Benches macOS

11

Is VNC always "balky"?

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I have the Vine server installed on my Mac Mini and Chicken of the VNC on my Mac Pro. It works fine but the virtual desktop is anything but smooth. When dragging windows for example, the image shreds and there is a delay of several seconds with most operations. Is this "typical" of VNC connections? Both computers are connected to a router via ethernet so it can't be "slow" wireless! Also, I can't seem to get a connection using only the screen sharing setting. As I understand it, I should not even need Vine to make that work.

User uploaded file

11 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    BobHarris

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The answer is "It Depends".

    The server, the client, the size of the screen, the number of colors being displayed (256, thousands, millions), the network between the 2, the CPU power of the server system, the CPU power of the client system.

    I have found that using the Vine Server and Chicken of the VNC with 8-bit color (256 colors) across the internet with the server having only 768kilobits/second upload speed, to be acceptable (beats driving 300 miles to Mom's house 🙂 ).

    I get my best performance using the build-in Mac OS X server with the build-in Mac OS X client, even with larger screens (such as my 27" iMac at work).

    However, mixing a 3rd party client or server with a built-in Mac OS X VNC componet, has generally not been all the successful. The one notable exception has been JollysFastVNC (shareware).

    I have the Vine server installed on my Mac Mini and Chicken of the VNC on my Mac Pro. It works fine but the virtual desktop is anything but smooth. When dragging windows for example, the image shreds and there is a delay of several seconds with most operations. Is this "typical" of VNC connections? Both computers are connected to a router via ethernet so it can't be "slow" wireless!

    I would not expect it to take seconds. A slight lag on an ethernet connection, but not seconds.

    So do you have a good router?

    Good ethernet cables?

    Have you tried measuring your network performance by copying a very large file and timing it?

    Also, I can't seem to get a connection using only the screen sharing setting. As I understand it, I should not even need Vine to make that work.

    Assuming both your systems are Mac OS X 10.5 or 10.6, then no, you should not need either Vine Server nor Chicken of the VNC.

    So how have you configured System Preferences -> Sharing -> Screen Sharing? Did you set anything via the "Computer Settings" button.

    How did you try to make a Screen Sharing connection? Did your other Mac show up in the side-bar of a Finder window, and you clicked on it? Did you try Finder -> Go -> Connect to Server -> vnc://otherMacsSharingName.local? Something else?

  2. 0

    musicwind95

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Connecting using VNC to my PC box over a wireless (802.11n) network, I see a bit of shredding/shearing and a slight lag, but nothing that's really bad. It could be the program.

    I'd just use screen sharing:

    1. Make sure both computers are on the same network.

    2. Determine the IP address of the computer you +want to connect to+ (System Preferences > Network, and find a number that looks like 192.168.1.x).

    3. Open Finder

    4. Press Command-K

    5. Enter
    vnc://IPADDRESS, where IPADDRESS is the IP address that you determined in step two

    6. Click Connect. Screen sharing will automatically load. You may or may not have to enter credentials.

  3. 0

    BobHarris

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The answer is "It Depends".

    The server, the client, the size of the screen, the number of colors being displayed (256, thousands, millions), the network between the 2, the CPU power of the server system, the CPU power of the client system.

    I have found that using the Vine Server and Chicken of the VNC with 8-bit color (256 colors) across the internet with the server having only 768kilobits/second upload speed, to be acceptable (beats driving 300 miles to Mom's house 🙂 ).

    I get my best performance using the build-in Mac OS X server with the build-in Mac OS X client, even with larger screens (such as my 27" iMac at work).

    However, mixing a 3rd party client or server with a built-in Mac OS X VNC componet, has generally not been all the successful. The one notable exception has been JollysFastVNC (shareware).

    I have the Vine server installed on my Mac Mini and Chicken of the VNC on my Mac Pro. It works fine but the virtual desktop is anything but smooth. When dragging windows for example, the image shreds and there is a delay of several seconds with most operations. Is this "typical" of VNC connections? Both computers are connected to a router via ethernet so it can't be "slow" wireless!

    I would not expect it to take seconds. A slight lag on an ethernet connection, but not seconds.

    So do you have a good router?

    Good ethernet cables?

    Have you tried measuring your network performance by copying a very large file and timing it?

    Also, I can't seem to get a connection using only the screen sharing setting. As I understand it, I should not even need Vine to make that work.

    Assuming both your systems are Mac OS X 10.5 or 10.6, then no, you should not need either Vine Server nor Chicken of the VNC.

    So how have you configured System Preferences -> Sharing -> Screen Sharing? Did you set anything via the "Computer Settings" button.

    How did you try to make a Screen Sharing connection? Did your other Mac show up in the side-bar of a Finder window, and you clicked on it? Did you try Finder -> Go -> Connect to Server -> vnc://otherMacsSharingName.local? Something else?

  4. 0

    musicwind95

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Connecting using VNC to my PC box over a wireless (802.11n) network, I see a bit of shredding/shearing and a slight lag, but nothing that's really bad. It could be the program.

    I'd just use screen sharing:

    1. Make sure both computers are on the same network.

    2. Determine the IP address of the computer you +want to connect to+ (System Preferences > Network, and find a number that looks like 192.168.1.x).

    3. Open Finder

    4. Press Command-K

    5. Enter
    vnc://IPADDRESS, where IPADDRESS is the IP address that you determined in step two

    6. Click Connect. Screen sharing will automatically load. You may or may not have to enter credentials.

  5. 0

    Fortuny

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi David,

    I previously also used Chicken to connect to a Windows PC at the office and found its performance sometimes very bad.

    Have a look / tryout of JollysFastVNC
    http://www.macupdate.com/info.php/id/25731/jollysfastvnc

    Not freeware but shareware now, but to me worth trying.

    Regards

    Stefan

  6. 0

    David DeCristoforo

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    +"I'd just use screen sharing..."+

    Well, that's what I'm trying to do. But so far I can't seem to get my Mac Pro to connect to the Mini. I set a static LAN address on the Mini and it's seen in the finder but so far that's as far as I can get. Both machines are connected via ethernet (not wireless) through a Netgear FVS318 router. It may be the router that's gumming up the works. There's a newer firmware version available so I may try that and see what happens. The thing is, with the Vine server running on the Mini, Chicken connects with no issues. So it does not seen like the router is blocking anything. I also have iTeleport on my iPhone and that connects to the Mini (via wireless) with no issues as does the Logitech TouchMouse app.

    User uploaded file

  7. 0

    musicwind95

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Unless you have to use static, I'd use DHCP, and let the router handle it. The connection type shouldn't make a difference. I don't think router firmware would make that much of a difference, if any, either. Check your setup.

  8. 0

    BobHarris

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    If Vine Server is running on Mac mini port 5900 and you are also trying to run Mac OS X Screen Sharing that also uses port 5900, then you have a conflict for who controls port 5900.

    How have you configured System Preferences -> Sharing -> Screen Sharing?

    Did you ALSO setup Remote Management? If you did, you may be creating a conflict.

    How are you trying to connect to the Mac mini? And what errors or behavior do you see?

  9. 0

    David DeCristoforo

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    OK, that was the problem. Without Vine running, Screen sharing works fine. Also, I had set up the Mini without a password and Screen Sharing would not let me log in to it. So I had to set a password. But now it works fine and it's way smoother than using Vine and Chicken.

    Thanx

    User uploaded file

  10. 0

    David DeCristoforo

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    One more question... is there any way to get the Screen Sharing app to remember connections? It seems that every time I launch it I have to reenter the IP address. I don't see any way to get around that. Looked in the app's prefs and there is no option there either...

    User uploaded file

  11. 0

    David DeCristoforo

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    OK, never mind... I figured this one out. Connect to Server (vnc://myserver) from the finder launches the Screen Sharing app which, thankfully remembers the password...

    Thanx Again

    User uploaded file