X won't close applications
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi All -
Got a brand new MacBook Pro here. I have been playing with the new stuff and navigating my way around. However, found a quirk that I am not happy about. When I am working with a few windows up, the red X will not close the window. I have an iMac and a PowerBook - and I have never had this problem on either of those computers. Only the new one.
I will click on the red X (with a wireless mouse) - I can click, click, click all I want. It won't close. I have used the mouse pad as well. Same issue.
I just checked and I'm all up to date. Anyone else having this problem? Anyone know why this is happening?
12 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Barney-15E ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I haven't heard of that one.
All apps, or just some?
Have you tried creating/logging into another user account and seeing if it still happens? That can help differentiate between system level and user level problems. Although, I wouldn't think something like that would be controlled with user settings. - 0
Erin Basten ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I wouldn't think it would be user specific either.
I forgot to add that this does not always happen - but it happens enough that I think there it's weird. It's also not just system windows but applications and documents, too. So it doesn't seem to be just one kind of X.
What I use most is the browser. So I will sometimes go to close the page and it won't close - so I will have to ignore it for a while and go into a different application.
Also - I should note, that when I come back to these "problem windows" they do close. Just, not right away - like they should.
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I wouldn't think it would be user specific either.
Do you just think that, or do you
know? If you're asking for help, don't immediately discount the suggestions an expert gives you. Testing another user account tells you whether the problem is in your user account (eg, a corrupt settings file) or is a system-wide problem. Possible fixes will depend on which of these it is. - 0
James Kincell ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I have just come onto the apple support for the exact same thing!!
Same as you, unibody macbook pro.
I usualy tap to click, but then I try a proper click, and then wireless mouse, doesnt do anything.
Very annoying!Really hoping that someone can help!
Thanks
- 0
Erin Basten ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Phew - Hi James. Good to hear it's not just me!
- 0
digi_art ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Is this a wireless issue ? I am running a Mac Pro with a wired mouse and do not have this problem . Does Command+Q exit the program successfully ?
- 0
James Kincell ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yes command-Q does quit the app, but the problem is I dont always want to quit it, sometimes just want to close that window - eg Mail.
This shouldnt happen though, its not normal. Hoping an update will address this.
Not sure if its a wireless problem, but pretty certain it isnt faulty trackpad. I've just had my trackpad replaced as the tactile click went funny. Still doing this problem unfortunatly, so it must be a OS issue.
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yes command-Q does quit the app, but the problem is I dont always want to quit it, sometimes just want to close that window - eg Mail.
What about command-W... does that work when a click won't? Also, did you try Barney's suggestion of testing on a brand new user?
Hoping an update will address this.
It won't, most likely, as I can count all the people I've heard mention this on one hand. It's not a bug, it's a problem with your specific system... the trick is figuring out what part. Regardless, I'd recommend against installing any updates while you're having problems. Updating a system that has problems tends to make things worse, assuming the problems aren't bugs addressed by the update.
- 0
digi_art ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yes , I forgot about Command+W Thomas ! This certainly does close a window that is open . If a solution cannot be found (and an update won't rectify this as Thomas has posted) then this is a viable alternate solution ...
- 0
Hail2theKingBaby ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm having exactly the same problem. It doesn't happen often but when it does I find that if you click on the top of the window in question and drag it then click the X it closes.
Although the effect of the problem is very minor, especially if you can close the window after dragging it a little like I can, but it's a problem that shouldn't be there.
And yes I'm on a 6 month old Macbook Pro unibody. I'm using the mid-2009 15" version with the single bottom panel and user non-removeable battery.
I'm also suffering from the intermittent touchpad mouse click problem many people have experienced.
As the problem with the red X button is so infrequent it's difficult to test using another user account as has been suggested. As sometimes I can use the laptop for a session and not experience the problem. Other times it can occur many times. Setting up a new account to test it is only viable if you were to us that new account for all your computing needs instead of your actual account.
I'm wondering if this problem is related to software currently installed on the machine and running in the statusbar. I recently did a full format to try and fix this and some other problems and I didn't see the problem occur again until I copied my documents and application settings across. I currently have the following software open all the time in my statusbar, so if anyone else has this software installed and have the same problem we could be onto something.
Simplyfy Media Server
Caffeine
Logmein
Evernote
Time Machine
Bluetooth (enabed)
Connected to WifiI'd be very interested to see if any fellow suffers are running the same software as me. To repeat... I did not notice the problem after a full format and install until I started to load software and settings back in. I did not reinstate previous OS settings, only library settings for 3rd party software.
I too am up to date and this problem only occurred in the past few months.
- 0
Erin Basten ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I was just going to come on and post that I found the workaround (dragging the window over just a bit and then trying the X again). But looks like KingBaby beat me to it quite a while ago!
- 0
Roger D ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The same thing happens on a brand new Mac mini with no additional software added.
Just bought one for my mom 2 days ago, and ran all updates. Tried to train mom on it and she became extremely confused, since I told her to click the RED X to close any window.
About every 10 minutes she would get a window that you could click all day long on the X and nothing happens. Move the mouse away from the window, and then back, and the X works fine. You don't have to drag the window or anything, just move the pointer off of the window and then back on.
So she said, "WHO SAID MACS WERE EASY???"
How do you get somebody to start using a mac when something as simple as closing a window doesn't work?
-
Why is it such a horrible experience? Seems that the worst experience occurs on a window that doesn't have focus. As you slide your mouse over the X, it changes from grey to bright red, indicating that you can do something, except that you can't. You can click forever, but you must get off of the entire control before the control will react to a mouse click again.
As we've added software, the problem continues to occur on the new software too.
There have been times where it occurs on a window that has focus (and the X is red before hovering over it), but the few times I could catch it, it seems as though those were windows that received focus because the program spawned them (such as a Skype window or Mail's preference window).
Note: new Mac mini with a $49 mac WIRED mouse with scroll ball (A1152) and Snow Leopard.