Benches macOS

6

Extremely slow samba speeds

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

When transferring files between my macbook pro and my windows file server (Windows Storage Server 2008) though samba, I get roughly 2MB/s transfer rate when reading from the share. From Windows 7, I get around 70-100MB/s.

Although my macbook is transferring the data through Wifi (Wireless N), it still takes 2 minutes to transfer a 130MB file. Although I cannot test at the moment, the speed does not get much better when I am wired in. (gigabit cable, gigabit router, and gigabit NIC on the file server)

This also causes videos played with VLC off of the file share to be extremely laggy and in most cases, it will crash VLC.

Is there any tips on how I can resolve this?

Thanks in advance.

6 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    moseman

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    IMHO, 10.6.2 is broken with respect to smb. I having been having other smb issues and a call to support just got me a "wait for next service update and see if that fixes things". I am not one to read much into things but this sure sounds like Apple knows of an issue and is working on a fix.

  2. 0

    donv_the_ghost

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Josh Mackey wrote:

    When transferring files between my macbook pro and my windows file server (Windows Storage Server 2008) though samba, I get roughly 2MB/s transfer rate when reading from the share. From Windows 7, I get around 70-100MB/s.

    Although my macbook is transferring the data through Wifi (Wireless N), it still takes 2 minutes to transfer a 130MB file. Although I cannot test at the moment, the speed does not get much better when I am wired in. (gigabit cable, >gigabit router, and gigabit NIC on the file server)

    To consider what you say, I did the following.

    Using my MBP (with both SL and Boot Camp/Win7 installed) (see sig) and Gigabit network , I:

    1. Transferred a 1.1 GB folder from the SL/MBP to a Vista/Gateway Desktop: Result = 38 sec or 232 Megabits per second (Mbps) = .232 (Gbps) = 29 Megabytes per sec (MBps). (Your result is about 1 MBps)

    2. Transferred the same folder back: Result = 28 sec or 314 Mbps = .314 Gbps = 39 MBps. (You appear to get 2 MBps.)

    3. Transferred a the same 1.1 GB folder from the Win7/MBP to Vista/Gateway Desktop: Result = 27 sec or 326 Mbps = .326 Gbps = 41 MBps. (As I read things, you get about 85 MBps.)

    4. Transferred the same folder back: Result = 69 sec or 128 Mbps = .128 Gbps = 16 MBps. (As I read things, you provide no info on your transfer back.)

    In summary, my results for 1 and 3 imply the superiority (41 / 29 = 1.41 times faster) of transferring from Win7 versus SL on the same machine/network. In contrast, my results for 2 and 4 imply the the superiority (39 / 16 = 2.44 times fastr) of transferring back to SL versus Win7 on the same machine/network. Since my results are in such sharp contrast, I can't draw any conclusions about SMB and SL.

  3. 0

    donv_the_ghost

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Addendum to Above:

    I attached a gigabit network adapter to my Win7/HP notebook and transferred the same 1.1 GB file to and from my Vista/Gateway (gigabit) desktop. The related data are:

    5. Transferred a 1.1 GB folder from the Win7/HP (gigabit) notebook to the Vista/Gateway (gigabit) Desktop: Result = 70 sec or 16 Megabytes per sec (MBps).

    6. Transferred the same folder back: Result = 76 sec or 14 MBps.

    Compare these results with, from above,

    1. Transferred a 1.1 GB folder from the SL/MBP (gigabit) to the Vista/Gateway (gigabit) Desktop: Result = 38 sec or 29 MBps.

    2. Transferred the same folder back: Result = 28 sec or 39 MBps.

    Given these results, my anecdotal evidence suggests that Snow is handling SMB data transfers better than Windows is handling the same data transfers. Note, however that my MBP is a generally stronger performer than my HP notebook. Still, the HP is a credible performer.

  4. 0

    Josh Mackey

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The complete opposite of what I get....

    Hmm....

    What do you get if you transfer from the MBP to Vista over wireless?

    (I should add, the file server im transferring to is in a Active Directory domain. The MBP remains out of it, but I can connect file (albeit, rather slowly).)

  5. 0

    donv_the_ghost

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Josh Mackey wrote:

    What do you get if you transfer from the MBP to Vista over wireless?

    Check my last post on [this thread|http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2256387&tstart=0]. On it, I report on transferring from my Win7 N HP Notebook to my SL N MBP. But, the results were very similar transferring the other direction.

  6. 0

    LaurenceMadill

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'm noticing the same thing, it seems to be a widespread problem with no solution as yet? Does anyone have an update? I have done software update as my laptop has prompted me and it is fully up to date. Im using Macbook Pro 2.8GHz Core 2 Duo, 4GB Ram, 7200RPM hard disk, 10.6.2. Various Windows computers I connect to are MS SBS 2000 or Windows XP