Benches macOS

15

mail change address book!

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

hello, excuse me for my BAD english...

I have big problem with my address book:

i have a imac 27" and macbook air with snow leopard and 1 iphone 3gs.

i have, also mobile me and I sync with mobile me address book, calendar and more...!

It is very very good for me BUT I have a problem.

Sometimes some contact CHANGE name!

I have do many tests and I have see THAT IT'S MAIL program that CHANGE some contact name when I send an e-mail at this contact!!

for example: I have 200 contact. 5 of this have an e-mail. the other only number...

I send an e-mail with Mail program from my imac to one of this contact...for example John Mcdonald...

immediatly MAIL change the name of John Mcdonald in my address book. (and mobileme change the name on my iphone and on my macbook air...!) the name often change to John mc donald john mcdonald (repeat two times...) or john john mcdonald...or, for other contact change to CAPITAL (JOHN MCDONALD).

so, in my test on this BUG I have connected this problem to adressees precedence on MAIl program...If I empty this "adressees precedence" I don't have the problem...but I need to empty every day...2-3 times a day...!

I hope You can help me...!

I hope apple can resolve this BUG: WHY MAIL program CAN modify MY ADDRESS BOOK??! MY ADDRESS BOOK is MINE!

do you have this problem?

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Golden Shoes

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    This is not a bug; it is perfectly normal behavior and it's always been this way. If you have a contact in Address Book that doesn't have the correct First and Last name, when you send email to an address that does have that information, Mail will change Address Book to match it.

  2. 0

    mancio83

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    what? what means CORRECT?? the address book doesn't have the CORRECT first and last name?

    in my address ALL contact have first and last name.

    BUT mail modify the first and last name with the name who the person have set up in his account!

    IF a person set up "JOHN MCDONALD" but in my address I DECIDE TO WRITE "doctor john" WHY MAIL MODIFY?? i am the owner...I am the uman! I DECIDE.

    so this is a Bug...

  3. 0

    Golden Shoes

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The correct name is the given name of the individual, not whatever you choose to put in there. Yes, Mail does modify this information with that which the individual setup in their mail account.

    Sorry, you're not the decider of this, Mail and the email address of the sender are what determine when and how this information changes. As I said before, this is not a bug, and it's not going to change, so you need to conform to the proper method of adding contacts to your Address Book.

  4. 0

    mancio83

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    ahahahhaha... LOL...

    you are very funny!!

    but I hope you are joking....!

    because it's unacceptable that I can't control my address book!

    and if my girlfriend name Michelle Simpson and I want name in my address book "LOVE" or "my love"?? it's impossible for a MAC computer??

    if it's as you support MICROSOFT is better of apple...!

    and I know it's impossible...!

    it's a bug. sure.

    And I need a resolution...

    😟

  5. 0

    jokey77

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    hello, mancio83, golden shoes (in italy we would say "scarpe d'oro")...!!!

    I completely subscribe mancio83's position!!!

    do you really believe, what I'm going to explain below, isn't a bug???

    this is what happens:

    I add a business contact called "Incisioni Morlacchi"; first name: blank; last name: blank; this because this company does not have just one reference person...but it needs many contacts (direct phones, mobile phones, e-mails, etc...)

    well!!!...the mail/address book conspiracy decides to add as first name "Giovanni" and as last name "Incisioni Morlacchi snc"???

    I believe this is - at least - a big limit!!!

    could you help me???

    thank you so much.

    ps. not least, my important client, here called "incisioni morlacchi" for make an example, said me (annoyed) that his company's not managed by mr. "Giovanni"!!!

  6. 0

    Mirmidon

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hello, I completely agree with mancio83: it is not normal that Apple decides what I can put in MY address book and manage it for me (I consider that it is not very "democratic"). It should be at least an option to enable or disable this possibility - I don't think that it is so difficult to do. I am sometimes very tired that Apple wants to control my life as they want and don't let me do what I want with MY computer!

    By the way, no, it is not a bug, it is a feature! And this is the worth thing of the story (this is a perfect behavior of "Big Brother").

  7. 0

    leo1965

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    For two years i try all the impossible to solve that problem, but it's impossible for me. And i think that it is my problem, and i don't "set" my mac so well.

    But now someone say to me that this is normal !!!! But it is crazy !!!!!

    I prefer to think that it is my problem, because i can believe that i can't decide how i can "nominate" my contact. I can't believe it.

    I hope that there is another solution, i want to believe that it is a bug and can be solved.

    But only in Italy we have this problem ?

  8. 0

    mancio83

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    hello guy! yes it's strange...So I'm not the only one with this problem...!

    I think many person think this is personal problem of his pc but I know it's a bug...I have 2 imac now and in the past other 3 mac...! all with the same problem.

    it's a BUG in the MAIL or address book program correlated to "Previous Recipients"...(in italian: destinatari precedenti)

    if I empty every time my "Previous Recipients" (destinatari precedenti) I don't have a problem.

    try this way and let me know...!

    p.s.

    HOW we can send to APPLE an e-mail with this bug report?

    I think apple can help us in 5 minutes with little modify...address book can be modify only by user. simply!

    Message was edited by: mancio83

  9. 0

    mancio83

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    excuse me for my bad english! in first post I have write: "adressees precedence"...it's incorrect!

    it' "Previous Recipients" the problem! MAIL modify address book with "Previous Recipients" contents...!

  10. 0

    Mirmidon

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    @ mancio83

    "HOW we can send to APPLE an e-mail with this bug report?"

    It is not a bug. It is a feature, something that Apple decided to do (not an error)

    (Non è un bug. È una caratteristica, qualcosa deciso da Apple [non per errore])

    .... Not for this I agree with it....

  11. 0

    jokey77

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    hi golden shoes,

    how do you manage a business contact in order to overide the problems before said related to the union mail/address book?

    have you suggestions with study cases to show me?

    thanks for your help

  12. 0

    Golden Shoes

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    how do you manage a business contact in order to overide the problems before said related to the union mail/address book?

    There is no problem with Mail and Address book regarding this except the fact that the OP is trying to conflate a perfectly normal behavior into something abnormal. This is not a bug, no matter what anyone else may think. It may be inconvenient to the thinking of some people, but it's not a bug.

    Address Book is meant for keeping contact information of individuals, with their given first and last names. It is not for keeping information in any fashion you like. Failing to adhere to the design of the program will yield unexpected or unwanted results. It's not a free-form database, nor was it ever intended to be, so people need to stop trying to use it as such.

    I seem to manage my contacts quite well without problems by simply entering their given names, along with their company name (where applicable) in the Company field, and their email address(es). I've never had a problem yet.

    There is a way to completely disable this behavior, but it would also have the effect of forcing you to completely type the full email address(es) of your recipients each time you send an email.

  13. 0

    mancio83

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    ok, if it's not a bug, there is a possible to prevent and block MAIL program to change address book? maybe by terminal??

    thank's

  14. 0

    Golden Shoes

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yes, but it will have the effect I described before: you have to type in every email address in full, each time you send an email.

  15. 0

    mancio83

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    golden shoes thanks for try to help me, I'm really annoyed by this issue and I apologize if my tone could seems rude it's fault of my poor english.

    so I know that if I turn off "auto completing e-mail address" don't have a problem.

    but I hope there is some command by TERMINAL to prevent modify address book by MAIL...

    😟