Benches Peripherals and accessories

15

Journaled or not journaled

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I've seen conflicting tips on whether or not to select "Journaled" when creating a new partition. Is it set differently for system drives vs. external drives?

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Allan Eckert

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi David;

    Since journaling is designed to protect you in case of any problems by helping the system to recover data that might get lost because of an unexpected shutdown I turn it on for everything. Why not? It does not seem to take a noticable amount of CPU cycles.

    Allan

  2. 0

    Kevin-WinXP-Free

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have been told that it's a good idea to turn off journalling on your video capture drive. I would turn it on for all other drives. You should probably also turn off Spotlight for your video capture drives as well.

  3. 0

    David S.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    non journaled for media drives.

    also, do not use firewire drives as media drives

  4. 0

    Jeff--

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    just out of curiosity, why do you recommend not using a firewire drive as a media drive?

  5. 0

    David S.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    there is only ONE FIREWIRE BUS on all shipping Macs.

    That means it shares the bandwidth i/o with the hard drives and the deck. There are huge issues of blown firewire buses and ports.

    Dropped frames, etc.

    Don't do it.

    Plus, FW drives have never been certified with any version of FCP

  6. 0

    Jeff Hubbach

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    David,

    You can turn journaling on and off on an already-partitioned drive without having to format and repartition it. This will give you the ability to do your own comparative analysis and figure out whether it makes a difference in your particular setup. I have noticed no difference, whether journaling is on or off.

    Here's how to do it (these instructions apply to OS X 10.4 Tiger, tested on Disk Utility 10.5.3)

    To Disable Journaling:

    Open Disk Utility

    select the partition you want to disable journaling on.

    hold down Control and Option and open the File menu

    select "Disable Journaling"

    To Enable Journaling:

    Open Disk Utility

    select the partition you want to enable journaling on.

    click the "Enable Journaling" button in the toolbar.

  7. 0

    Maxx Power

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have used anywhere from 2-12 drives daisy-chained out of the rear port with my camera to my front port for a year and a half now with NO issues. No PCI cards or anything like that. I know they run off of the same bus but I am just saying I haven't had any problems running FW drives and a deck off of the same bus. I don't have problems capturing. I capture at least a couple of hours per week. I don't have dropped frames . Just my 2 cents.

  8. 0

    David S.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Glad it's working for you.

    Hope it continues to.

    But an anecdotal report flies in the face of what I see each day, and what Apple indicates -- they aren't certified for use with FCP.

    There's a reason

  9. 0

    Allan Eckert

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Jeff;

    That is exactly what I have done. Since I didn't notice any difference in performance, I decided allowing the system to journal my disk to possibly prevent corruption was a good thing.

    Allan

  10. 0

    Brian Conner

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    That's a good point, Jeff, one that I've made a number of times here.

    However, looking at what journaling does, it isn't useful for a media volume anyway. Even if the media file that was in process at the time of the power failure could be "saved", it would be a partial QT file that would be unusable. So, IMO, it's a moot point. And I say that as someone who's been vocally in favor of journaling for all volumes.

  11. 0

    hanumang

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    But an anecdotal report flies in the face of what I see each day, and what Apple indicates -- they aren't certified for use with FCP.

    There's a reason

    No need to be
    that smug.

    Apple actually incorporates FireWire drives in it's documentation when it advises on suitable hardware (
    Final Cut Pro: What Kind of Hard Drive Should I Buy?).

    Also, the recently released Apple Pro Training Series:
    Optimizing Your Final Cut Pro System book actually details working with FireWire drives (and with many FW devices on a single bus) and it does not discourage FireWire drives for media (like it does with USB 2.0 drives).

    And considering the book is meant for Apple Pro Certification, your statement that FireWire drives are discouraged - and not certified - is a dubious one.

    Any links you'd care to share to support your statement?

  12. 0

    David S.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'm not being smug; I'm reporting my and other's experiences here and as a moderator for three years at 2-pop.com. Ask Kevin "Telly" Monahan, the San Francisco founder of the Final Cut Pro Users Group, or Michael Horton, the founder of the LAFCPUG about their view of firewire drives, particularly in post FCP 4.x systems.

    If you read the portion on firewire drives you refer to, it's hardly an endorsement for their use. In fact, it is full of caveats and warnings.

    for example:

    Important: Meeting these requirements does not guarantee the effectiveness or reliability of the drive. If a FireWire hard drive causes dropped frames during playback or recording, try moving the media to an Ultra ATA or SCSI drive.

    I've worked with the pro apps team for years at Apple.

    The company does not recommend firewire drives, nor does it certify them.

    People still use them and some successfully. They are referenced in the book you cited because in order to be certified you have be able to troubleshoot a variety of configurations.

    I've never heard of a blown ATA or SATA bus or channel. I hear of blown or fried Firewire buses every week.

    I strongly recommend not to use firewire drives on a production FCP station.

    You can do what you wish.

    If you must use firewire drives, follow Apple's recommendations as set forth in the referenced noted above, and purchase a PCI firewire card to create a second bus.

    Many people mistake firewire ports with the single firewire bus supplied on all shipping Macs. With separate buses, you increase the reliability of firewire hard drive editing by using one bus for camera/deck and the other for hard drives.

    If this sounds smug, I apologize.

    Don't shoot the messenger.

  13. 0

    Maxx Power

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Whatever bro- I guess a lot of people here on the forum are just lucky like me. And what you are saying flies in the face of what I see here everyday where many, many pro level users recommend FW drives for media storage. Whatever works I guess...

  14. 0

    Brian Conner

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Maxx,

    I recommend firewire drives . . . . . for archiving. Unless circumstances dictate that you must use FW drives for serving media files for an NLE, my opinion is that I won't recommend it.

    That's not to say it doesn't work. There are many users it works very nicely for. You are one of those.

  15. 0

    hanumang

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    If you read the portion on firewire drives you refer to, it's hardly an endorsement for their use.

    While there are caveats to be sure, it does say that FireWire drives are suitable for "low data rate clips such as DV."

    Considering that the vast majority of users who use FW drives - as media drives -
    are doing work in DV, I must disagree with your view ("Do not use firewire drives for media").