Benches / Printing and scanning
Canon i960 and Airport Extreme Printing Problems
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I have been having problems printing with my Canon i960 printer when it is connected to my Airport Extreme. I have all the latest drivers from Canon and Apple but when I print something, the printing will stop partway through and wont start back up again.
Printing works fine when I connect my PB to the Canon directly over USB but I cant figure out how to fix it when I want to print over Airport.
I have read that it is a firmware problem with Airport and have tried manually installing 5.4 but I cant seem to connect to my network now (Im having a really good day).
Anyway, does installing the 5.4 firmware for Airport Extreme fix the printing problem until Apple finds a fix?
Thanks.
15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Henry B. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The best firmware version to run on an Airport Extreme Base Station is currently 5.5.1 found at:
http://www.apple.com/support/downloads/airportextremefirmware551formacosx.html...but no firmware version for the Airport Extreme Base Station is known to fix the problem you are having with the Canon i960. The exact problem you note (printer hanging in mid-job) has been noted by many others, most often by users of MacOS 10.4 - you won't have to search very far back to find several existing discussions on this topic in this forum. There seems to be no fix for this problem, and my suspicion is that there will be no fix until Canon updates the drivers for their printers.
- 0
Daniel Mannus ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I wish HenryB. that you would accept that the printers work perfectly on USB but when connected via Airport Express they don't! They worked on Airport Express before OS10.4.3 or maybe earlier.
Ergo the fault is Apple's, do I have to repeat it Henry B. the fault is Apple's.
Since you seem to have an in there please get them to do something about it. Sorry to be so rude Henry but I have lost all respect for Apple in this case as I can no longer use my portable to print through Airport Express. - 0
Henry B. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yes Canon's printers work just fine via a direct USB connection - that is the way Canon designed them to work.
But... say for a moment that Canon designed their printer drivers in such a way that they only work properly when the printer is connected directly via USB, and in such a way that they won't work properly when the printer is connected via an Airport Express/Base Station. It isn't hard to imagine why this might happen - for example, Canon might have implemented a method of improving printing performance that doesn't follow Apple's design guidelines yet does work for a USB-only connection. Would you still maintain it is Apple's reponsibility to fix a design problem caused by Canon?
Of course, I have no way of knowing who is at fault here... but given Canon's known lack of any interest in supporting network printing from Macs, I am not so sure Canon can be cleared of responsibility in causing this problem. I have no more "in" with Apple than you or anyone else, and certainly I could be very wrong in my assessment of who has the responsibility for fixing this problem with Canon printers. All I'm doing here is pointing out there really are two sides to this story.
- 0
Rocc ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
HI. This is my first post to Apple discussions, although I've been reading them for quite some time. Thanks to those who spend time helping to solve others' problems.
I've been having the exact same problem with my Canon i960 and airport extreme ever since I upgraded to Tiger from Panther. At first it would Stop Jobs before it ever started printing. After uninstalling and reinstalling the latest driver from Canon twice, it overcame that problem, but now it is freezing up in the middle of a print job every 4 or 5 jobs. Canon and Apple are passing the buck on this issue, Canon saying the printer is not made to work wirelessly and Apple saying the i960 is not on their list of OSX printers.
Yesterday, in a tech call to Apple we totally reset the base station, and in the process uploaded firmware 5.6. (Now I read that perhaps I should have stayed with 5.5.1. Is there any way to go back to 5.5.1? I haven't tried it, but is downgrading a possibility? No other problems with the wireless internet that I've noticed so far, and it sounds like 5.5.1 still has the same printer issues, so I guess i can stay with 5.6?)
Today the printer is freezng again. I have to shut off the printer, unplug the Base Station, plug it back in and turn on the printer again, quit the app, reopen the app and then MAYBE it will work. Or I unplug the printer from the base station and plug it directly into the Powerbook. Then it will print just fine.
I was considering giving the i960 to a friend and buying the Canon Pixma i5200R, so at least Canon won't be able to pass the buck anymore, but now I read that people are having problems with that printer too. I am loyal to both Apple and Canon, so I want to make this work somehow.
So now I am thinking of just getting another printer and a USB hub for the main computer and putting the i960 in my son's room for the other computer and giving up on the wireless printing altogether. I hate to spend the extra money, but it is better than being frustrated on a daily basis. Or should I hold out for an upgrade, either in Tiger or the Canon driver? I don't know whose fault it is. I'm leaning toward Apple, since the Tiger upgrade was the start of the problems. I was totally problem-free until then. Suggestions? Does anyone know if Apple or Canon are interested in and/or working on resolving this issue?
- 0
Henry B. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
You can go back to firmware version 5.5.1 by using the software provided by Apple at:
http://www.apple.com/support/downloads/airportextremefirmware551formacosx.htmlApple and Canon aren't really "passing the buck". Both Canon and Apple clearly agree on the same thing - which is that this printer won't work when connected via the Airport Base Station.
I'm not optimistic that either Apple or Canon are interested in fixing this problem any time soon, so if you really badly want wireless printing I recommend you buy a new non-Canon printer.
- 0
Rocc ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
You're right that neither Apple nor Canon made any promises that the i960 will work with Airport. It's just frustrating that from June 2004 until now it did indeed work flawlessly with the Airport Extreme. Not a single tiny problem. But as soon as I upgraded to Tiger it was all over. So I guess I should just consider myself lucky that it worked when it did, although if it had not worked in the beginning I could have exchanged the printer for another model. Now, post-Tiger, I'm stuck with a printer that doesn't suit my needs. I am a bit spoiled, of course, by all things Apple usually working so smoothly. Usually upgrades make my life easier and my work more efficient, which several aspects of Tiger have indeed done, but this issue has me flummoxed.
Thanks for responding.
- 0
Simon Abrams ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
What I'd like to know is how this issue is considered solved. I guess the "solution" is to not use a Canon i960? What kind of solution is that? And why, then, was the printer available for sale in the Apple Store, where I bought mine?
- 0
Henry B. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
This printer was sold in the Apple Store because it works, as designed and advertised, when connected to the Mac's USB port.
Neither Canon nor Apple make any claims this printer is supported for use when connected via an Airport Express or Base Station.
- 0
Simon Abrams ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I understand that; I guess it's just frustrating having to compromise, rather than have full access to all the benefits of having a wireless network. Plus, I like the idea of being able to use my gear to its full potential.
I won't even start complaining about the scanner I got that sort-of works...
- 0
J Siegel ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Actually, I have a S900, and have had this exact same problem with the USB wireless printing and the Airport Extreme ever since I have had both (? 3yrs). I have had every Canon driver, and every AEBS update installed. This occured with every version of OS X I have had, even back to 10.2.x, so it precedes the exact same behavior in 10.4.3. I might be slow, but banging my head against this wall for a couple of years is enough to make me give up on it. Question is- which printers do people currently have that work with the AEBS USB printing port. I will keep the Canon in direct USB to computer hookup, for pictures, but would like to get a text inkjet for all else. Suggestions for text inkjet that actually works?
Thanks, Jonathan - 0
Henry B. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The printers from Epson and HP on the list found at
http://www.efelix.co.uk/tech/1013.html will generally work without difficulty. The big advantage of Epson and HP printers is that excellent third-party driver support (for the OS X CUPS printing system) is available, so worse-case scenario one can get an Epson or HP printer to work - and work well - using these alternative drivers.I will add that there is third-party printer driver support for many Canon printer models available from
http://www.printfab.net/ . These drivers (unlike the ones provided by Canon) do support network printing, which includes printing via the Airport Express/Extreme Base Station. Unfortunately, the drivers available from PrintFab are not free. - 0
um ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
fwiw...
when the airport extreme base station first came out i bought one, but printing large high-quality images (i.e.
lots of data) would fail or go veeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrryyyyyyy slowly after the first inch or so was printed, this was with a canon s9000at lower quality settings or at smaller media sizes there was no major problem, others on the forum reported the same
apple support didn't have a clue, apple engineering weren't much better, eventually i found the problem and told apple in detail what it was, but they wouldn't say when they'd fix it, so the aebs went back for a full refund
recently i bought an airport express, as far as i can tell the problem
still has not been fixed even though years have passed, it will still stall on large high-quality printsto cut a long story short, this was an
apple problem...as soon as the volume of print data passed some threshold the tcp session for print data from the mac to the airport would start getting large numbers of retransmits and retransmit timeouts, and printing would stall, the aebs lights would also display patterns not listed in apple's documentation so it clearly was in distress
this appeared to be due to apple not implementing proper flow control on the protocol it uses to stream print data to the airport, at a guess the unit runs out of space to buffer data to the slower usb port and at that point starts just dumping data and loses track of things
the streaming protocol between the mac and the airport is apple's, the printer manufacturer has no control over the airport unit, it is running apple's software, so surely only apple can fix this
you can see the tcp retransmits and timeouts using...
netstat -s -p tcp
check the numbers before trying to print, print a job that stalls and see if the number goes up fast (normally you should expect only a few retransmits or retransmit timeouts)
- 0
Simon Abrams ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
While I don't know much about retransmits and retransmit timeouts, this would seem to make sense, as I usually have no problem printing fairly simple text documents (directions from mapquest, emails, etc.). It's when I go to print out a photo at a moderately high resolution that it craps out - and as a result, I waste yet another sheet of photo paper.
- 0
ddt460 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Just upgraded to Tiger, guess I should have been reading these posts before. It's depressing. The thing is, I've been having trouble all along with trying to print through the AEBS on my i960 with Panther. With Panther, the printer would hang only when big data jobs were being printed and then, only sometimes. I was getting along. I don't know why, but I just assumed that upgrading to Tiger and subsequently being able to upgrade the AEBS firmware to the latest version would improve the problem.
Now, I cannot print anything, nada, zip. Not even simple text only docs. Not on AEBS and not even with the i960 plugged directly into the USB of the computer. I've tried the usual fixes, reinstalling the printer driver, resetting the base station. Restarting the printer, etc...
The funny thing, is that this total printing shut down only occurred on my FP iMac after installing Tiger. With my PB that is still on Panther, I can still print wirelessly (simple jobs only) but it hangs at the end of the job and I have to delete the print job to get the print to complete.
I came to this great forum, in hopes of finding the answer, maybe it is still out there, but I'm increasingly pessimistic. - 0
ddt460 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Well, I seem to have fixed my problems, although, I'm not certain how.
One thing that solved the problem of not being able to print from the hardwired USP port was reinstalling the Canon driver from the disk. The older version of the driver seems to work when the version downloaded from Canon's website was buggy.
I'm not so sure how I got the printer to work via AEBS. First I reset the base station. (from Airport Admin Utility). I also opened Printer setup Utility and deleted and re added the printer from the Printer List. This of course was after reinstalling the older version of the driver. In the course of re-adding the printer, I clicked around various options, and this is where I'm not sure which step was crucial. But the utility searches for new drivers, and on the advice read on other posts some how selected Canon BJ Network as the driver. After that, it worked. But I did delete and rechoose every reference to a printer driver that I could find in Printer Setup Utility.