Benches Uncategorized

4

10 things I like about Pages '08...

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

*...and 5 things I don't.* First, the good news:

1. You can now use the Document inspector to make Headers and Footers disappear completely. In Pages 2, you had to define their distance from the top of the document as zero inches, which still left a visible header or footer.

2. You can now get a word count on a selection of text, which you couldn't previously do. Even better, the word count is dynamic so, as you type, the word count increases. Nice! What's not so nice is that the only way to activate this feature is through the Document inspector > Info. It would be nice to have a menu item, keyboard command, or at least an icon on the toolbar or the format bar. (That'll be a to-do item for Pages '10.)

3. Speaking of the Format bar, that's a new goody that puts many of the items previously found in the various inspectors close at hand. My guess is that many new users found the inspectors somewhat cumbersome, and I can't disagree with them. They take some getting used to.

4. I love the fact that all inserted images default as "Floating" objects (Floating, by the way, is Apple's new terminology for Fixed on Page; they listened to you, Peggy!). In the 2-1/2 years I've been using Pages, I've yet to need an Inline object.

5. Something else that caused new users to tear their hair out was the bug that caused printed documents to shrink whenever the Comments feature was turned on. This no longer happens.

6. While I've never felt a burning need to have software slap my wrist when it doesn't like my grammar, many people will love the new Proofreader feature that flags a number of grammar no-no's.

7. There was always an oddity in Pages that, if you set up the Preferences to load a blank document (or one of your own templates), it seemed impossible to find the Template Chooser. You had to hold down the Option key and click on File > New. Intuitive, eh? Apple fixed that by adding a new menu item in the File menu: "New from Template Chooser."

8. You can now highlight a word or a phrase, click on Edit > Writing Tools > Search in Google (or Wikipedia). This is a godsend for writers and other plagiarists.

9. There was a bug in the Bookmarks feature that seemed to tick off no one but me. It worked like this: when you sorted your Bookmarks by Page (lowest page number is shown first) -- as you would when you've got a bunch of book chapters -- then saved and quit the document, when you loaded it again, the Bookmarks would be sorted by Name. Not a huge problem to once again click on Page, but annoying nevertheless. Apple finally fixed it.

10. You now have the option to show (or turn off) the connecting lines between text boxes. It used to be that if you had a text box on page 1 and a linked text box on page 4, it was easy to forget what linked to what. Pages solves that by drawing a line from the first box to the linked box. Nice feature.

*And 5 things I'm not in love with.*

1. The Export feature is still a pain to work with. Say you're using Pages to create a document for a Word user; you can write the entire document in Pages' native format, then Export it at the end. Or you can choose the Export feature every time you want to do a "save." (But it's not really a save. It's a Save As -- meaning you have to rename the document each time.) What a pain! I don't like either of those options. I want Pages to remember that I exported it to Word and that this is my default format for the document. I don't want to have to rename the file each time.

2. I'm not sold on this Page Layout vs. Word Processing thing yet. There are times when I simply don't know what kind of document I'm going to create until I'm well into it. In asking us to choose one or the other, it seems to be Apple's way to get us to begin a project with one of Apple's templates. Begin a document with their blank Word Processing template, and none of the graphics icons are available to you on the Format bar. Related to this is the fact that there is no more need to click in the margin and drag to select an object. This absolutely plagued new users. And understandably so. It's much easier to select objects that have been sent backward.

3. I don't understand the menu position of the Save As Template menu item. We have Save, followed by Save As -- and underneath Send to iWeb is Save As Template. What's the logic of that? Shouldn't it be grouped with other Save commands?

4. Another nit that bugs me: I turn on Invisibles because I want to see everything invisible ... like paragraph marks. Why is it that the last paragraph mark on the page continues to be invisible? (Note: this also applied to previous versions of Pages)

5. When you begin a document with one of Apple's Page Layout templates, there is no visual indication whether an object is Floating or Inline. It took me awhile to figure out that all objects are Floating, since there is no text layer in Page Layout templates (all text seems to be in text boxes or inside objects). You can have an Inline object only in a document that began life as a Word Processing template. This is one of those "interesting" features that's sure to bedevil users.

*And 2 things I'm not sure about.*

1. The Track Changes feature. Every time you type a sentence, then move your cursor back to insert some text, Pages changes the newly inserted text to blue and puts a Comments-like notation on the left side of the screen. You have the option to click on a check mark to accept the change (which changes the text color to black), or an X to reject the change (which erases the new text). Of course, when you move your cursor back to the end of the paragraph, as everyone will when they're done futzing around with the change, Pages will read any new text as a change in text and turn it blue. It's maddening. It strikes me as a good idea for a feature that's poorly implemented here. I'm a novelist; I constantly go back and forth inside a paragraph. I don't want Pages flagging my every utterance.

2. The slowness issue. Pages was never slow on either of my computers. It'll be interesting to see if this issue has been successfully addressed for other people. I wonder if the Page Layout vs. Word Processing mode is, in some way, a fix. Let us know.

-Dennis

4 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You picked up on many of the same things I did

    *2. I'm not sold on this Page Layout vs. Word Processing thing yet. There are times when I simply don't know what kind of document I'm going to create until I'm well into it.*
    I hadn't thought about this issue but I don't see it as a biggy - default everything as a word processing document. If it becomes too unwieldy you can cut and paste it into a Page Layout.

    *3. I don't understand the menu position of the Save As Template menu item.*
    Why not a generic Save menu item with the options in the dialog box. That seems to be the way most programs handle the issue.

    *5. When you begin a document with one of Apple's Page Layout templates, there is no visual indication whether an object is Floating or Inline. It took me awhile to figure out that all objects are Floating, since there is no text layer in Page Layout templates (all text seems to be in text boxes or inside objects). You can have an Inline object only in a document that began life as a Word Processing template. This is one of those "interesting" features that's sure to bedevil users.*
    I think the old Pages way was a bigger bedeviler than this one. Since I'm from the 'I don't need no stinkin' manuals' school of computers I don't know, but I'd think that the manual would start out with an explanation of this. If not, the bedevilment should be short lived, which wasn't the case with Pages 1 & 2.

    I'll add to your don't like list: I really don't like the small size of the contextual menubar of Pages nor the data entry bar and formula entry bar of Numbers. They are too too small.

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    +I'll add to your don't like list: I really don't like the small size of the contextual menubar of Pages nor the data entry bar and formula entry bar of Numbers. They are too too small.+

    Time for some bifocals, perfesser.

    -Dennis

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    *Time for some bifocals, perfesser.*
    That would be a step backwards from my tri-focals! On my desktop at work the menubars are fine but on my MacBook they are too small - its a matter of how many pixels are packed into an inch, dontcha know.

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for your comments, dwb. Now that Pages 3 has been around for a few days, I'm hoping other people will post their likes and dislikes, too.

    Here's the big question I'd really like answered: for those people for whom the previous version of Pages was unbearably slow, does Pages 3 address that issue for you?

    -Dennis