Benches macOS

5

Erase & Install vs. Automatic Installation ...

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

We have a MacMini running OS 10.4.11 and want to install Snow Leopard on it. One reason, among many, is that we want to run the newest version of Mac Dictate - v.1.5.8. We're concerned about different information we have received on which form of installation we need to make, and I know the installer options for Snow Leopard have changed from previous OSes. I'm not sure whether we can do an "Automatic" installation, or whether we have to do an "Erase & Install." Here's the conflicting information I've read or received, and I need some guidance on which is the best to follow.

Pogue in his "Missing Manual Snow Leopard" makes very clear that the new, improved and much smarter installer makes it so that there's "no longer any need for the classic "clean install"... every installation is, in effect, a clean install." He says that Snow Leopard can turn any OS X version 10.0 through 10.5-point-anything into version 10.6. He says, there are of course incompatible programs in the Applications folder, for which its one's job to check to make sure they've all been updated to 10.6-compatible versions.

However, the MacSpeech Mac Dictate people say, "if you are currently running 10.4.11 you will not be able to "upgrade" your operating system, you will have to do a clean install of Snow Leopard which will require your programs be reinstalled. For more information on Snow Leopard system requirements please contact Apple."

This seems to be in direct conflict with Pogue's information, which I have found to be extremely reliable - my go to source almost equal to the Apple discussion forums if I have a problem. But, Mac Dictate has a history of quirks. Is it possible that if I did an "automatic" install, the one program Mac Dictate could cause problems, or, not allow me to upgrade/install the new version of Mac Dictate?

Any help on this one? I'd like to do an automatic install and be able to utilize this improvement Apple made with the new OS, an easier installation process.

Thanks.

5 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Although you can install Snow Leopard over Tiger, it's not recommended. It would be much better to erase the drive and install Snow Leopard freshly. This will provide for a more stable installation. The reason is that some components of Tiger will remain after Snow Leopard is installed which is not desirable.

    This is not a problem when upgrading from Leopard nor when reinstalling Snow Leopard. There is no contradiction, rather an unclear understanding of the Snow Leopard installer and the process of installing fresh versus upgrading from an earlier version of OS X.

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    How do you do a clean install from the new Snow Leopard install disk?

    I recently purchased Snow Leopard, but when I try and install it over 10.4.11 I can't even find the option to do an "Erase and Install" installation. Where did it go? The "customize" option only provides additional printer support, QuickTime 7 installation, etc. I would like to do a "clean" install but don't know how from my install disk.

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi tman84;

    With the release of Snow Leopard, Erase & Install was removed.

    If you feel the necessity to do an Erase & Install, then you must use Disk Utility on the SL DVD to erase the disk followed by an install.

    Personally I consider an Erase & Install a waste of time when it comes to upgrades.

    Allan
    tiger

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks Allan. What about the possibility of older OS components that remain. Is there a chance that these components can cause issues with the new OS. I am making the jump from 10.4.11 to 10.6.3; any known issues without first erasing the drive and then doing a fresh install?

    Thom

  5. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    What about the possibility of older OS components that remain.

    FWIW, I have never seen any credible evidence that this actually occurs. It seems to be a theory meant to explain some problems some users have after upgrading, but usually there are other reasons that could explain the same behavior that haven't been ruled out. AFAIK, it is kind of a "maybe/just in case" thing that justifies to some the "nuclear" solution of an erase & install to get rid of vaguely defined problems, including some unspecified 'left over' OS components that nobody seems able to identify.

    Personally, I agree with Pogue & with several other users that post here frequently that consider an erase an unnecessary waste of time, except for a few very specific issues like a file system so corrupted that Disk Utility can't repair it or a HD not formatted with the GUID partition scheme.

    If it were me & some company like the supplier of MacSpeech said "if you are currently running 10.4.11 you will not be able to 'upgrade' your operating system," I would at the very least ask specifically what they meant by that & why the scare quotes around the work "upgrade." This doesn't seem to have anything to do with the application itself or with installing it -- there is no mention I can find of this in any installation or upgrade instructions at the MacSpeech web site.