Benches Printing and scanning

15

Using "Pages" for High-end DTP

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I have been reading this discussion for quite some time now and discovered that many of "Pages" users are attempting to use the program for DTP work (desk top publishing). So the questions fly around my head and beg me to post them here:

1) Has anyone sent a file (PDF) to their service bureau and or printer?

2) What was the Output directions on the "Read Me" chart? 300 dpi, neg WrongRead, emulsion down?

3) Did you request a MatchPrint?

4) Was the PDF converted to Vector or EPS prior to color seps?

5) How did the colors separate?

6) Any errors? RIP errors? Trapping? Flood or Knockout issues?

7) Did the offset operator match the MatchPrint?

Anyone?

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    KevinCu

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Dragon,

    Some of us who use Pages are exploring this, but for me it's an entry level approach to the qustions you've asked. I'm writing a book about Macs and I'll have to rewrite it because of a change in direction, so other insights to your questions might enlighted some of us.

  2. 0

    Dragon 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hey Kevin, thank you for the response. I posed these questions for general purposes only. I have more than enough experience in the high end graphic world to know that Pages may not work for me. I am more interested in hearing about the trials and tribulations individual users may have encountered.

    Personally, I strongly feel that Apple has provided an absolutely fabulous, cost effective, alternative to the offerings by MS Corp. Elegant, easy to use - once you know how to make it dance, without the full-on down your throat "This formatting is for your own Good" MS way. (I'm not a great fan of MS but I do understand that there are a few people out there that have no clue and so MS helps them out.)

    Mr. Chairman, I reserve the rest of the time alloted to me in case I may rant further - in the near future.

  3. 0

    KevinCu

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hey again,

    I'm going to see if Pages can work, I'll be heading to FEDEX/Kinkos this week to do a trial of Pages in various "versions" of it's output, what would you suggest that I ask for in an "input" and "output" approach?

    As one who is just getting into this area and as I mentioned to Kinkos a few weeks back, I don't want to spend a whole lot of time figuring out details as I progress toward the rewrite of my book. I'm looking to "narrow down" some of the key items that will help reduce problems in the future. As I've seen from Lulu.com and other POD publishing, I'd take out 80% of what I do if I know that it would be less troublesome in the publishing areas.

    Do you have any suggestions as to what to ask for? I've also found no books about the technical aspects of publishing to help writers, only how to write better.

    Your comments and questions are welcome as I progress toward my goal.

  4. 0

    Melissa Cyber Element Inc

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I was so excited to see what this new Pages can do. I create custom digital scrapbooks. I use Photoshop. I love being able to simply drag and drop everything into Pages. I finally sent a book to the printer. I print on a Xerox digital press.

    Something happened on the way to the printer...

    I saved my files as pdf and didn't touch them, sent them to print. Everything that was transparent - my png files I added to the pages and the included nifty frames in the program - all printed with a very light ugly shadow. I have no idea how it happened. There is no shadow in my files onscreen and I printed a page on the inkjet - nothing. But the digital prints are unusable.

    So... in an attempt to fix it (I don't want to re-do the pages in Photoshop), I saved each page as a jpg in Photoshop - or you can do it in Preview. But, there is a difference. If I save as a jpg in Preview, the pages are 11.5 x 11.5 and 150 ppi - very weird. In Photoshop I make them 200 ppi and they come out 12 x 12, like they should. I also have one page that the text didn't save at all in.

    So, now that they are all jpgs, I will made a new pdf in Photohop and have sent it off to print. I'm crossing my fingers!

  5. 0

    Dragon 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Melissa, I'm sorry to hear about your printing mishap. I believe your problem stems from the png images. You see PNG images are meant for viewing on the web and not really for print. PNG images have a transparency layer that is best suited for the web and when you send the image to a printer the printer driver tries it's best to interpret the file. Thus the soft grey shadow in the background. I believe that your best best would be to flatten your images first, save them as either Tiff, EPS or even JPEG then drag them into pages. Be sure that when you flatten the file the background color is set to white - digital white should read C0, M0, Y0, K0, in photoshop.

    I would suggest, from a graphic artist POV, that you set up a master page file in Quark Xpress or In-Design rather than using Pages. You should also be able to do this with Adobe Illustrator. I personally believe Apple designed iWorks as an alternative program suite to compete with M$ Office suite. As an added value the savings in price cannot be matched by M$ Corp.

    For very simple layouts generated by the home-user Apples iWork suite beats the pants off M$ Office by 'Light Years'!

    I hope this helps.

  6. 0

    Melissa Cyber Element Inc

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have to disagree with you about png. The files are way too large for web use and there are severe issues with browser compatibility. They are perfect, however for digital scrapbooking. I love having all the levels of transparency and lots of colors with no compression. If it was just my png files causing this problem, I might try an alternative as you suggest, but I need transparency - white backgrounds will not work. And gif files are useless for printing. However, my files are not alone... there are nasty gray boxes around the frames included in iWork. Of course, they are probably pngs as well. And, just to drive my point home, I've never, ever had a problem printing png files before and I've been doing this for over 3 years - different printers, different file formats, different software programs (I was a web designer before that and a video game designer before that - I've been working with graphics for a very long time - just to establish my background - I got that you are graphic artist as well).

    Coming from all digital, I have never liked page layout programs. I have In-Design, but I've never learned how to use it. I live in Photoshop. I can do Illustrator too, but my files are all raster and there is no advantage to using Illustrator.

    So why am I using Pages? Because the built in frames are fun, quick and easy, I can drag and drop all of my files (I have to open each one and drag them to a new document in Photoshop and it takes too long) and I can mask my images without cropping (I can use layer masks in Photoshop, but it takes way more time) and I don't need to worry about resizing up and down (I haven't really confirmed this last part, but so far it all looks great). So the bottom line is that I can whip up a book in a fraction of the time in Pages that it takes me to do the same work in Photoshop - a book is a min. of 20 pages.

    And, the time savings is great enough that I'm committed to solving this issue! I don't know if I would see the same time savings in In-Design or not, but I know that I would be spending lots more time learning it. So, thank you for your input and suggestions and for responding to my post. I'm stubborn, I want it to work in Pages!

    I did figure out how to flatten a pdf in Acrobat today. I think that might help, as well. I have a pdf-x test at the printer, hopefully it will be done tomorrow.

  7. 0

    Walt K

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Melissa,

    I had a similar experience with a recent newsleter. I used a frame on two photos — the one with the ragged edges that crops in slightly from the full picture — and the edges that should have been transparent were a light gray when printed by a commerial printer, even though they printed correctly on my inkjet.

    This harkens back to Pages 1 where the drop shadows were messed up when converted to PDF. I suspect it's pretty much the same thing here. Perhaps we should all send feedback to Apple.

    Walt

  8. 0

    Melissa Cyber Element Inc

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yes, we should send feedback to Apple. Tech support was quick to dismiss me and blame the printer. I knew and now really know it was Pages but had no way to communicate with them or prove it on the phone. I told the tech I thought it was a flaw in the program - I don't think he liked that. If we voice it, maybe they will see it's a problem - the tech never heard of such a thing!

  9. 0

    sashura

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi,

    I've been publishing a glossy magazine for 18 months now, laid out entirely in Pages, printed at a locall pirnt shop here in Normandy on flat-bed presses.

    My work finishes when I deliver press quality PDFs to my printers, they then take over. I am using Adobe Acrobat/Distiller to convert Pages files into PDFs with additional pre-press checking and verifying with PitStop.

    So, I can answer some of your questions:

    1 - yes

    2 - no idea

    3 - no

    4 - conversion process: Pages - print to PS - convert through Distiller

    5 - no problem with converting colours with PitStop

    6 - not aware of any errors

    7 - can't answer this.

    Export to PDF or Print as PDF do not work. They produce fine PDFs for office printing or sending out proofs, but for professional printers you need to use the three step conversion process: Pages-Print to PostScript-create PDF (with Acrobat Distiller). This allows four colour CMYK separation. I am not sure I can explain why, but this seems to be the only (or the best) way to produce press-quality PDFs.

    I have been writing a small blog on wroking with Pages, mostly to remind myself how I'd done something... Producing PDFs is a major task, but it can be done.

    Cheers,

    Alex,

    i-work-in-pages.blogspot.com

  10. 0

    Dragon 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hello everyone. I want to thank all of you who have responded to this post. The questions I posted was to generate feedback/dialog from people who have successfully used Pages to create layouts for high-end DTP. I must say the responses are extremely positive.

    Sashura (Alex) has the methods by which, I believe, Pages can/may be an alternate layout program to possibly Quark or In-Design. Excellent reply. Thank you very much Alex.

    All the best to everyone from Newport Beach, California - where the fires are raging.

  11. 0

    Melissa Cyber Element Inc

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have my test prints back and can confirm that PDF-X is not the way to go. Not only are the shadows there, but my images were compressed quite a bit. Saving as a jpg and then as a pdf again worked, but it's so much work. I tried saving as PS then again as a PDF and it didn't work for me, Acrobat gave me an error. I'll try it in Preview. I don't need CMYK with a digital press, so that part is not critical for me. Thanks for all who responded.

  12. 0

    Dragon 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Melissa. Please do not get me wrong when I say something is missing. I do not intend to discount your experiences but rather try to help and resolve your printing issues. From the responses you posted it seems to me that you are looking to streamline your workflow. Perhaps inquiring your service provider as to the precise file format, preferred by their system/machine guidelines, could help. Perhaps the conversion from PDF-X is creating difficulties through Acrobat translation filters? I do not know but something is definitely amiss.

    I don't believe PDF-X and PNG image files is the way to go. There may be a step you may be missing in your workflow. You stated that you have years experience as a graphic artist and I believe you, but something is missing.

    As for CMYK not being a factor for a digital press I beg to differ. The company I worked for many moons ago was the very first in Southern California to introduce the AGFA Chromapress On-Demand digital printing system to Los Angeles. Web-fed, 4 over 4 'Full' color printing at 600 DPI resolution. It was a totally new process that needed to be taught to graphic designers representing major Hollywood movie studios as well as megabucks ad agencies. We presented many seminars to help the designers understand a "New" workflow. They could now save out there images as 72 dpi, CYMK files that will be printed as 600 dpi - 'Full Color' images. So this prompts me to ask the question "What machine are you using? Chromapress or Indigo?" Electronic file preparation differ from system to system and is the key to successful output. Full, 4 color CMYK images being the key.

    The primary reason I created this post was to find individuals who are using 'Pages' for serious 'High-end' DTP. Having these individuals share their knowledge/experiences here would serve as a valuable information center.

    Alex has been successful with the workflow method he devised. Perhaps you can inquire as to his techniques?

    I anticipate more questions regarding this issue, for I too am searching for an alternative method of production.

    In highest regards. All the best to you.

  13. 0

    Melissa Cyber Element Inc

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Sorry if I seemed a bit touchy from my previous post, I get a little defensive about my experience and didn't express myself clearly. I print on a Xerox. It's an older model, basically a gigantic room sized laser printer. The machine does all of the color conversion, so RGB and CMYK both work. I agree with you about the PDF-X, but I'm very attached to my png files. It's the "standard" in the digital scrapbooking world for cross platform, cross application use. I have literally over 100,000 files that are all png and jpg, so converting now is not an option. I don't think my printer - the person - knows the precise format.

    I think it has something to do with the layers in the PDF. I don't know much about PDFs. Flattening them works, if there was a way to save the PDF out of iWork without the transparency and flattened, that would work - I think. I will be trying the postscript trick, my previous attempt failed.

  14. 0

    Dragon 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    No offense taken. We all learn things whenever we ask questions.

    Holy smokes! 100,000 images in your library! Even with Photoshop running a script to make the conversions, let's say 24/7—that would be time consuming.

    And oh my God, here we go again - I'm going to ask you a question.

    What version of Acrobat are you using? No even better yet... Which Xerox machine is your printer using? Because, after reading your post again you stated that "Flattening them works." There in lies a clue. Ever since Adobe released Acrobat 6 and layering, in order for certain 'Older' technologies to get it straight and print correctly the files had to be flattened.

    Boom! I believe you've identified the missing step in your workflow. If you re-read sashura's (Alex) posting - 1) Print as postscript, 2) Distiller to create PDF (depending on the version, this step should flatten the file), 3) Trouble shoot the file with PitStop (a pre-press software to control color separation, trapping and other functions as well).

    I haven't upgraded Acrobat Professional since I purchased version 6 but I would recommend the additional step to flatten and save your files to say Acrobat 5. I realize it's an extra step but isn't the final printed piece what's important? And yes, you are correct in saying that CMYK images doesn't apply in your situation since the Xerox machine can interpret and handle RGB to CMYK conversions for you.

    I'll work on discovering the flattening issue in regards to iWork generating a PDF and post my findings here.

    All the best

    Lance

    (Dragon 1)

  15. 0

    Melissa Cyber Element Inc

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Digital Scrapbooking is crazy. The files are all "elements" like papers, staples, brads, stickers, alphas (so there are 26+ files for each one of those!) etc. So imagine a room full of scrapbooking supplies, or better yet, a store full - that's what I have digitally! Digital Asset management is a nightmare - and an entirely different subject!

    I have CS2, so version 7 of Acrobat Professional. The Xerox is a 6060 - I think. One of the few printers that prints large enough for me (my prints are 12 x 12 full bleed).

    I have a question for you. I did a ton of research on PDFs to figure out what format would be the smallest to send over the internet with the best quality (my files are still way over 100MB). PDFs turned out to be one of those subjects like color management - the more you know, the more you realize you have no clue. I have been saving my pdf files to be compatible with version 7 for smaller files sizes (which I'm not sure how much it matters at my massive sizes). So, if I save files for version 5 - that might be better? I do this in Bridge / Photoshop.

    I say I think it's the layer thing because I'm guessing. I know they are layered by the screen re-draw. When the pages in the pdf load, the background comes in whole, then the shadows, then the graphics and photos. I think if the image was flat the problem would go away. If I can just flatten the PDF from iWork - it might work.

    Alex has a great solution, but my concern is the time factor - not to mention the errors I get. All the time saved designing in iWork is now being used to make a printable pdf file. If I was doing typical DTP like a brochure or something, it wouldn't be an issue. But, I'm cranking out 5 to 20+ 12" x 12" graphics intense files with each document I create. My poor computer chugs and chugs and makes all kinds of nasty noises while attempting the post script thing and the results:

    Preview gives me an error - Postscript conversion error - can't convert to pdf. Acrobat gives me an error - Offending Command: imageDistiller; ErroInfo: DCTDecodeFilter Cannot allocate 79074892 bytes

    Maybe my files are just too large.