Benches Uncategorized

3

iMovie '08 and FotoMagico DV Quality Test

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

In response to questions from Karl and Matti, I conducted a short test of the DV image quality out of FotoMagico and iMovie '08.

The results can be seen at: http://homepage.mac.com/profpixel/DV_Quality/DV_QualityTest.html

The observations (as stated on the web page) are:

The Compressor setting in FotoMagico DOES affect the image quality even though the final DV file size and data rates are the same.

Importing a DV movie into iMovie '08 and simply exporting it again as a DV movie reduces image quality even though the final DV file size and data rates are approximately the same.

Like the old saying goes, "I just do them, I can't explain them"!

Any thoughts?

Fred

3 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    the image quality even though the final DV file size and data rates are the same.

    DV uses a fixed video bitrate, so yes, two DV clips of equal duration will always end up with the same file size. If a DV encoder has quality settings, then that does not reduce the output bit rate, but rather how much CPU it will use to encode the video. Lower quality means faster output. For example, when you de-interlace a clip while encoding to DV, you can do it very fast (use only the odd frames), or much slower (properly blend odd and even frames).

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    thanks Fred for adding this ...

    I like to remember my
    'DV stays DV? The 10x Re-Import Experiment'
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1090633&tstart=225

    at my German board, they made some additional tests.. it is 'confirmed' that iM08 somehow handles files differently then we did know before.. in iMHD≤6 and imported dv-stream was kept 'intact'; same procedure with iM08 adds a 'blurr' and somehow a 'zoom' to a dv video..

    that's the price we have to pay for adding the feature to handle DVDcorders, HDDcorders, mobiles, still cams...

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    iM08 adds a 'blurr' and somehow a 'zoom' to a dv video

    In Fred's test the iMovie 08 .dv export slightly horizontally squeezed the image. Those sample images seemed to be just parts of the output frame -- I wonder whether the whole IM08 output had any black borders at the left & right?

    So it seems like IM08 scales the .dv export so it can't preserve the quality?!

    BTW, if you look for the black borders you'd better to do in apps like MPEG Streamclip because QT Player slightly crops the .dv clips for display.