Benches / Printing and scanning
Image resolution of inserted image
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm creating a PDF e-book for a friend:
I scan an image (line art) as a 200dpi greyscale jpg in photoshop. Looks sharp on screen and when printed. I scale down the image from 100% to the size I'll need it in Pages (3" wide). Move over into Pages and insert>choose> and select my image. Once imported, the image is huge! So I go back to photoshop and scale it down way more. Now when I re-import the image into Pages, its the correct size but appears fuzzy. If I print the image from Pages....it's fuzzy. If I print that same image from photoshop it's tiny. How do I reconcile this?
11 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Jon Walker ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Now when I re-import the image into Pages, its the correct size but appears fuzzy. If I print the image from Pages....it's fuzzy. If I print that same image from photoshop it's tiny. How do I reconcile this?
I fail to fully understand your problem. Pages retains/stores imported images at their full resolution until or unless the user applies the "Reduce File Size" option. When "scaling" the original image to make it smaller, you are merely reducing the display dimensions -- not the resolution of the stored file. Thus, you are actually increasing the apparent image resolution as defined by the number of dots per inch in the stored image as divided by the decreasing size of the display/printed image. On the other hand, if you reduce the resolution of the image before importing/use it to pages, you have, in fact, reduced the actual resolution of the image stored/available for display/printing by Pages.
- 0
mohawkhigh ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Let's say the image is 4" wide in photoshop @ 200dpi. The intended width of the image in the Pages document is 2". I reduce the image in photoshop to 2">save.......then go over to Pages and insert (what should be a 2" wide) graphic. The image is way too big. So I go back to photoshop and reduce it down to 1" or smaller....so that when I take it into Pages THIS time....It will be closer to the (2") size I'm looking for it to be......But think about it....if I take that down to 1/4"---yes there are more dots per inch, but the image is so darn small, it won't actually be "clear" if then (in Pages) it's blown up twice....it will appear fuzzy(ish). Why is this happening?
Thanks
- 0
KOENIG Yvan ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
It's really simple.
If you reduce the size out of Pages, the file size will be smaller but you will be unable to recover the revoved pixels.
If you insert the HiRez file, the document will be huge but if you zoom on a picture resized in Pages to 1/4", you will see the original pixels.In some documents, the first choice is the good one, in some others, the best one is the second.
It's matter of choice.Yvan KOENIG (VALLAURIS, France) jeudi 11 mars 2010 16:48:16
- 0
mohawkhigh ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm sorry but that doesn't answer my question (I'm not being rude). If it's 4" ouside Pages (in PhotoShop)......why wouldn't it still be 4" when inserted into Pages. The other guy who responded seemed to indicate that there should be no change(?).
- 0
KOENIG Yvan ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I didn't wrote the opposite.
Pages doesn't grab the resolution from your original file, it treats it as a 72 dpis one.
The pict will be huge so you will have to tell the app to display the picture with a given size.
The Inspector of measures is available for such a task.Yvan KOENIG (VALLAURIS, France) jeudi 11 mars 2010 17:08:52
- 0
Jon Walker ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm sorry but that doesn't answer my question (I'm not being rude). If it's 4" ouside Pages (in PhotoShop)......why wouldn't it still be 4" when inserted into Pages.
You are dealing with two separate issues here.
Your original question asked about the change in display/print clarity when a file imported to pages at two different resolutions. In the first case you have an 4" image at 200 dpi (or lines). This means the image contains 800 dots in the dimension being measured. When this image is imported to Pages, it still has 800 dots in the indicated dimensions and will have a 200 dpi resolution when displayed as a 4" image (i.e. 800 dots / 4" = 200 d/") On the other hand, if you display the same image at 2" in Pages, then the resolution becomes 800 dots / 2" = 400 d/" resolution available for display or printing. However, the apparent quality of any such representation will depend on the monitor display or print resolution used to render the image. (I.e., you can modify the viewing/printing scale of a Pages page, as well as, the size of the image within a Pages page which affects both the relative size of the page as well as its apparent quality.
In the second rendering of your question, you asked why the PS and Pages images display at different sizes. One of the main differences between the two applications is that PS displays the image at dimensions relative to the "display" dimensions which are embedded in the image while Pages displays the same image relative to the viewing scale selected by the user which is relative the fixed resolution of your monitor and/or print resolution. (I.e., if you want the small, 1" PS view of your image to "appear" the same size as your Pages version of the same image, then reduce the resolution reference embedded in the PS file (which PS uses for display but Pages does not use) to match the current resolution of your monitor. That is, both applications must be using the same reference resolution for their display.
One last point here. If you are creating an eBook here then disregard both applications when it comes to scaling and resolution settings. Simply target your project for the size and resolution of the target eBook reading device. For example, if creating a file for an 800x600 @200 dpi device use a page size on the order of 4" x 3" (less any area not dedicated for reading display) or on the order of 4.8" x 3.6" for an 800x600 device at 166.67 dpi device, use these dimensions for your target page dimensions in Pages, and use an image that provides your best estimate of quality on the device in terms of KBs required for the saved PDF file. In this manner you should end up with an eBook that matches your project file in terms of page content.
- 0
Kelly Coull ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
If I understand you and Yvan correctly, the imported picture will be placed at 72 dpi. Your picture is 200 dpi. Therefore, you don't only have to reduce the size of the image, but also the dpi of the image. In photoshop, select the crop tool and define the size you want the picture to be, but also that you want the resolution to be 72 dpi.
Of course the easiest option is to import the original image into Pages, use the inspector to resize to the size you want and then reduce the file size.
- 0
mohawkhigh ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Don't know if this matters or not...but when I say e-book....I'm just referring to a manual / or how to type of book that you pay for and download....not a narrative or chapter book to be read on a iPad or "krindle" device. It would most likely be downloaded in pdf format and viewed on a computer monitor.
- 0
mohawkhigh ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thanks to everyone for your help/posts. I appreciate it. I'll have to go back through now and re-read...a couple responses were great, but a little hard to get on the first read. I knew or figured it had to do with the default dpi of Pages, but I thought I'd read about it somewhere in the documentation, but I didn't see anything.
Thanks again.
- 0
Jon Walker ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Don't know if this matters or not...but when I say e-book....I'm just referring to a manual / or how to type of book that you pay for and download....not a narrative or chapter book to be read on a iPad or "krindle" device.
It matters only to the extent you allow/want it to matter. If producing a manual you expect to be downloaded and later printed in hardcopy by the user, then a standard page may prove best. If you are creating a manual to be referred to on the screen while the software and/or process it explains is also active on the screen, then you may wish to consider a small size page for your manual.
In my case I am creating custom PDF files for my own personal use on various eReaders (currently three and will be ordering may 4th tomorrow). There are literally thousands of books, novelettes, short stories, and other works covering everything from science fiction to philosophy covering nearly 2,000 years of recorded human history. Most are works I would never buy if I had to pay for them but would gladly spend a decade converting for inclusion in my personal library. Many include illustrations which are often left out by others creating files for public distribution in various formats. Thus, I am making my own. For what it's worth...
- 0
KOENIG Yvan ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The picture is inserted at 72 dpi if it fits in the page.
If it's too large, it's displayed with a higher res.
Just an example:
I took a screenshot of my desktop (cmd 3).
The file is a 1920 x 1200 pixels one.
When I drag & drop it in Pages, I get a picture whose dimensions are : 448 x 280 pixels which means a 308 dpi rezolution.
If I click the button "original size" in the Inspector > measures, I get the 1920 x 1200 pixels objects which doesn't fit in the page.If the document is designed for a screen_only use, It would be interesting to down_sample it to 72 dpi (448 x 280 pixels) before inserting so, we would see the same thing than with the large file but the document will be less big.
If the document may be used for printing, it would be a good idea to keep it as a 1920 x 1200 pixels one.
When printing, if the machine is able to work at 300 dpi, it will use every available pixels giving a better result than the one obtained with the 448 x 280 pixels.
This is why I wrote that we have to make choice : arbitrate between quality and document size.Yvan KOENIG (VALLAURIS, France) jeudi 11 mars 2010 21:11:58
