Airtunes Sound Quality with Lossless music
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I have all my music in iTunes ripped from CDs with Apple Lossless Encoder. When I play via Airtunes on my HiFi (Fibre Optic cable to an Onkyo AV receiver) although the quality of the sound is very good you can hear a noticeable difference between the iTunes files and the original CD. I know music is transmitted as lossless to the Airport Express but the sound doesn't seem to have the same quality as the original CDs. I'm thinking about ripping in AIFF although that will mean HUGE files!
Any suggestions would be very much appreciated.
8 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Tesserax ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Switching to AIFF format may not buy you much ...
For the AX, the audio is handled by a Texas Instruments PCM2705 digital-to-analog converter which it outputs on a 3.5mm stereo minijack. However, the innermost end of the 3.5mm jack is an optical S/PDIF transmitter.
The AX works only with iTunes v4.6+ and is limited to music files that iTunes can read; ie, 16-bit data only. (An exception is you can use a third-party product like Rogue Amoeba's AirFoil to stream other non-iTunes sources.) These data, though, can be in any file format that iTunes recognizes, from lossy MP3s at the low-quality end of the spectrum to Apple Lossless and lossless AIFF or WAV files at the high end, as you are suggesting. However, it is also important to note that the AX functions only at a 44.1kHz sample rate. Regardless of when you play 32kHz or 48kHz source data, iTunes sample-rate-converts the data in real time before sending it to the AX.
iTunes uses a QuickTime CODEC to convert audio files to Apple Lossless, and then, uses AirTunes to send them to the AX. In turn, the AX uses built-in software that converts the Apple Lossless to an Encoded Digital Audio format. From there, digital audio is sent to a optical transceiver to convert the electrical signal to an optical one before sending it to the innermost part of the audio port. For analog, the AX has a built-in DAC to convert the Encoded Digital Audio to Analog which is sent to the same audio port.
- 0
'T. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thanks for the very informative response.
All my music is encoded in iTunes with Apple Lossless and as I mentioned the connection from the AE to my amp is via an optical cable as I know an analog connection results in pretty cr*ppy sound quality.
The problem I'm having is that even with this I still don't get quite the same quality as playing music directly from the CD so I was wondering if encoding in AIFF would make any difference or will the fact that I'm doing this wirelessly always result in some reduction in quality? Also, would Airtunes over ethernet be of any help. I'd rather not do that as wireless is so much more flexible.
Thanks for any help.
- 0
Tesserax ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The problem I'm having is that even with this I still don't get quite the same quality as playing music directly from the CD so I was wondering if encoding in AIFF would make any difference or will the fact that I'm doing this wirelessly always result in some reduction in quality?
Well, it's certainly worth a try and I would be interested in the results. I suggest that you pick a particular song with subtle tonal qualities, like the sound of a hand sliding on the neck of a guitar. Create an Apple Lossless and an AIFF copy, and then, play them through iTunes to your AX.
I'm venturing to say that since iTunes will convert the AIFF source to Apple Lossless before sending it to the AX, the end result will be a "slight degradation" of the sound instead of improving it.
Also, would Airtunes over ethernet be of any help.
It might, but it will really depend on your current wireless bandwidth. For comparison, a 1 Gbps Ethernet should out-perform 802.11n running at 5 GHz (300 Mbps). However, 100 Mbps Ethernet would also perform better than 802.11g (54 Mbps).
- 0
'T. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
It took a while but I finally got round to ripping some music in AIFF. The results were absolutely brilliant. You can really hear the full range of tones whereas when they were ripped in Apple Lossless the music was still sounding rather compressed. AIFF sounded pretty much like listening to the CD. This was done over the AX so I didn't bother with Airtunes over ethernet. I know iTunes converts to Apple lossless before sending to the AX so it's rather strange that ripping in Apple lossless sounded noticeably worse than the original CD where AIFF doesn't.
This poses a bit of a problem for me as I have about 800 mostly jazz CDs to rip! I think I might be investing another external HDD just for my music as each CD is working out at roughly 500MB in size.
- 0
Jase the C ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
This is a very surprising result. I don't doubt the difference you're hearing, but I wonder if the problem may have been somewhere else in the chain (I don't have any clues, though). I've always used Apple Lossless and have compared it to AIFF without being able to direct any difference. This includes when sending the AX's digital signal (using optical, like you) through a high quality, standalone DAC for conversion into analog. Lossless compression methods are supposed to be truly lossless, and when John Atkinson of Stereophile magazine conducted lab tests, he found that the bit stream resulting from decompressing an Apple Lossless file was bit-for-bit identical to the original signal.
I mention this because you have a lot of work ahead of you, and obviously the difference in terms of hard disk size and cost is significant. You may want to play around a bit and do some additional comparisons of AL and AIFF based on fresh rips and see if the issue is reliably reproduced. Just a suggestion.
- 0
Tesserax ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thanks for the time and trouble to post back your results. I don't have quite as many jazz CDs (around 400), but you gave me something to think about (& try). Hopefully old age/hearing loss won't kick-in before I get a chance to enjoy the differences. 😉
- 0
'T. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I am rather surprised myself about the results having been lead to believe that Apple Lossless really was indistinguishable from an original CD. I could hear a difference between the two so I got my "better half" to listen without telling her the music was coming from iTunes. Her first reaction was "Is there something wrong with the amp or the CD player?".
I'll keep playing around but I'm quite happy to rip with AIFF as it provides a true backup of my collection. One never knows when an "act of God" might come calling. This way I just have to grab the HDD and run! After grabbing the family, of course!!!
- 0
mattcain ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi - I guess you already know this - but you don't have to re-rip cds. Itunes can convert quite happily between apple lossless and aiff. The conversion is not lossy. Additionally - if you're uncertain - there are a couple of freebie tools that will perform a bitstream check between files. If you compare a wav rip to an aiff rip to an apple lossless rip - they're all the same.
The only loss is a bigger harddrive to hold the aac->aiff conversions...
- Matt