13 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
varjak paw ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
You can only deauthorize computers you no longer have access to if you read the five-computer authorization limit, at which point a button allowing you deauthorize all five will appear in your account (you can do this once per year). Otherwise you cannot deauthorize the computer yourself. You'll have to contact the iTunes Music Store customer support department through the form at the bottom of
this web page and explain the problem to them and ask if they'll deauthorize your computers for you. If they will, you can then reauthorize the computers you're using as appropriate.And next time, don't forget to deauthorize a system
before it leaves your control.Good luck.
- 0
Sean Kelly7 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Dave,
First let me start off by saying that it seems to me that you work for Apple, and this post assumes such. If I am wrong, then I will just be ranting to some random person on the net! π
I've been using iTunes for quite some time and really enjoy the product. I have purchased quite a few songs because I was tired of pirating music and fearing that the big, bad RIAA would come after me. iTunes provides a very amicable solution for me and people like me.
However, the inability to deauthorize a computer that is no longer available to me is the ONE HUGE problem I have with using the product. I spend money to purchase songs and am forced to authorize a computer to play them. That's fine, I have no problem with that part. What I DO have a problem with is only being "allowed" to clear my deauth list "once a year" so that I can listen to music
I purchased or have to count on the "good will" of customer support to clear my authorization list so that I can use the items which I have purchased.Apple really needs to wake up and smell the coffee because this whole issue should be managable by the users. Period. I spend my money to purchase music from the Music Store. I should be able to change computers and/or do something as human as forget to deauthorize a computer without being penalized for it. This sort of "customer service" is ludicrous and you can't expect people to want to continue to use your service if there is a chance that the music they buy will one day be inaccessible to them because your CS department didn't "feel" like clearing your authorization list.
When you listen to iTunes music on computers that do not belong do you, you should be able to deauthorize those computers remotely. Work computers, internet cafeteria computers, etc. should not have to be hunted down to be able to use something that I spent my money on.
I understand the need for security and to *** down on piracy and I'm all for it. But when you keep people from using something they purchased just because they forgot to do something, you're heading down the wrong avenue for business success.
Anyway...my .02
Sean
- 0
Otto42 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
If I am wrong, then I will just be ranting to some random person on the net! π
Dave doesn't work for Apple. You're ranting to some random person on the net. π
I should be able to change computers and/or do something as human as forget to deauthorize a computer without being penalized for it.
Here's the thing.. they had to make a decision when creating this DRM. They had one of two options:
1. Authorizing a computer sticks to the computer and doesn't have to be connected to the internet to play songs.
2. You do have to be connected to the internet to play songs.
Method 1 means that they can't deauthorize a computer remotely. Method 2 means that they can.
They went with method 1, and I think you'll agree that not having to connect to the internet every time you play a purchased track is worth the minor inconvienence of the current authorization/deauthorization process.
As sophisticated as this stuff is, it's not magical. Computers operate independantly. What the authorization process does is to download the decryption key for your purchased music to the computer. In order to "deauthorize" a computer, that computer must be instructed to remove that key. Obviously without access to the computer, this can't be done. Apple doesn't have any way to remotely connect to the old computer and remove that key, so deauthorizing it from their side doesn't really mean anything. The old computer can still play those songs because it still has the key.
- 0
varjak paw ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Otto is correct; I don't work for Apple. Apple employees who post in the Discussions are clearly identified.
Normally I won't take on such policy issues, but I disagree with your premise. You
do have complete control over the authorization and deauthorization of your systems. There's a deauthorization command in every copy of iTunes.The fact that you can't do it remotely is an artifact of the intent to which iTMS tracks are to be put. Tracks are sold for your personal use only, so it's presumed that the systems on which they'll be played are accessible to you or to a close friend or relative. The iTMS tracks are not, per the terms of sale, to be widely distributed, so remote deauthorization isn't something that has been or is likely to be included since it's not normally needed (and if someone does have such a need in regular course of operation, they're probably violating at least the spirit if not the letter of the Terms of Sale). There's no way you should be authorizing systems in an Internet cafe or any other system that you'll only be using for an hour or so; if you need that much portability of your music, buy an iPod. At work should be no problem; just don't forget to deauthorize the system if you leave that employer.
Yes, sometime people forget to deauthorize a system before they sell it or give it away. The ITMS will in such circumstances sometimes make an exception and deauthorize all the systems attached to an account. But it's an exception and something that should not be needed except under rare circumstances. But if you forget to deauthorize, that's really your problem, just as it would be if you left your music player in a rental car, or left your license plates on a car you just sold.
- 0
Sean Kelly7 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
<quote>But if you forget to deauthorize, that's really your problem, just as it would be if you left your music player in a rental car, or left your license plates on a car you just sold.</quote>]
My big beef is that Apple and the ITMS have more responsibility than this. They provide you with a means of buying songs in a way that no one else does. If they completely disregard the experience their customers are having and the ease of use of their products, they are not providing a valuable service. Most people are on broadband services anyways, so buy a few extra servers to handle the checking of authorization and go with number 2 suggestion above, IMO.
If I pay for something tangible (i.e. a book) I get a reciept, and I lose item THEN that is my problem. The tangible item costs materials and money to create and ship. When you are selling digital items (i.e. music files) that only have a one time cost of creation, if I "lose" it (in this case, become unable to use it but have proof that I purchased it) then I should be given another. Yes?
If you say the answer is no, then I have to ask these questions. Is the ITMS in the business of only catering to the computer savvy and those that know how to write a CD to back up their files? Is the ITMS only interested scamming people out of their purchases by saying "Well, if you forget to do this, we get your money and you get nothing to show for it"?
We can sit here and argue about "Well, the terms and conditions say you're responsible for backing up your files yourself" all day long, but just because it's written in a Service Agreement doesn't make it good policy. If I go to a resteraunt and order something that gets destroyed (I spill my drink on it, someone knocks it off the table), the resteraunt replaces the meal at no charge. Why? Because they want to create customer loyalty by giving good customer service. Yes, it costs them extra money, but good customer service and thinking about the people using what you are providing ALWAYS comes back to you tenfold in the end.
The ITMS, via their own FAQ page, states "Well, we'll only give you permission to deauthorize your computers once a year" and is exhibiting the kind of elitist attitude that Apple has been known to put forth before. The ITMS is a new way of doing business that no one else has done before, so all of the old rules don't apply. I'm an online book publisher and my policy is that if a person buys a digital copy of a book and lose it, if they can prove to me that they purchased a copy already, I have no problems resending their file to them. Do I open myself to the occasional hoax? Yes, but I have far fewer customers than the ITMS and I am able to provide good customer service to my customers who don't want to pay for something they purchased twice.
There are new music services popping up all the time that are competing with ITMS and service issues like this will come back to bite them in the butt if enough people start forgetting to deauthorize their computer. There ARE ways around having to use the authorization entirely, but why should someone have to resort to that in order to listen to what they rightfully purchased?
In summary, I suppose that the ultimate point is this:
This service may not be "magical" but it can be improved. How? I'm not sure, but then I don't do this for a living.
If ITMS doesn't figure out how to do this, then someone else will and ITMS will suffer for not being a forward thinking service. There are enough people out there that think this service is worth paying for and NOT having to go out and buy a CD that ITMS will not see a significant loss but, in fact, may see a significant gain not only in sales, but customer loyalty. Because there is always the trusty CD that I can go purchase instead of buying on ITMS that means I can listen to the music regardless of having authorization or not..
shrugs. - 0
Otto42 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Most people are on broadband services anyways, so buy a few extra servers to handle the checking of authorization and go with number 2 suggestion above, IMO.
It's not really about the server capacity. It's about the fact that most people don't want to be connected to the internet to play their music.
You said that "most people are on broadband". That's only recently true, and in any case, the best number I've heard is only 60%. At the time they started selling music online, that number was still closer to 30-35%.
And if I had to be connected to the internet to play my music, I'd get my music elsewhere. I do not need some company somewhere monitoring my music listening using my own computer and music I darn well paid for.
The ITMS, via their own FAQ page, states "Well, we'll only give you permission to deauthorize your computers once a year" and is exhibiting the kind of elitist attitude that Apple has been known to put forth before.
This is actually a fairly recent change. Before they didn't offer any way to deauthorize computers short of having the actual computer there. But they got so many requests from people who formatted their boxes without deauthorizing first that they created this. In other words, it's not "elitist", it's them "listening to their customer's needs".
There are new music services popping up all the time that are competing with ITMS
And every single one of them has far, far more strict DRM methods than iTMS does. Have you even read what WMP10's DRM is capable of? That whole "Plays For Sure" initiative Microsoft has been pushing is designed specifically to give customers music that expires after a period of time. Stop paying your monthly fee, and your portable device erases the music after some period of time, without connecting it to a computer or the internet.
- 0
Chris Frank1 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Well, that was quite the discussion on deauthorizing a computer. It did answer my question - so thank you to all. Whether I think it's good customer service or not, I know the way iTunes does it. And since I don't own Apple, I'll be a good socialist and go with the law. π
- 0
Sean Kelly7 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
This is actually a fairly recent change. Before they didn't offer any way to deauthorize computers short of having the actual computer there. But they got so many requests from people who formatted their boxes without deauthorizing first that they created this. In other words, it's not "elitist", it's them "listening to their customer's needs".
If they were listening to the customer's needs, then why allow it only once a year? This is a temporary fix to a problem that could definitely happen more than once a year. Anyway, I don't mean to beat a dead horse, but there it is.
Thanks for the discussion
- 0
Otto42 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
If they were listening to the customer's needs, then why allow it only once a year?
Because it breaks the DRM limitations. When you reset your account on the server, you're only resetting there. All those 5 authorized computers can still play the music, it doesn't actually deauthorize them
This is a temporary fix to a problem that could definitely happen more than once a year.
It's a tradeoff. They can't make it unlimited, because that defeats the whole point of the DRM in the first place. Since you can authorize five times, then reset and auth another five times, that's 10 times you'd have to format your computer or otherwise lose your authorization incorrectly in a year. How often do you erase your computer?
- 0
Lomin ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
OK, to throw in my 2 cents on the three important things I have learned:).
One, I have learned once I have enough songs I burn it to a CD, then reimport those songs back in and get rid of the M4P files that are those songs.
Two, Windows is a POS OS, which I knew anyway, which is why I had to go with option one. My problem being that after a few weeks to a couple months windows would not be able to find the ntldr or ntoskrnl, I would put them back in, but still not be able to load Windows. I would reinstall Windows back on the computer, install Itunes, Itunes authorizes another computer for me to play purchased music on, even though it is the same comp, I just had to reinstall the OS. I didn't get the opportunity to deauthorize the comp because it is the same comp that just messed up.
When I hit #6, I will definitely use the deauthorizing of "my other comps" as posted by Dave.
Three:
ALWAYS BACKUP YOUR MUSIC AND IMPORTANT FILES
. I do this anyway, just thought I would throw it out there for others. - 0
SinTexas ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm with Lomin. However, I still have more than 5 computers than need to be authorized, have an iPod that just died and just left a job and forgot to
deauthorize, of course.But yes: BACKUP music files!
PowerBook G4 Mac OS X (10.3.9)
- 0
Rich74 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
What happens if a computer at work has been 'Erased and Installed' and it wasn't deauthorized ? It no longer has the key therefore it's not able to play your music but is listed as authorized with Apple in your account. If (presumably) Apple are registering the authorised machines by a unique identifier i.e. their MAC address or serial number, then you should still be able to deauthorize from that particualr machine...
- 0
donkoller ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
My work computer was replaced (rather than erased and reinstalled) which is normal as we upgrade systems. I didn't know/remember to deauthorize it. My new work system is now authorized, but I am at the limit of 5. I'd sure like to remove that old system from my list.
Sounds like the solution is to deauthorize all, and then just re-authorize the systems in use.