Benches macOS

12

Time Machine says I need more space-so I …

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Long story short, all the sudden this message comes on my screen:

User uploaded file

Which is odd because the only thing I've done today with files is clean them up - meaning, I added very little, but deleted a lot to clean things up and (I thought) save space. After i'm all finished, a few hours later I get the above message saying I need 102 GB more of space on my external drive! Huh - I only added maybe 100MB to the computer and removed atleast 2 or 3GB of space, so why all the sudden do I need all of this extra space?

So I begin going though things AGAIN and cleaning up even more. I deleted about 5 -7 more gigs, so it would be enough to do the backup. So the next hour comes up and time machine starts calculating the changes and then bam, I get this:

User uploaded file

Now I need 215 GB of free space??? what is going on? I'm only DELETING files, (and yes I am emptying the trash, and I also restarted) and it keeps telling me I need MORE space when it has LESS to backup???

Looks like I'm going to have to format my external hard drive and just start over before the number of gigs I need doubles again, which is more space then I have on the computer or the hard drive to begin with!!!

Anyone know what is going on????

Thanks,

Scott

12 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    V.K.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    how big is your TM drive, how much space is used and how much data do you have on your main hard drive?

    also check in TM system preferences->options. It should list how much is currently included in the backups. also, do you have other hard drives attached? TM will back up all directly attached drives which are formatted mac os extended and are not on the TM exclusion list.

  2. 0

    sdschramm

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    It is a 320GB hard drive and there is apx 250GB or so of actual data on it.

    The point isn't that the drive is "full" - the point is, all I did was DELETE files, and now it trying to rebackup the whole system (which in that case, there is NOT enough space to do)

    For instance:

    3PM - If there is 250GB of data - all of which is already on the backup drive.

    I then delete 7GB of data, and add 1GB that is not backed up.

    4PM - Backup should see that 1GB of added, copy that to the HD, then report what was delted.

    What happened:

    4PM - Backup does not take place, says I need apx 3 more gigs of space.

    So I backup apx 5 gigs of space, which is enough for it to do the backup

    5PM - Now it says I need TWICE as much space to be able to do the backup....

  3. 0

    V.K.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    TM is quite a finicky and buggy program. such things can easily happen. you may have to reformat the TM drive and restart TM backups. but please answer all the questions. how much fee and used space you have on the TM drive and how much does it say is included in the backups in TM system preferences->options? also, verify both the TM drive and the startup drive with disk utility. verify disk, not permissions. if there are any errors run 'repair disk". to repair the startup drive you'll have to boot from the SL install dvd and use disk utility there.

  4. 0

    sdschramm

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Not really solved, but what I did was reformat the drive again, and started over.

    Haven't had any problems...yet.

  5. 0

    boomhaueruk

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'm having the same problems - so I'll take over the discussion, as reformatting my drive isn't helping - did that (and ran Onyx as well to clear the logs) it worked for 2 days and now, same problem.

    My internal hard drive (on a mac mini running 10.6) is 499.76Gb. Free space is 79.96.

    The external hard drive I've been running time machine on is 499.76GB, connected by USB. Currently has 90.74 Gb free.

    If I run Time machine it says I need 153.85Gb to do a backup.

    Deleting files just means this figure gets bigger.

    Under preferences, options 409.02 is written next to the external drive and 'estimated size of full backup' is 414.43Gb.

    No idea why it needs 153.85Gb. Suggestions?

  6. 0

    Pondini

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    boomhaueruk wrote:

    I'm having the same problems - so I'll take over the discussion

    That's usually not a good idea, especially one that's marked "solved" as most folks won't bother to look, and after 30 days, emails won't be sent to those who responded initially.

    My internal hard drive (on a mac mini running 10.6) is 499.76Gb. Free space is 79.96.

    The external hard drive I've been running time machine on is 499.76GB, connected by USB. Currently has 90.74 Gb free.

    That's too small. Time Machine usually needs at least twice the space of the data it's backing-up; you're backing up about 420 GB to a 500 GB drive. See #1 in the
    Frequently Asked Questions *User Tip,* also at the top of this forum.

    Under preferences, options 409.02 is written next to the external drive and 'estimated size of full backup' is 414.43Gb.

    No idea why it needs 153.85Gb. Suggestions?

    That means it's trying to back up about 128 GB (it adds 20% for workspace, as mentioned in the message).

    Most likely, you're running a feature or app that causes huge backups (my guess would be virtualization software); see #9 in the
    FAQ Tip. It lists some of the common culprits.

  7. 0

    boomhaueruk

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Pondini,

    Thanks for the advice.

    "That's too small. Time Machine usually needs at least twice the space of the data it's backing-up; you're backing up about 420 GB to a 500 GB drive."

    Well, that's annoying (the fact it needs so much space, I mean). It's been working beautifully from 350gb (when I set this up) to 420, but has suddenly jumped how much space it needs to 128gb for some reason.

    I need an unpowered external drive too, which limits me to 500gb, (pretty much unless I want to spend a fortune) and from what you're saying I need a 1tb drive to backup 500gb - it needs to be small form factor. Why does it need so much space? Any idea?

    I'm not running anything apart from Itunes, front row and VLC. The Mp3 library is big (about 396gb now), but it always has been quite sizeable, and it's not growing very fast, about a gig or two a month.

    Does seem odd it needs that much space.

    Thinking about it I could go back to using Carbon Copy Cloner - which I used before time machine was around. Just seems a bit lame it needs so much space...and it does seem to be a problem time machine develops too, from what I'm reading around the place.

    Message was edited by: boomhaueruk

  8. 0

    Pondini

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    boomhaueruk wrote:

    . . .

    Well, that's annoying (the fact it needs so much space, I mean). It's been working beautifully from 350gb (when I set this up) to 420, but has suddenly jumped how much space it needs to 128gb for some reason.

    Apparently, something you've added or changed lately.

    I need an unpowered external drive too

    Why?

    from what you're saying I need a 1tb drive to backup 500gb - it needs to be small form factor. Why does it need so much space? Any idea?

    It keeps previous copies of things you've changed. If you change a 1 GB file, the new version will be backed-up. If you rename or move a large folder, it will be backed-up again completely (all sub-folders and files).

    Does seem odd it needs that much space.

    If you want "archived" backups (previous copies of things that have been changed or deleted), that requires space.

    Thinking about it I could go back to using Carbon Copy Cloner - which I used before time machine was around. Just seems a bit lame it needs so much space...and it does seem to be a problem time machine develops too, from what I'm reading around the place.

    Not in most cases. If you have a large enough drive, and avoid things like virtualization software, and the other types of things listed in #9 of the
    FAQ Tip.

    You may get a clue by using +Time Tracker+ or +Backup Loupe,+ as in #8 of the
    FAQ. It won't show you what TM was trying to back up on the backup that failed, but if you look at recent completed backups, you may see something.

  9. 0

    boomhaueruk

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Pondini,

    "Apparently, something you've added or changed lately."

    Well, that's just it. I formatted the external drive and started again, after this problem occurred a couple of days ago out of the blue. I had to run Onyx scripts to clear out the logs (or whatever they are - if it's a network drive I think it's sparsebundle) for Time Machine, but T.M. then backed up and worked for 2/3 days and then jumped the size it needed to this large amount.

    Haven't added anything!

    "I need an unpowered drive/why"

    Simply put - power sockets and (less directly) space! This is for a media centre mac mini and I need a little hard drive running next to it doing the backup that fits in the shelf in the cabinet. Got 6 plug sockets available - all full.

    I've got a little Iomega 500gb external, which has run beautifully for quite a while.

    "...and it does seem to be a problem time machine develops too, from what I'm reading around the place." "Not in most cases..."

    Well, that's not the impression I got from;

    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1639272

    http://discussions.info.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2129144&tstart=1

    http://forums.dealmac.com/read.php?4,2778860

    http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13727_7-10330105-263.html

    http://newsgroups.derkeiler.com/Archive/Comp/comp.sys.mac.system/2008-03/msg0146 5.html

    and a lot of others I found. Quite a lot related to network attached stores, but certainly not all.

    "...Time Tracker or Backup Loupe,"

    Well, this is interesting, didn't know you could look at T.M. logs or anything. I tell you what I'll do, I'll format the drive again, run Onyx again and start off with a fresh backup in time machine again. Hopefully that'll get me going once more. Then, once I hit the wall (if I hit the wall!) I'll post my results from those apps...

    If not, I'll drop back to just incremental backups on CCC.

    Thanks.

    Message was edited by: boomhaueruk

    Message was edited by: boomhaueruk

  10. 0

    boomhaueruk

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Curiouser and curiouser.

    Restarting time machine now says I need 504.34 Gb. Which is odd. I've formatted the 500Gb external drive and estimated size of full backup is 420.87Gb.

  11. 0

    Pondini

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    boomhaueruk wrote:

    . . .

    and a lot of others I found. Quite a lot related to network attached stores, but certainly not all.

    Most of those were new drives, new logic boards, or disk too small. And a few folks will
    always have problems. You can find a few such posts about any software. The majority of threads here have resolutions (most others probably do, too, but many posters never post back with "it worked," unfortunately).

    Well, this is interesting, didn't know you could look at T.M. logs or anything. I tell you what I'll do, I'll format the drive again, run Onyx again

    I use OnyX, but it's not going to make much difference here. Time Machine automatically excludes most logs and caches, plus trash, etc. See #11 in the
    Frequently Asked Questions *User Tip,* also at the top of this forum.

    And speaking of logs,
    Click here to download the +Time Machine Buddy+ widget. It shows the messages from your logs for one TM backup run at a time, in a small window.

    Restarting time machine now says I need 504.34 Gb. Which is odd. I've formatted the 500Gb external drive and estimated size of full backup is 420.87Gb.

    That's what you posted earlier. But remember, Time Machine will add 20% to that, for workspace, so there's not enough room.

    Short term, you can "squeeze" a backup onto that disk, by temporarily excluding enough, so the estimate is below about 415 GB. Once that's all backed-up, remove the exclusion, and the rest will fit (since 20% of the smaller backup won't be so huge).

    But it will fill up rapidly, the more you add or change, so it's not going to suffice for long.

    Long-term, you need
    much more space to use Time Machine.

  12. 0

    boomhaueruk

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Pondini.

    Well, I restarted and Time Machine is backing up now. Don't know why it suddenly decided it was ok.

    RE Onyx - Switching time machine off, formatting the hard drive and starting it again doesn't work.

    Switching time machine off, formatting the hard drive, running Onyxes clearing of all system scripts and caches, then turning it on does.

    Don't know why either.

    I've got the buddy widget. Doesn't say much of interest.

    But, anyway, I think there is some sort of irregularity or fault in Time Machine that suddenly decides the backup is massive. I know what you say about the software, but, in all seriousness there are hundreds of those posts around, they're not hard to find. Don't believe in coincidences. But it's free, built in software, I'm not grumbling.

    Either way, I take your main point; Time Machine is built to do a specific kind of 'work in progress' snapshot of an os and it's apps, hence the 20% extra h/d required, that's not what I need really and I've hit a wall.

    I'll trot off to CCC and do incremental backups.

    Thanks ever so much for the help.