What iMovie '08 is all about IMO
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I figure I shouldn't tell people to RTFM until I had actually read the manual myself so I've been reading through the iMovie '08 Getting Started PDF.
The opening paragraphs say:
Introducing iMovie ’08, a revolutionary way to enjoy,
store, and share all your home video.
You can bring video into iMovie from a variety of sources and devices so that your memories are always at your fingertips. All those clips you have hidden away on your digital camera or camcorder? That box full of discs and tapes in your closet? Add them to your video library to enjoy anytime. Watch all your home movies without having to unpack your camcorder or connect it to your computer or TV. Browse the events that make up your life, moment-to-moment, year-to-year, person-to-person—all in one place. With iMovie it’s easy to organize and catalog your video, separate the good from the not-so-good, and find just the parts you’re looking for, when you want them.
It appears iMovie '08 is a very logical extension of Apple TV mixed with the iPhoto model - with a little bit of iPod thrown in. We will have ALL our video files available for viewing anytime we want. Since DV video files can be very large, H.264 compression is used so we can keep more video content available.
I'm not sure that I personally, want to keep many hours of video 'at my fingertips' - but I expect many people do.
F Shippey
14 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
the library in IM is certainly a nice feature.. but once you find your video, you don't want lower quality than the original and less features right?
Just my thoughts... - 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Can't say I'll be keeping that much video on my hard drive at all times, I'm content to keep them on the DV tapes.
I have to say that making a home movie with the new iMovie is worlds easier for me though. But once I make my edited movie, I'll probably get rid of the clips.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I edit my movies in Final Cut Pro and keep the edited masters on my hard drive then throw away the raw footage... the media library in iMovie 08 is GREAT because I have over 130gb of edit masters (76 completed projects) that now are in the iMovie 08 Event Library in native resolution (HDV1080i50) and its so easy for me to publish them to .mac in multiple resolutions. It is also perfect for splitting the master file into 10 min segments for YouTube. iMovie 08 will export them and upload them its GOLD!
I really dislike opening up an 18gb HDV video master in quicktime, splitting it into 5 smaller length clips export each one to a file size that YouTube will accept and the uploading them.
iMovie 08 is a blessing as a media organiser for digital video content... the editing features are lacking in my opinion and as many others have pointed out but thats easy to fix. We know apple can do it cause they did it in iMovie HD (previous versions) If you want serious control over your movies.. please edit in Final Cut Pro or the previous version of iMovie HD... but use the brand new iMovie to organize upload and share you edited movies, and in time I hope the editing features catch up for an all in one application. If your only intending to drop the pest part of ech clip into a sequence with some titles transitions and background music then iMovie 08 is fine and there is no need to load another editing program. But seriously there is not much else... no slow motion no video filters no themes with drop zones so be prepared this is a media library with editing functionality.. just like iPhoto, which is by no means photoshop. By the way the editing in the new iMovie is superfast for certain tasks. For example uploading a 1 hour Hi-Def video to YouTube can be a long task. You may not be aware but YouTube has a 10min limit on video uploads. iMovie 08 has been brilliant for cutting these large HIi-Def edit masters into smaller 10min clips. So easy to just drop in a Part I of IV title at the head and then upload!
i'm obsessed! ha ha... I do request apple get, Audio Waveforms, Video Filters, Clip Speed Control, LOADS MORE TITLE templates, Audio extract from a clip etc. Then even some templates with drop zones like old iMovie would be nice. But be quick about it because a lot of people are confused about the direction this software is taking and they are trying to get it to perform in a way that it was not designed...
When the software was previewed at the Media Event keynote. The scuba diver shooting Hi-Definition, probably explains why I seem to get this software and others don't.
I think the iPhoto / Photoshop analogy works best, same with iMovie 08 / FCP or iMovie HD(6)
Adobe Photoshop is the most powerful and capable software to modify enhance and touch up your photos, although it's not the only tool you need. Without iPhoto organising albums, the ability to quickly edit a group of photos and make them presentable and to share your photos would impossible with Photoshop alone.
Well iMovie 08 for a Final Cut Pro (or iMovie HD6) user seems to compliment in the same way. If your not ready for Final Cut Pro... the best advice I can offer is to stick with iMovie HD for big editing projects where you want themes, filters, slow motion etc and use iMovie 08 to manage and share your completed edited files. Just be patient until the editing capabilities in iMovie improve just as they have in iPhoto.
Good luck...
I hope your enjoying the potential this software has as much as I am... This is one of those apple things where I didn't realise I needed it until I tried it.IF YOUR STILL NOT SOLD! then do this.... get a movie you made that you really like.. preferably something you made in iMovie HD or Final Cut.. import those projects into the media library (there can be issues with the dates but there are fixes mentioned here on the forums for that) then using the new iMovie make a new folder, in there put a Master Project for the full video and publish it to dot mac. and then in the same folder make as many projects you need to divide your movie into 8 - 9 min segments! Once you have those templates, drop either drop the full clip into each proect and trim it down accordingly , or select 8 min segments of your film from the Event Library.. and put one in each project.... Now drop a Part I of I, Part II of II, title at the begining of each clip may as well throw in a cross dissolve. Finally drop another title at the end of each clip saying 'To be continued'end of part I etc... see where i'm going with this... now just go to share and publish each of them into you tube... PAINLESS... and it dosen't matter if your starting out with video shot on your mobile phone, the isight on your mac or a High Definition video camera like I use.... its the same simple steps!
Hope this help and inspired u to give iMovie 08 a fresh look over, because after 2 days it indispensable for me and I'm worried the negative reactions comparing it to the iMovie HD of iLife 06 could be detrimental..
Lata
Brett(ps in some of my posts i put links to my site oops realised this is wrongs oo if you see them just ignore them im trying to delete them all)
Message was edited by: Brett Watson
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
iMovie 08 is a blessing as a media organiser for digital video content.....
From reading through the PDF file, it appears that it is easy to store your video library on external drives and if they are not on line when you try to access a clip, you will be prompted to mount the necessary volume.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi Brett,
I do agree with many of the points your are saying about organizing videos etc. Also, to regard the movie editing feature of 08 as a compliment to more sophisticated programs. And yes, it does show potential, but unfortunately stops short, just before making it available.
In terms as a program for quickly being able to show a few takes, it's fine, but any step beyond that: you are lost.
I consider myself an amateur in terms of videography, though with Mac experience since these nice machines first appeared. My projects do run from "show a clip on the fly" to multi hour dodumentary takes for work and associations I am in. Though I did reach the limits of iMovie 06, though not quite ready to go on to FCE for sophistication and price, 08 can definitely not serve my needs.
Apple is giving a good start, and I mean start, at giving you a good media library, but even for serious amateur work, I find it too little for what had been offered before.
Integrate iMovie 06 into iMovie 08, and I will have what I need and wouldlike to see.
Dirk
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Dirk, thanks for taking the time to read what was a long and repetitive post. I was just getting very frustrated with a lot of people saying its not like last iMovie, because the old iMovie served no purpose for me. I'm glad its new an iPhoto for video is just what i needed.
I completely agree that there are massive holes in iMovie 08 but since I do my editing in Final cut pro they are less of an issue for me. I just want to be able to split clips up, add some text if i had to, and perhaps join a couple of clips together then publish!
It needs work if its going to replace the old iMovie a lot of work... But as a mac user who's main hobby is video editing. Then i'd rather see a video media library developed and have its editing features improve rather than a consumer based version of advanced software that I'm already familiar with.. I had no use for iMovie before, i'm just excited that I can finally use the program and it will be useful to me now... Just give it all the features of the old iMovie and then i'll be able to make great sequences out of my dodgy (phone small camera clips) and manage my major projects from final cut pro... ok I'm going on and on again..
I love you apple..
good night - 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
That is revealing. But my angst is not in what iMovie is suppose to be now, but rather what it was before, and has now become. The fear is that the great product that was iMovie HD is now gone. Yes, we can still download the point upgrade, but the purpose was not to be a library tool, but rather an editing tool.
I have an extensive video library, but I use iTunes to categorize them. If my kids want to watch cartoons, I go to the cartoons folder and make sure it is on random, and off it goes for as long as they like. I could do the same with iPhoto if I wanted. It too will play video.
I believe a better solution would have been iMedia. That is, an all-in-one library for movies, photos, audio and text. Organize, play back, and communicate with Apple hardware with complete ease. Then iMovie will be for what it was initially intended, a midrange editor as part of a suite of great integrated products. - 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
That is revealing. But my angst is not in what iMovie is suppose to be now, but rather what it was before, and has now become. The fear is that the great product that was iMovie HD is now gone.
Let's not panic until Apple actually DOES drop support for an iMovie HD type product.
Right now all I see are a lot of knee-jerk reactions to something that MIGHT happen in the future. NONE of us have ANY idea of what Apple's long term plans are. I find the release of iLife '08 in August 'interesting', but we are not allowed to speculate on such things in the forums.
My hope is that people will 'take a deep breath and relax' for a while. Let's see how things play out. iMovie '08 is really a version 1 product of a completly new approach to working with video (which is why I always refer to it as 'iMovie '08' and NOT iMovie 7).
F Shippey
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi Brett,
I get the feeling, you as a pro, regard 08 out of a viewpoint similar to mine (would consider myself technically interested amateur).
Actually, I had been jsut about to get FCE for my projects, for I had about reached limits of im 06, but the step still seems somewhat large to me at this point. that is where my dissappointment comes from: virtually bought most apple software blindly up to now....
Got norrkross movie as a companion to iMovie, now I am thinking further
Guess we'll run across each other again!
Dirk
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I've been reading these posts for awhile, regarding the love/hate relationship some have for IM '08 - and these last few posts gave me the inspiration chime in with what I think would be a BRILLIANT solution for Apple- and all of us!
Firstly, the biggest driving factor behind iMovie '08 is it's library feature. Store all your video, and easily post them on-line. Then it hit me. Apple should re-instate IM '06 as the editing program we have all watched grow up - and have what is known now as iMovie '08 become a kin to Compressor, but for consumer use. It's just about there already, with it's ability to encode videos from different formats, and get them on-line very easily. So, Apple should re-introduce IM '08 as an "i-friendly' version of Compressor, and along with it - has the ability to become a repository for all your priceless footage and masters! So, there's my answer: add one more iApp to the iLife suite, and continue forth with the iMovie '06 lineage for our editing program we know and love!
Cheers!
Mark Lamkin
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Mark,
As I have said earlier - none of us have any idea of what Apple is planning for its imaging software in the future - and at the moment, iMovie HD is still with us.
I continue to recommend 'patience'.
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Mark,
This is a brilliant solution for which I agree. If Apple truly wanted to give us a video library application, it should have been a separate application and not given it the iMovie title.
iMovie 08 needs to be called iLibrary or, as Mark suggested, iVideo. Treat it like "Compressor" is for the Pro line. I find this a very reasonable solution.
Shippey,
You say we do not know what Apple is going to do. Actually, we do know what they have done. We KNOW that they have stopped supporting iMovie HD because it was not included in iLife 08. The application was replaced. If it were not replaced, they would have announced iMovie HD as a new product outside of iLife--and that would have been fine.
I am as patient as the next guy. But to sit quiet and let Apple think they have hit a homerun does not sit well with me. I want them to think twice before making a sudden move like this.
You might ask, "What is the big deal?" It is a big deal to those who spent hundreds of dollars on third-party plugins. It is a big deal to those who have built businesses around the iMovie plugin architecture. And I am sure they have sent a few words to Apple as well. I doubt they are being patient. This is the current list of companies whose livelihood is tied to iMovie...
Stupendous Software
BKMS
AlphaPlugins
eZedia
ImageIP
Digital Thought Software
SebSofts
Virtix
Trix Software
Pixlock
Gee Three - Slick Series
Digital Arts GmbH - 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
that's what I had hoped for and expected for this release....
Dirk
- 0
Apple Support Community member ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Level of video editing skill..
None, Intermediate & Advanced
No Skill - Use iMovie 08
Intermediates - Continue to use iMovie 06 & stop ******** about 08 or take the time to learn final cut pro & motion
Advanced - Continue to use Final Cut Pro & Use iMovie 08 to manage and share your completed sequences.Main people who are upset seem to be the intermediates.. ***** to be the middle child I know.. not the most stupid in the room but still not quite as bright as the other children... ready a book and study hard. iLife is not the only media management software on the market and it is designed in my opinion to be entry level toold to manage media in the most professionl way.. iThink iMovie has more uses for me as a pro then previous iMovie and is even EASIER than previous versions to get entry level people into cutting and sharing movies!
Brett