Benches macOS

15

Memory leak, Kontakt 3, Omnisphere, RMX, and our friend Logic 8

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hello all,

Haven't been back in a while, hope everyone is doing well.

Firstly, a while back when we made the Intel move and the Logic 8 move, I had heard Logic was "leaking memory". This seems to make sense lately, as sessions are crashing with more frequency. Kontakt 3 gives me memory error messages, then sessions crash.

I am using RMX multis, Omnisphere multis, and Kontakt 3 multis. Am I asking too much? Am I crazy to think that being Mr. 8-core 8 gigs of RAM is supposed to give me MORE power and MORE abilities? Or am I right back where I was with my old dual G5?

I have read not to use Kontakt 3 as a multi. Ok, fine. Anyone else find this?

I have also read using Kontakt 3 as a standalone and routing it in to Logic works better. Anyone do this and have a few minutes to write down how to achieve this?

I have read that EXS works a lot better if you can manage to port your Kontakt samples over to it. Anyone done this with success, and LIKE the sound EXS makes with their Kontakt samples?

We've now been on 8.0.2 for quite a while...are we getting an update EVER?

"Snow Leopard" is going to be 64 bit therefore we will get to use the other half of our RAM we purchased?

So many questions, so many deadlines...

Thanks in advance, and again...hope you are all well!

Mark

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Bee Jay

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Haven't been back in a while, hope everyone is doing well.

    Hey Mark, nice to have you around, hope you're cool...

    Firstly, a while back when we made the Intel move and the Logic 8 move, I had heard Logic was "leaking memory". This seems to make sense lately, as sessions are crashing with more frequency. Kontakt 3 gives me memory error messages, then sessions crash.

    Does this only happen when Kontakt is in the mix? Or does it happen on sessions not using Kontakt? (I know, it's probably a pretty heavily used tool for you...)

    I am using RMX multis, Omnisphere multis, and Kontakt 3 multis. Am I asking too much? Am I crazy to think that being Mr. 8-core 8 gigs of RAM is supposed to give me MORE power and MORE abilities? Or am I right back where I was with my old dual G5?

    I still think that for power users, we are still *not quite there* for a powerful, stable system running large, demanding sessions. Snow Leopard & Logic Next
    promise to get us finally there and fully exploit the power of the hardware, but until then, we have to struggle on by with workarounds in many cases. Annoyingly enough.

    I have read not to use Kontakt 3 as a multi. Ok, fine. Anyone else find this?

    I don't personally have much experience with this - anybody else?

    I have also read using Kontakt 3 as a standalone and routing it in to Logic works better.

    Anyone do this and have a few minutes to write down how to achieve this?

    I've done it, and I find it's generally clunky for a number of reasons which you can guess. Bottom line is you use IAC to route MIDI to it from Logic, and you use a virtual audio cable like Soundflower to route Kontakt's audio back into Logic.

    When you've got some down time, it would be worth trying and and seeing what performance you get on your system, and whether it's a workable setup for you (and gets around the issues you've been having.)

    I have read that EXS works a lot better if you can manage to port your Kontakt samples

    over to it. Anyone done this with success, and LIKE the sound EXS makes with their

    Kontakt samples?

    Well, the EXS is lighter and more efficient of course, but it's also less powerful. Depending on what your Kontakt instruments are doing, conversion could be easy or it could be a nightmare. I probably wouldn't go that route if I could avoid it, or unless I knew my sample collection could be handled easily.

    We've now been on 8.0.2 for quite a while...are we getting an update EVER?

    I'm pretty sure the next version of Logic won't be 8.x, due to the amount of time that's past. Again, it really depends on Snow Leopard. If we get a maintenance/compatibility Logic release for Snow Leopard, without much in the way of new features, then it could be an 8.x, but my guess would be that they probably want to do a good release and get the first DAW running plugins on your graphics card using OpenCL ('bragging rights') so I reckon it would be a 9.0 release.

    Speculation, of course, but...

    "Snow Leopard" is going to be 64 bit therefore we will get to use the other half of our RAM we purchased?

    That's the promise, anyway...

  2. 0

    Mark Isham

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for the reply BJ. Good to see you around here again.

    I guess we'll do what we always do.

    Fingers crossed, hope and pray.

    m

  3. 0

    timkertoy

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Mark Isham wrote:

    I guess we'll do what we always do.

    Fingers crossed, hope and pray.

    m

    Wouldn't it be cool if Logic 8.x or 9 ⚠ included the one feature every other competing DAW (and plugin company for that matter) offers that Apple doesn't: tech support?

    That'd be awesome.

    PS. I live in a dream world... And I have the same problems with Logic, Kontakt3, and Omnisphere. Even with 12 gigs of RAM... My fave is when Kontakt3 crashes with "low memory" warnings, and the Mac over-writes your preferences files in some kind of last minute panic. (Back up your prefs kids!)

  4. 0

    Mark Isham

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Wait, does it really? So after a crash preferences can be assumed to be corrupt?

    timkertoy wrote:

    My fave is when Kontakt3 crashes with "low memory" warnings, and the Mac over-writes your preferences files in some kind of last minute panic. (Back up your prefs kids!)

  5. 0

    Pancenter

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Mark Isham wrote:

    I am using RMX multis, Omnisphere multis, and Kontakt 3 multis. Am I asking too much? Am I crazy to think that being Mr. 8-core 8 gigs of RAM is supposed to give me MORE power and MORE abilities? Or am I right back where I was with my old dual G5?

    Mark,

    It sounds like you're running up against Logic's memory limits... I don't really think it's a leak as much as "ceiling", above which Logic becomes unstable. I forget the exact number but it's under 4Gigs. From looking at your VI's I can say you're pushing that limit. It's probably Kontakt causing most of the problems as I think it grabs a big chunk of memory to work with upon opening.

    Running Kontakt as a standalone let's Kontakt use a separate chunk of memory outside of Logic's mspace but I don't know if this allows an audio bounce of it's outputs.

    pancenter-

  6. 0

    antonyxx

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I also Have an 8 brain with stacks of RAM and use both Omnisphere and Kontakt amongst other instruments.

    Recently I signed up for the Kontakt 3.5 public beta which loads samples outside of Logic, and have been able to use many more samples within Logic, which has been a joy.

    You can join up here:


    http://www.native-instruments.com/forum/showthread.php?t=84470

    Omnisphere does seem to use a lot of RAM per patch and frequently takes me up to the 4 gig Virtual memory limit which causes Logic to crash (as do most instruments except Logic's own and now Kontakt) but I am sure future updates will solve this.

    I recently started using East West Gypsy and RA (Play versions) and these also seem to have a very low memory footprint as well as being highly stable and sounding awesome.

    When I purchased this machine I was dismayed at how the CPU could handle anything I threw at it but the same memory limits still stood in place as on my old G5. The recent advances (with Kontakt and Play) have been a new lease of life - I don't fancy trying a new Snow Chicken operating system with 139 items in my components folder and a load of flawlessly functioning drivers.

    As a rule I keep Activity Monitor open and watch Logic's virtual memory creeping up, saving frequently as it approaches 3.9 GB then reload the project before the crunch. Usually the VM usage is smaller on reload.

    Things are on the up I feel...

  7. 0

    Bee Jay

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Wait, does it really? So after a crash preferences can be assumed to be corrupt?

    It's possible, but it doesn't mean it will always happen. (Logic always writes out prefs when it exits, and if a crash causes an abnormal exit, it's possible the prefs can get garbled.)

    It's a good idea to store backups of your pref files, especially if they contain stuff that's not easily retrievable (like a load of custom controller assignments, for example).

    There's even a little applescript utility floating around that will backup your pref files for you (I think it was done by John Pitcairn from OpusLocus iirc).

  8. 0

    Bee Jay

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yep. They are all fairly heavy footprint plugins, especially on the RAM.

    The proper solution is to get OSX and Logic to be able to access the RAM you can actually put in a modern machine. Until then, we hang in there (as we have been doing since these type of sessions became possible, lets say the past three or four years).

  9. 0

    Mark Isham

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    This is quite brilliant Antonyxx. I am downloading the 3.5 beta now. Hopefully they are headed in this direction...

    I am going to try the activity monitor thing as well. I think I've just hit the ceiling and need to cool my jets with all of these plugins loaded up.

    Well, back to using the G4 Plugin Host running Raxx in the closet along with the orchestral PCs...

    Darn...when will "in the box" truly happen?

    It's the carrot we all seem to chase...

    m

    antonyxx wrote:

    I also Have an 8 brain with stacks of RAM and use both Omnisphere and Kontakt amongst other instruments.

    Recently I signed up for the Kontakt 3.5 public beta which loads samples outside of Logic, and have been able to use many more samples within Logic, which has been a joy.

    You can join up here:


    http://www.native-instruments.com/forum/showthread.php?t=84470

    Omnisphere does seem to use a lot of RAM per patch and frequently takes me up to the 4 gig Virtual memory limit which causes Logic to crash (as do most instruments except Logic's own and now Kontakt) but I am sure future updates will solve this.

    I recently started using East West Gypsy and RA (Play versions) and these also seem to have a very low memory footprint as well as being highly stable and sounding awesome.

    When I purchased this machine I was dismayed at how the CPU could handle anything I threw at it but the same memory limits still stood in place as on my old G5. The recent advances (with Kontakt and Play) have been a new lease of life - I don't fancy trying a new Snow Chicken operating system with 139 items in my components folder and a load of flawlessly functioning drivers.

    As a rule I keep Activity Monitor open and watch Logic's virtual memory creeping up, saving frequently as it approaches 3.9 GB then reload the project before the crunch. Usually the VM usage is smaller on reload.

    Things are on the up I feel...

  10. 0

    Curtis Marolt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    antonyxx,

    I had a heck of a time with Logic 8.0.2, Kontakt 3 and Play giving me CPU overload errors on my 8 core machine at pretty low instrument loads. It forced me to try Logic 7.2.3 again and now it performs well.

    Were you only experiencing RAM issues or did you also have CPU issues as well? I've seen some people that have had the same issues as me and then others who's systems seem to be fine.

    Thanks in advance.

    Curtis

  11. 0

    antonyxx

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Sorry been out on a little Friday night razzle.

    Mark,

    I hope you has the same feeling of wonder that I had when loading a seemingly unlimited volume of samples into Logic.

    Curtis,

    My machine is the early 2008 2.8 ghz dual quad core with 10GB RAM (upgraded by Crucial UK).

    Kontakt 3 has never given me CPU issues (I have always unticked Multiprocessor support) but I had suffered from Virtual memory overloads/Logic crashes often, prior to downloading v3.5 Public Beta.

    The only CPU/overload issues I experienced on this machine were when I used an external Lacie Little Big Disk Firewire 800 drive for audio files, which caused frequent audio overload messages. After transferring all files to an internal SATA drive the overloads were gone.

    I have only used Play for a week which was immediately updated to version 1.2.5 and it has worked flawlessly so far (deep breath).

    I have one internal SATA for Audio, one for BFD and one for pianos, including Ivory. The remaining Samples are on the external FW800 drive that was incompatible with Logic for audio use.

    Antony

    http://itunes.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewAlbum?id=309524086&s=14344 4

  12. 0

    Curtis Marolt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    antonyxx,

    Thanks for the info. I too have the early model 8-core. All 4 of my drives are internal. Maybe I should try some externals and see if that helps.

    Thanks again for the tips.

    Curtis

  13. 0

    antonyxx

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Curtis,

    From my experience I would stick with internals is possible - I use the external FW as a mobile drive for the laptop sometimes.

    I also use a program called iDefrag to keep the drives running well.

    Antony

  14. 0

    Pancenter

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    antonyxx wrote:

    Curtis,

    From my experience I would stick with internals is possible - I use the external FW as a mobile drive for the laptop sometimes.

    I also use a program called iDefrag to keep the drives running well.

    Antony

    I use iDefrag as well. There is a caution though.. Logic does not handle long filenames well, either for project files or audio files, the danger being that your project loses track of it's audio files and each has to be loaded manually.

    pancenter-

  15. 0

    Marty Frasu

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    It's true about the memory leak. If you open and close a bunch of Logic projects that use samples, Logic doesn't always give back the memory. If you open the Activity Monitor, you can see this in action.

    I have been either quit Logic and/or restarted the computer If I have been opening and closing Logic Projects that use a lot of Sampler memory.

    I'm hoping that Snow Leopard and 64 bit applications and plug ins will allow me to load large amounts of samples.