11 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Barney-15E ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
When you log in, your keychain will not be unlocked automatically.
You should also set it to lock after some time period, though, or you don't really improve things over having the same password.If someone gets hold of your computer and tries to change the login password with an install disk, your keychain password will remain the old password, so they will not have access to your private passwords and data.
So, you should combine that with not auto-logging in, keep a timeout on your keychain, and don't select the option to "Always Allow" when viewing your own passwords.
- 0
V.K. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
NewYorkYogi wrote:
I've gotten mixed feedback on this: What additional security, if any, is obtained by making your keychain password different from your login password?none. what can make it more secure is if you uncheck some standard options that Barney mentioned like unlocking your keychain on login and check the box to lock the keychain after a certain period. then having the keychain password the same as login password will be just as good as having a different password.
- 0
neutron ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Probably true for most people. But, just to play devil's advocate: if someone were to gain access to your login password, they wouldn't be able to get your keychain as well if the two passwords were different.
ddr
- 0
V.K. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
sure but how does one get access to your login password. there is *absolutely no way* to do that unless you have it written down somewhere or tell it to someone. but then you can have your keychain access password written down somewhere too. so there is no security gained by this at all.
- 0
NewYorkYogi ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
V.K., my thinking is as yours, yet I have them as different because I read it on some site somewhere.
If they are the same and someone uses a startup disk to change my login password, then the keychain password still is the old one, so they still need to get that one, too... and I wonder if the post I read was by someone well intentioned but confused.
I also have implemented the suggestions made here, which basically means that when I log in, I have to enter two passwords; after that, I'm in the same boat.
So, it seems that while little is gained, there is also little convenience lost, since I remain logged in for weeks.
Ya?
Message was edited by: NewYorkYogi
- 0
neutron ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm not saying it's probable. I'm saying it's
possible.Example: Someone looks over your shoulder as you type. Or you use your login password for something else (a website, perhaps), and that something else leaks it/loses it.
Perhaps in 99% of scenarios it wouldn't make a difference. But for the ultra-secure computer user, it's one more layer to have separate login/keychain passwords.
ddr
- 0
NewYorkYogi ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
neutron, it is sort of like the RSA argument in reverse; if you have a secure way to communicate a password to someone, then why don't you just use that way to communicate your data?
If my shoulder is not secure, I can't increase security by adding things to look at over it.
- 0
V.K. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
neutron wrote:
I'm not saying it's probable. I'm saying it's
possible.Example: Someone looks over your shoulder as you type. Or you use your login password for something else (a website, perhaps), and that something else leaks it/loses it.
ok, for something like this yes, you are right.
Perhaps in 99% of scenarios it wouldn't make a difference. But for the ultra-secure computer user, it's one more layer to have separate login/keychain passwords.
ddr
- 0
neutron ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I concede that if:
- any shoulder-lookers/keyloggers have equal access to the login and keychain passwords
- the login password isn't being used for anything else
- the login password isn't being stored in some other insecure location (maybe in a script for use in a sudo command)
- you're not using ftp/some other protocol w/insecure logins to connect to that computer and get datathen there is no reason to have separate login and keychain passwords.
But what I'm saying is that there are lots of little things (like those I mentioned above) that can be security holes that one simply doesn't think about. A user who is truly concerned about security may wish to simply have two separate passwords, thereby avoiding many (not all) potential insecurities.
ddr
- 0
V.K. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
neutron does have a general point (not specific to keychain password) that it's generally a good idea to keep your various passwords different. if you keep many passwords the same and any one of them gets exposed somehow (by somebody looking over your shoulder, hacking your mail account etc) then all of them are exposed.
- 0
NewYorkYogi ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
OK, I see your point. What started all of this (i.e., me) was a website article from a well intentioned by misinformed individual that thought (apparently w/o testing) that since you can use a DVD to change your login password, if they were the same, you would also gain access to the keychain, which is flat out not true and never was true.