Benches macOS

9

Mac on NTFS or Windows on HFS+ What is better?

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hi Folks,

My network is composed of Macs and Windows. So far my external drives are FAT32 formatted. Since it is a very old system I have been contemplating formating them all to either NTFS of HFS+. I am aware of incompatibility but I found out that Mac can read and write NTFS with the software called NTFS for Mac® by Paragon. Equaly, Windows machines can read and write HFS+ with MacDrive 7 by Mediafour.

What would be better option to have? All my Macs reading and writing NTFS or all my Windows machines reading and writing HFS+?

Many thanks

Alex

9 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Kurt Lang

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    My personal opinion would be to format all external drives for HFS+. Macs use two disk resources (forks) for each file. It would be better for the Mac to be able to write its slightly more complicated file structure natively.

  2. 0

    Kenneth Hjulstrom

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi,

    I seem to recall that OS X cannot write to NTFS-formatted volumes without the addition of a third-party addon (beta, the last time I checked) that can allow writing. And Windows can't natively read or write to HFS+-formatted volumes without the use of third-party software (such as MacDrive, which you mentioned). For external drives that I want to be readable and writable by both Windows and OS X systems, I format them as FAT32. Of course, if you aren't connecting the drives directly to the incompatible OS, then you can format them either as HFS+ (if you are going to leave the drive connected to a Mac) or as NTFS (if you are going to leave the drive connected to a Windows machine). I this case, you can set up the host machine to share the drive, and the host OS will mediate the format differences as the files are moved between platforms over the network.

    Ken

  3. 0

    V.K.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    there is also MacFuse and NTFS-3g.

    http://macntfs-3g.blogspot.com/

    They also make NTFS drives writable from OS X but unlike Paragon are free. I haven't tried either Paragon or Mac Drive but i did try NTFS-3g and it worked fine. Still I agree with Kurt that it would be much better for the mac side to have the drive formatted HFS+.

  4. 0

    a brody

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The best way is to keep everything running on their own native format.

    First off, you start using non-native formats, documents may not launch correctly in the operating system, and so might applications as well.

    Making a bootable backup with anything other than a native format for the drive is impossible. As long as the files are readable across the network, that usually is the best that can be hoped for it.

    One thing to consider, if you have Macs running Virtualization that can share the Mac formatted drive/partition, that can then be networked over to the Windows machine probably easier than trying to go over something like SMB.

    See my FAQ* on virtualization:

    http://www.macmaps.com/macosxnative.html#WINTEL

    - * Links to my pages may give me compensation.

  5. 0

    Camelot

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Firstly, this is only an issue if you're physically reconnecting external drives between platforms. If any given external drive is only used on one platform, then format it for that platform.

    Secondly, if they are being shared, which do you have more of? Windows machines or Macs?

    If you have more Macs, format as HFS+ and install the HFS+ software on the Windows machines.

    If you have more Windows machines, format them as NTFS and install NTFS software on the Macs.

    That way the majority of the machines get to use their native format and you have fewer software installs to run (and maintain).

  6. 0

    KJK555

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hello dizara, the safest and most reliable way is sharing files with Mac NTFS support using the

    latest edition of Paragon NTFS (6.5.1).

    Ntfs-3g may cause problems if you run other programs that use Mac Fuse at the same time that

    Ntfs-3g is using it (such as parallels desktop). Ntfs-3g is still beta software though, perhaps a

    stable version isn't far off from now, but as of right now, it may or may not work reliably for you.

    Media Four's Mac Drive is not 100% reliable and stable unless used in read only mode. In read/write

    mode I have had corrupt file problems and blue screen of death problems with Mac Drive running

    in read/write mode. Running in read only mode has been trouble free.

    If reliability is most important to you, following the above guidelines will keep your cross platform

    experience a pleasant one.

    Kj

  7. 0

    dizara

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi everybody, and thank you very much for your kind suggestions. They are most helpful.

    I have a couple of clarifications. The external drives are almost all NAS ones.

    1) Now, does this still count as direct connection to my Macs and Windows considering the fact that the HDs are not really in direct USB connection with each and every prospective host computer?

    2) Currently I use SMB protocol with my NAS drives rather than AFP because of compatibility issues. If I format all my NAS drives to HFS+ what protocol do I have to use then SMB of AFP? Or it does not matter really?

    Thank you

    Alex

  8. 0

    KJK555

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Files accessed on a network (Lan or Wan) do not need any translation. as the network drivers

    translate them all to the same protocol in order to move them across the network.

    Your NAS network storage device specs will dictate which drive formats is are allowed for use with

    its internal disk drive(s).

    File system translation is only required for drives connected directly to usb, firewire, sata, ide, scsi

    or other direct hardware interface connections.

    Kj

  9. 0

    dizara

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thank you Kj, that's exactly what I thought re NAS storage. As for my directly connected USB HDs that should be swapable btw, perhaps the best thing would be to format them with NTFS. That way even some other people's Macs without NTFS software can still read it at least, while my own Macs could also write using the Paragon software.

    Alex