Benches Networking

4

AT&T PPPoE DSL: no simultaneous Airport Exp...

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I've got an old Quicksilver PPC mac which I use for book-keeping, websurfing and email, and an Airport that I can't get to connect to the internet at the same time using AT&T PPPoE DSL over a Speedstream 5100 DSL modem (everything is connected through a Netgear gigabit switch). I've updated the Airport utility and the airport firmware, and followed all the tech descriptions I could find online, including following the PPPeO configuration guidleine Apple posted on the web where you disconnect the Airport, configure the Macintiosh, then connect the Airpot alone to the DSL modem after cycling power on both units. I also saw the note about making sure that the PPP on the mac is not set to "Connect Automatically", but the only way I could get them both to work at once was a very obscure method I thought of by sharing the internet connection of the mac, and manually setting the IP address on the ethernet of the Macintosh, and the Airport to match the domain and router information for the AT&T PPPoE connection, and of course with this setup, the Airport only works when the Macintosh is on, and connected to the internet, but I want to be able to turn off the Macintosh, and still use the Airport for my iphone while the Mac is off. The whole situation has some consistent failures in the Airport setup utility, and these are them. The first issue is that I need to first do a hard reset of the Airport for it to be seen at all by the utility after I have configured the Airport for PPPoE. The second issue is that I can successfully configure the Airport to work by first making sure that my AT&T connection on the Mac is disconnected first in the Network setting. Setup of the Airport will then go along fine, it will then reboot, and the network utility will then give me the message that it has successfully updated the settings on my Airport, but it can no longer see it on the network, and that I should try restarting the utility app, and try to "see" it then. This invariably fails, but long before that happens, the light on my Airport is green, and I can surf away using the Airport with my iphone, so that fact that the Airport utility application can't see the Airport would not be a problem, if all I wanted to do was use the Airport as my internet connection. But when I return to my Macintosh, and if I attempt to connect to internet on that machine, of course by using the PPPoE setup by hitting the "Connect" button in the Network panel (which I had previously turned off to configure the Airport, because if I leave it on, and try to configure the Airport, the Airport fails to connect to the internet) which previously worked fine before I connected and set up the Airport, I now get an error message "Internet Connect - No PPPoE server has been found for the specified service. Please delete the service name option and try again." But if I disconnect the Airport from the network, or turn it off, I can connect again fine on Macintosh again, without rebooting the modem.
So they both cannot seem to connect to the modem over ethernet at the same time. AT&T tech support says I should have no problem connecting multiple computers to the connection via my ethernet switch, but I am yet to try that, as my only other machine here at the moment is a windows machine with a broken network card. They say I should ask Apple what the problem is, although I am not totally convinced the problem is actually Apple's alone, and that somehow AT&T's new security settings in its PPPoE setup has something to do with my problems....

4 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hello Donald_Grahame. Welcome to the Apple Discussions!

    I've got an old Quicksilver PPC mac which I use for book-keeping, websurfing and email, and an Airport that I can't get to connect to the internet at the same time using AT&T PPPoE DSL over a Speedstream 5100 DSL modem (everything is connected through a Netgear gigabit switch).

    Please bear with me, as I just want to be sure I understand your network configuration.

    If I understand you correctly, you have the Speedstream 5100 directly connected to the DSL source. In turn, you have the Speedstream directly connected to a Netgear Ethernet switch. Finally, you have the AirPort Express Base Station (AX) directly connected to one of the available Ethernet ports on the switch ... correct?

    How is your G4 Power Mac connected? To the switch via an Ethernet cable or to the AX by wireless?

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The DSL modem is connected to the Netgear ethernet switch. With an ethernet cable. The computer and the Airport are also connected to the switch. With ethernet cables.

    The Mac does not have a wireless card, and Powermac do not have wireless built in.

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The DSL modem is connected to the Netgear ethernet switch. With an ethernet cable. The computer and the Airport are also connected to the switch. With ethernet cables.

    Thank your for clarifying your network configuration. The problem with this configuration is that you cannot use an Ethernet switch to "split" the modem's Internet connection with multiple devices on the local network. Instead, you need to use a router. With your current configuration, the modem will become "confused" as to which device is connected to it. In addition, only the device directly connected to the Internet will need to be configured for PPPoE.

    To resolve your problem you will need to replace the Ethernet switch with a wired Internet router. The DSL modem would then connect directly to the WAN-side of this router and the network clients, including the AX, would be connected to the LAN-side of this same router.

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for the reply, which means the AT&T support people were wrong when they told me multiple computers could be connected to their connection through my switch, they obviously meant a router. Since my setup clearly does not work, you are more likely right!