Benches Uncategorized

15

AVCHD vs. HDV - Are they both exactly the…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I'm on the cusp of purchasing a new camcorder, to replace the fantastic (but MASSIVE) Sony HDR-FX1 I bought a couple years ago when Steve Jobs first told us how great that camera was and first rolled out a version of iMovie that could do HD video. I'm not rally a professional videographer and this camera is too bulky for family recordings -- though the footage looks great.

Now, the question is, do I buy the Panasonic that Steve mentions in the announcement, which is an AVCHD based flash recording model, or something like the Canon HDV20 which records to tape in HDV. Reviews I've seen so far imply the Canon would take moderately better footage, but leaving tape behind is a very appealing idea to me.

My question is, do both formats get converted into the same intermediate format for editing that iMovie HD has been using? That format is fine, but it does suck up a lot of drive space. I'm trying to figure out how to get enough drive space to really use the appealing idea of a video library.

Finally, does anyone happen to know if HDV camcorders can play back tapes made with competitor's cameras? I'd like to sell my Sony pro cam if I go with a new (smaller) HDV model, but I'd still like to be able to play back old HDV tapes.

Thanks guys... interesting and shocking to see iMovie as we knew it gone.

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Kelly Hawk

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yes -both AVCHD and HDV get converted to Apple Intermediate Codec.

    I too started with an FX1, and since I got my Sony SR1, I haven't looked back (much - the FX1 has lots of controls no consumer camera will ever have). I can't imagine buying another tape-based camera again. AVCHD is a big nail in the coffin of tape, in my opinion.

    AVCHD cameras have multiple quality settings, which affect the bitrate they capture at. This appears to affect the filesize in iMovie - so where HDV was a one-size-fits-all 22Mb/s, AVCHD gives you more choices.

    The SR-1 also can record MPEG-2, when standard-def is enough.

    The real win the import time - its soooo much faster than tape.

    as to the HDD or flash? question: It depends. HDD cams are uniformly larger and heavier, but that makes for a more stable shooting platform. the SD ones are smaller and thus more stealthy. I also have to borrow an SD cam any time I want to shoot content on my motorcycle; the HDD won't record with all the vibration.

    I like my SR1, but there quite a few cameras listed on the compatibility list, so give'em all a try. what's best for me isn't going to be right for everyone.

  2. 0

    I Dylan Malone

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for your experiences.... this is pretty much what I suspected. Do you find the quality of the footage from your Sony SR1 (shot in decent lighting) to be at least in the same league as the FX1's was? I'm hoping I won't look at every shot I take on the $1000-ish camera and wish I'd lugged the monster around instead. 😉

    Also, just to clarify, are you saying that the AVCHD cameras can import into iMovie '08 at more than real time? Is it roughly 2x, 5x, etc.? It would be very nice indeed to import at even double real time speeds.

  3. 0

    Elizabeth Vetter

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Is AVCHD support only in iMovie '08? I've read on various forums that Final Cut Pro/Express didn't support the AVCHD camcorders. I kind of find myself stuck in the middle - I'm planning to buy one of the new AVCHD camcorders but I need some of the editing/filtering features in FCE/FCP that no longer exist in iMovie.

  4. 0

    Sjoerd De Vries

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    In FCP 6.0.1 you can import AVCHD. Up until now not in FCE.

    When you heva iLife 08 you are allowed to donwload and install iMovie 6.0.3

    So you can always use the 'old' iMovie. And when U use the plugin 'Voltaic' http://www.mac1080hd.com you could use iMovie6

  5. 0

    Kelly Hawk

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    So far, I think the FX1 still has better image quality - but then that camera cost a lot more money. AVCHD is essentially an extension of Blu-ray, and I've seen what they can encode into that, so if there's anything lacking in AVCHD picture quality, it's not the spec that's to blame. Canon has announced AVCHD devices, and I'm hoping that their optics and sensor up the ante a bit in the AVCHD space; it certainly did for HDV.

    I feel like all the cameras I've tried give the same image quality per dollar, whether its recording to tape or disk or a card.

    All that is to say that the SR1 has a reasonable image quality, given its price point.

  6. 0

    Ran007

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have the Panasonic SD1 AVCHD that uses the SD Cards. The video is very clear and deep, not grainy or faded. Shooting at night - well, it's amazing.

    Importing speeds? I've heard that on the dual core extreme, converting from AVCHD to the intermediary is pretty quick.. I might buy one, or maybe a dual quad Pro to see.

    Right now I have an XP box (pentium 4), and here's my workflow:

    1. Copy video clip files off SD card (1 hour of video - around 2 minutes)

    2. Open TMPEG Xpress 4.0 and convert the AVCHD to H.264 720x480 (1 hour video - around 18 hours to convert) ouch!

    3. Copy to itunes.

    4. iTunes to Apple TV.

    Proposed Workflow with new iMac or Mac Pro:

    1. Import from camera SD Card (1 hour of video est. 2 or 3 hours)

    2. Convert again to H.264 720x480

    3. Copy to itunes

    4. iTunes to Apple TV.

    So to answer your question.... Importing can't be any less than 2x real time on the new macs..

    My question is... Has anyone tried it yet? Any benchmarks on importing into iMovie 08 on any of the new Macs?

  7. 0

    Ed Hurtley

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Here is a quick clarification on AVCHD.

    "AVC" stands for "Advanced Video Codec", "HD" for "High Definition".

    AVCHD is just the Advanced Video Codec used at High Definition resolutions.

    AVC also has another name. A name that us Mac users are extremely familiar with. H.264.

    Yes, that's right, AVCHD is the EXACT SAME FORMAT as H.264. Apple's High-Def movie trailers could properly be titled AVCHD video. (AVC is the video part of MPEG-4 that accompanies AAC, or Advanced Audio Codec, the format iTunes Store music is purchased in.) For Blu-Ray and AVCHD camcorders, they wrap the video in a slightly different wrapper than Apple does, and it's that wrapper that has been the problem up until now.

    Yes, Blu-Ray uses AVC. So does HD-DVD. So does Apple. (Again, "AVC", in a lower-resolution variety, is what the iTunes Store sells videos in, and is Apple's preferred 'sharing' format, now that they are denigrating iDVD.)

    The big difference in quality among HD varieties comes from the bit rate, or the raw amount of data per second recorded. At the same resolution and the same codec, from the same sensor and lens, a higher bitrate will look better. Blu-Ray discs use a whopping 40 Mb/s. AVCHD camcorders can theoretically top out at 24 Mb/s, but the highest-bitrate current model does 18 Mb/s. Apple's HD trailers come in at about 10 Mb/s (varies from trailer to trailer, but that is the average of 5 I just checked.)

    For comparison, HDV is 25 Mb/s MPEG-2 video, the same codec used in DVDs, only with more resolution, and at higher bitrates. (DVDs max out at 9.8 Mb/s.) However, AVC is a more efficient codec, so 18 Mb/s AVC SHOULD be approximately equal to 25 Mb/s HDV, if the optics and sensors were the same in both cameras.

  8. 0

    Pedro Schaeffer1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Ed

    Quite impressive your explanation about AVCHD.

    Reading the iMovie 08 Help I found this phrase : "Note:

    An Intel processsor is required for AVCHD video support. AVCHD DVD

    camcorders aren’t currently supported.".

    My question is: Will a computer with Intel processor and iMovie 08 be able to import from a Panasonic HDC-SD1 ?

    Regards

    Pedro

  9. 0

    Rubytuesdayappleuser

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    All,

    I heard that if you import AVCHD video into iMovie 08 and then try to burn it on a standard DVD throgh iDVD, that it will only play on a blu-ray player. Is this true? Is there a work around?

    Thanks!

    Ruby

  10. 0

    Tom Wolsky

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    This is not true. If it's burned it a Blu-ray burner it needs a Blu-ray player to play it back. If you record on a standard DVD burner it should play on any set-top player.

    Message was edited by: Tom Wolsky

  11. 0

    DavoMrMac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    To I Dylan

    If you decide to go with tape, which in my opinion will give you archiving ability and better quality, my experience with the Canon HV20 was not very good.

    It had connection problems, and more annoyingly the recording of the tape motor noise made me return it.

    I then bought a Sony HC7e and I am more than happy with my decision. Zero connection problems, superb build quality, stunning images, and no tape noise at all.

  12. 0

    First Mac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Will iMovie 06HD work with AVCHD? or am I stuck with the limited iMovie 08?

    I have not upgraded yet but was just about too when I got a little confused...

    Thanks,

    Greg.

  13. 0

    Dana D'Alessandro

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    That's interesting that you had problems with the Canon. I same one and have not experienced any of the problems that you had. It may have been a defective one.

    "D"

  14. 0

    AlBook

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    If AVCHD is the same as H.264, then is there a way to convert m2ts files to something playable on the Mac without re-encoding?

    I have a Sony AVCHD DVD camera (HDR-UX1) and I'm not clear as to why Sony hard disk based AVCHD cameras are supported but not DVD based ones.

  15. 0

    DavoMrMac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Dana, yes very strange.

    Have you listened to your footage to see if you are getting any of the tape motor noise in the background of your sound. They vary from HV20 to HV20.

    Good luck.