half way decent print out of it. I've also read on this and other forums of people having the exact same problem, however for others it is working fine. This makes me think that the bug isn't just Aperture alone, but there seems to be some incompatibility with certain printer drivers and/or ICC profiles that Aperture has a problem with.

  15. 0

    Gary i

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I just feel my life is too short for all this, so I will continue to output and print from applications which do not make it a chore to get good output.

    There is an issue, its a simple as that, if aperture cannot in my experience print to five different printers without significant user input and even then get unacceptable results, I have to blame the app.

    Is anyone getting good results printing to an epson r360?

    I have the latest aperture, its an educational discount one, would this make a difference?

    I have an iMac and macbook both intel, both with 2 gigs of ram.

    I am printing to a shared macmini printer (would this make a difference)

    I have now switched off system managed and used the correct IIC profile for the print

    I have system 10.5.1

    ALL other apps print fine, even Safari prints a better JPEG than Aperture can even get close too.

    I have used 15 sheets of good quality paper and nearly half a set of inks.

  16. 0

    mac fangirl

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Silly question -- but you you have Black Point Compensation checked or unchecked? Generally, you will get better results with it checked, also with gamma at 1.1. I assume your paper type is appropriately selected too?

    BTW if you've only used a half set of ink on this consider yourself amazingly lucky. I blew through $300 worth of ink to get my prints just right! I use an HP B9180 and get flawless results, but it did take experimentation.